Dual battery setup question

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Aug 8, 2015
Threads
61
Messages
778
Location
Somewhere
Hello,

I bought the cruiser with DieHard 31M and 34 batteries. They are connected together by the SurePower battery separator which connects both batteries if there is a charge on the main one. The problem I have is that the aux battery - 31M is not holding the charge as it should. I have probably deflated the battery too much as it was sitting for 4 months when I was doing the head gasket job. Now if I drive and see that the AUX battery is charged - after while it gets to 12.2v.

As this battery is discontinued what is the good alternative ? I would probably change also the primary battery.


The car is suppose to be camping rig with fridge, couple of water pumps and some led lights . There is no inverter installed. I am looking into some not so expensive alternatives like interstate, costco etc. If you guys could suggest me some good battery with the simmilar size of the 31m I would be very thankful .

Thanks,

Jorge
 
What about this combination:

Main battery:
http://www.summitracing.com/parts/isb-mtp-27f
Brand:Interstate Batteries
Manufacturer's Part Number:MTP-27F
Part Type:Batteries
Product Line:Interstate Mega-Tron Plus Automotive Batteries
Summit Racing Part Number:ISB-MTP-27F
UPC:721112753713
Battery Usage:Starting
BCI Group Number:27F
Volts:12 V
Battery Terminals:Top
Battery Type:Wet cell
Cranking Amps at 0 Degrees F:710 amps
Cranking Amps at 32 Degrees F:890 amps
Reserve Capacity:165 minutes
Length (in):12.060 in.
Width (in):6.810 in.
Height (in):8.870 in.
Weight:50.400 lbs.
Quantity:Sold individually.


In-Store Pickup:Choose In-store pick-up (OH, GA, NV) on our web site.
Aux battery:
Interstate Batteries Results Page - Battery replacement for various Interstate Batteries models
Interstate SRM-29
Product ID: SRM-29
Cranking Amps: 845
Cold Cranking Amps: 675
Voltage: 12
Termination: Common Code M
Weight (lbs): 59.7
Width (in): 6.75
Length (in): 13.00
Height (in): 10.00
ReserveCapacity-25: 210.00
WET/DRY: W
 
Went to Sears and got refund for the Diehard Platinum 31M. I need to get this sorted out as quick as possible.
 
Well I am little tight on the budget right now so cheaper better. I don't care if I will have to change the battery in one year.
 
Looking into Interstate 31M marine deep cycle AGM battery in combination with Megatron MTP-27F battery. Anybody running such setup ?
 
You may want to search and see if your separator is one of the ones that was subject to a recall. The info is out on the webbers somewhere. You may end up with a free replacement. Keep in mind that the separator just takes whatever juice is coming from the alternator through the primary battery. A deep cycle marine battery (agm or conventional) is not going to be happy getting blasted with 50-80 amps for several hours driven down the highway. They typically like 1/10th their rating, say 6-12 amps. Thats what our alts put out at idle or lower rpms. This is where those really slick solid state smart battery management units make a lot of sense. They only charge your aux battery at a lower amperage, to try to keep it in shape longer.

I currently run a pair of conventional walmart batteries, a group 27 starting battery, and a group 27 deep cycle marine/rv aux with a surepower 1315 separator. I've had to replace the batteries twice, but they were both under warranty at the time. I "try" to keep the circuit breaker disconnected between them,and occasionally use a charger on just the aux at 6-10 amps. I had a group 31 as an aux, and a group 29 as an aux, but I decided I'd give up 10-20 mins of reserve for less weight. I went the walmart route for two reasons. One, I was slated for a 2300 mile road trip/campin trip 2 days after I bought them the first time, and figured I could easily replace a dead battery (walmarts are only slightly less available than starbucks). If doin it over, a conventional starting battery, and an AGM battery with some flavor of smart charge controller between would be the way to go. Throw a small solar panel up on the roof, and you can manually disconnect your batteries almost all the time. The solar would supply enough juice to charge a deep cycle, and with the right controller, would never overcharge it.
 
You may want to search and see if your separator is one of the ones that was subject to a recall. The info is out on the webbers somewhere. You may end up with a free replacement. Keep in mind that the separator just takes whatever juice is coming from the alternator through the primary battery. A deep cycle marine battery (agm or conventional) is not going to be happy getting blasted with 50-80 amps for several hours driven down the highway. They typically like 1/10th their rating, say 6-12 amps. Thats what our alts put out at idle or lower rpms. This is where those really slick solid state smart battery management units make a lot of sense. They only charge your aux battery at a lower amperage, to try to keep it in shape longer.

I currently run a pair of conventional walmart batteries, a group 27 starting battery, and a group 27 deep cycle marine/rv aux with a surepower 1315 separator. I've had to replace the batteries twice, but they were both under warranty at the time. I "try" to keep the circuit breaker disconnected between them,and occasionally use a charger on just the aux at 6-10 amps. I had a group 31 as an aux, and a group 29 as an aux, but I decided I'd give up 10-20 mins of reserve for less weight. I went the walmart route for two reasons. One, I was slated for a 2300 mile road trip/campin trip 2 days after I bought them the first time, and figured I could easily replace a dead battery (walmarts are only slightly less available than starbucks). If doin it over, a conventional starting battery, and an AGM battery with some flavor of smart charge controller between would be the way to go. Throw a small solar panel up on the roof, and you can manually disconnect your batteries almost all the time. The solar would supply enough juice to charge a deep cycle, and with the right controller, would never overcharge it.
Hi ,

thanks for reply. My situation is slightly different - we are going to road trip in Russia for cca 10k miles so while I don't really need Odyssey expensive batteries I would on the other hand also want some battery that would last those 10k miles. I am not sure if this can be said about batteries from Wallmart. What I have seen on this forum is that Interstate is very popular for price they sell.

Jorge
 
Looking into Interstate 31M marine deep cycle AGM battery in combination with Megatron MTP-27F battery. Anybody running such setup ?

If your trying to stay in budget you can get a group 29 deep cell from Walmart for less then $100 if you make sure to take them your old battery as a core. This is what I am planning to use for my secondary battery, and the one you saw sitting on my bench the other day. They may have a 31 size there but I didn't check as I wasn't sure I had enough space for it. The Walmart batteries are made by Johnson Controls and have a pretty good reputation.

Edit: Johnson Controls may even be the manufacturer for Interstate, you'd have to look it up.
 
Interstate 31M is only 150 dollars. Called Firestone as they are dealers here for marine batteries and they can have it tomorrow.

31M-AGM
CCA 800
MCA1 1190
RC 190
Ah 100
RRC2 400

Dimensions :L W H
13
6 3⁄4
9 3⁄8

Seems pretty much the same size as Diehard Platinum 31M.

Jorge
 
Bear in mind that we will have fridge, couple of led lights, some heater for the mattress and couple of phone and camera chargers. Typical day would be driving two and half hours and rest spending on the camp site.
 
I am puzzled by the dual battery options and really would like some more opinions here. I always say that Aussies are doing it the best and looking into their forums basically all of them suggest constant current DC-DC chargers as CTEK D250s which would overcome the lower voltage given by our alternators.

This is from book on overlanding which is very good source for me:

Constant current DC-DC chargers The idea behind a 12-volt to 12-volt charger is that no matter what the engine speed, the charge current remains constant and the charge to the second battery comes directly from the charge of the first battery. The results are almost all positive. Firstly, a constant rate of charge is very good for the battery and the battery’s life is extended. Secondly, the original charging cables are not changed in any way, so the alternator cables need not go through additional switches and relays to charge the main battery, which is the case with almost all other systems. (Wherever there is a switch, some voltage will be lost). Modern DC-DC chargers, like the Ctek, perform brilliantly. Because of clever electronics, from a company that specialises in battery charging, that increases the voltage, it overcomes a deep-cycle’s tendency not to accept charge until the voltage exceeds 15-volts. Because they are current-limited means that the cables running to and from the unit need not be overly thick. This saves weight and cost. Having had many split chargers in my various vehicles, and having three of them fail while on safari, I am now using a Ctek DCDC charger, and I’ve found it to be excellent. The disadvantage of DC chargers is that their output current is limited, and therefore the full charging capacity of the alternator cannot be taken advantage of. For most overlanders, this is rarely a problem.

Question, why here in US everybody uses auto-relay - solenoid type of dual battery setup ?

Jorge
 
I wouldn't say so. I am not expert by any means but CTEK does really make sense in usage with deep cycle AGM batteries.
 
I just don't know where to mount this beast , it is 7.5 x 4.3 x 2.6 inches big. @half k cruiser do you have time for one more bracket :)
 
Bad news with CTEK is that I lose the ability to join the batteries together when the primary drains out. :(
 
Common guys even Jay Leno is talking about it !!

 
I just don't know where to mount this beast , it is 7.5 x 4.3 x 2.6 inches big. @half k cruiser do you have time for one more bracket :)

LOL, maybe. Why don't you just get a blue sea system like everybody else. Haven't seen any complaints yet.
 
Well I already have the dual battery system with SurePower separator. I am not saying it would not be working but probably I would never top the aux battery just by charging from the alternator. What I understood is that deep cycle batteries require higher voltage and lower AMP's then the alternator is providing. The battery will never be topped of and probably would be always around 80 percent. Is it good or bad ? Not sure.
 
Back
Top Bottom