I just got done installing a Magnaflow wye pipe and cat, and second cat, with a Bosal muffler (RockAuto), Toyota seals, and hardware.
It was a long day of bolt-in. After I got it going, it sounded like I had a soup can full of marbles and I was really pissed until I saw the spot where the heat shield was hitting the catalytic converter while driving. At rest, there was 1/4" clearance, but during operation or sitting in gear, the engine would torque to the side enough that it would contact the shield. I bent the shield out of the way a bit and all is well!
Looks like you are in PA, so you don't need to worry about the CA emissions versions. I bought my wye and cats through O'Reilly for a couple reasons: One is that my son works there so I get a discount, second is that I could return it over and over and over until I got a correct Magnaflow unit. Out of the (3) that I have purchased, I have received the good version every time. ( I bought one as a "spare", and when I thought I had a cat plate issues, I bought another one to have ready in case the problem was not the heat shield.)
Also, as the suggestion of
@2fpower , I coated all of it with Hi-Heat (1000'F) clear coat paint prior to installing to help it all last longer.