yea. I have been there done that with a TDI.
$1K in maintenance every 10k miles like clockwork.
I even justified it the same way, "my carpayment is X, I drive Y, the difference is Z, this car doesnt cost me anything it saves me so much money!" then the clutch goes out.
then the rear axle bends.
then you find out you "really" do need a steel oil pan skid plate, not that plastic bubble wrap crap from the factory.
then waterpump/timing belt.
head light went out, well **** you have to take the whole front bumper apart to change that, better hope you dont accidentally deploy the air bag doing that.
the ONLY nice thing about my TDI was the time my fuel pump went out and I found it that you didnt have to drop the tank, you pull the rear seat, unscrew a little door, and bam. fuel pump is right there under a little screw cap. but I didnt get the exact right fuel pump, (there were 3 offered that year) so I always had a CEL light and my mileage dropped 1mpg because the pressure or some German BS wasnt exactly right.
Dunno man. We bought my wife's with 11k on the clock, and she's got close to 70 now on regularly scheduled maintenance which has been like clockwork. I bought my golf with 62k on it, got 70k now, no hiccups. A lot of that sounds like abnormal wear and tear. I've never had a car that I've ever bent an axle, burned up a clutch, or dented an oil pan.
How did you come up with the .41 per mile on the cruiser?
Edit: just did the math on my 80, and if I gave it away tomorrow for free it has only had an operating cost of .43 per mile.
Can't find my original spreadsheet, but some quick math (I hadn't figured depreciation into my initial calcs)
Item Mileage Interval Cost Per Mile Cost
Tires 50,000 $1,800.00 $0.04
Oil Change 5,000 $60.00 $0.01
Gas 13 $3.85 $0.30
Brakes 50,000 $1,500.00 $0.03
Depreciation 20,000 $2,500.00 $0.13
Cruiser Total $0.50
Tires 50,000 $450.00 $0.01
Oil Change 7,000 $100.00 $0.01
Gas 38 $4.00 $0.11
Brakes 75,000 $800.00 $0.01
Depreciation 69,000 $8,000.00 $0.12
Jetta Wagon Total $0.26
Tires 50,000 $450.00 $0.01
Oil Change 7,000 $100.00 $0.01
Gas 40 $4.00 $0.10
Brakes 75,000 $800.00 $0.01
Depreciation 8,000 $700.00 $0.09
Golf Total $0.22
At the federal reimbursement rate or $0.56/mi, I'm making $0.06/mi on the cruiser and $0.34/mi on the golf. Plus the savings on fuel that I'm driving for personal purposes... I'm still not sure how this shakes out to be "not worth it."