Engine Diagnostic Assistance

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Feb 7, 2006
Threads
11
Messages
84
Location
Savannah, GA
I'm trying to figure out if my motor is at its end:crybaby: .

I compression tested the cylinders

8 (100) 7 (62) no change w/oil
6 (100) 5 (44) then (50 w/oil)
4 (108) 3 (112)
2 (120) 1 (60) no change w/oil

I didn't "warm" the motor before the compression check. Problem?

It's a 350 (V1219TMT)
Double hump heads
Flat pistons and HEI
Motor installed by PO -- Circa ~ <1991

No antifreeze in the oil and no oil in the antifreeze
It burns a little oil ~ 1 quart every 2 months -- DD

I'm thinking valves but i'm out of knowledge (only book smarts) when it comes to valves. I haven't taken the valve cover off yet to check anything....

How can you tell if the valves are FUBARed by looking at them?

I did blow a head gasket in 98' -- professionally replaced

Thoughts?:confused:

Cheers
 
If the numbers were marginal, I'd say warm it up and redo...but those are some pretty disparingly low numbers on 1,5, & 7. As far as the valves being burned, yep it is a good chance that is the situation going on in cyl 1,5,& 7. Taking the valve cover off won't show the burned valve issues, that is visible once you pull the heads and look at the valves and seats. But I would caution you against just rebuilding the top end. Your motor has been in there since ~@1991. Has it seen quite a few miles over the years ? If so, just rebuilding the heads will probably reveal cause and/or otherwise make conditions right for the rings to begin to let go...or by as the case may be. I'd say it's probably time to do a complete rebuild. Just my 02 gleaned from the info provided.
 
I don't have a proper leak down tester, but I take the schrader valve out of my compression tester and hook up the hose to my compressor so I can put air in my cylinders, roll the engine through to compression and then listen to the exhaust, intake, and oil pan to see if I can hear air coming out. Fortuantly, mine still holds pressure. YOU HAVE TO TAKE THE VALVE OUT though. other wise it'll hold air regardless.
 
More info for those who can help...

I did everything but the leak down test. Still the same comression in 1 5 & 7. Did notice a :censor: load of exhuast coming from my oil filler neck:doh: . Now I'm leaning towards bad exhaust valves.... and a new motor (which is inevitable). Gonna do the leak test before I get too froggy.

Any inputs would be appreciated!!

Cheers,
 
Exhaust coming out of the oil filler is not consistent with bad exhaust valves, but it is consistent with bad rings or a gasket leak or other leak into the crank case.

In order to properly interpret the leak down test, the cylinder has to be at TDC on the compression stroke.
 
I would definitly do some more trouble shooting before I gave up on that engine. You definely have a problem. The only thing is it doesn't really sound like it is the bottom end. No change with oil in and warm sound like it may be top end related. unless the rings are totally gone. Change your pcv valve see if that stops the exhust throough the oil filler. Also it very well could be the head gasket. Rebuilding the bottom end is expensive so I try everything before I go there. did you only repalce one head gasket or both 1, 5 and seven are on the same side so it sounds like it may be a head gasket to me. If you only did one side that may provide the answer.
 
I'm going to do a leak down test tomorrow and I'll have more then. I (had) both head gaskets repalced at the same time. I did notice a little bit of oil coming from the intake mounting bolts on 3 5 7.... 3 is my only good cylinder on that side as of now.

I went and looked at a Vortec 5.7 today out of a rolled 98 Silverado w/ 60k. The motor is still in the truck and seems to be in good shape. The guy said he'd give me from the shoud to the exhuasts... I'm seriously debating it!!

Thanks for the inputs...BTW if I do the Vortec, do you need a star to post pics and pass on knowledge. It'll be to a SM465 and stock 70 TC and I'd just thought I'd pass the poop.

Cheers,
 
Back
Top Bottom