Cost vs. Inexperience

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

For someone starting out I would recommend an arc welder. Again, it's cheaper, just as powerful as MIG and TIG (if not more so), and once you can arc weld, the other welding disciplines are much easier to learn. My learning curve was Arc, then Mig, and now I'm looking to get into Tig one day. Not because I need Tig, just because I'd like to know how to do it.

Arc welding is pretty difficult compared to Mig/Tig.

For easy of learning, I'd say (hardest to easiest): Arc, gasless MIG, gas MIG, TIG (which is always gas).



As far as buying a Mig welder, I'd search the local Home Depots since Lincoln just came out with a new model and they're discontinuing the old models. I'd also look to get a 220V model, stay away from the 110V.

x2 on the Lincoln's.

I bought a gasless MIG because the price was right (extremely cheap). I don't regret it because at the price I couldn't go wrong, but after using a buddies gas MIG, I'm amazed at the difference in power, penetration, and how much cleaner it is. His is about 10x easier to weld with as well.

To give an example, on mine I get about a 10% penetration on 4 gauge steel (on a flat butt joint). His gets about 40-50%. If you throw any sort of angle into the joint (so there's some room to fill in) his jumps to 80-90% while mines maybe 20-30%.

Mine will work just fine with maybe 8 gauge or thinner, so it works well enough for most uses for me. It's NEVER a pretty weld though.

Price wise mine was around $40 (with a welding cart, a couple spools of wire, etc), his was around $400 (not including tank, supplies, etc). So you get what you pay for. ;)


If I had the money gas MIG is what I would have gone with in a heartbeat. I didn't, so I borrow someone elses. :hillbilly:


Hmm, actually I would have gone with TIG. But TIG is slower than MIG and also starts about $2,000.
 
Ebag, you think TIG is the easiest to learn!?

And on the same MIG machine, fluxcore wire will penetrate better than gas shielded.

I learned to stick weld first and as a result, every other form of welding has been a breeze. MIG welding is almost as simple as using a hot glue gun.

I've acquired a LOT of tools over the past 5 years, and now rival many small fab shops, but I enjoy the work, and a lot of the time I think I have a better or diferent design than is being mass produced so I have no choice but to build my own.
 
Ebag, you think TIG is the easiest to learn!?

I've never used TIG, so anything I can comment there is from hearsay.

That being said, I've talked to multiple people who have used MIG/TIG (and usually Arc as well), and every single one of them have said TIG is the easiest. It's also the slowest, so they usually prefer MIG unless there's a reason why they want a pretty weld, or they're just being lazy.


And on the same MIG machine, fluxcore wire will penetrate better than gas shielded.

This has not been my experience at all.

The initial pool *MAY* penetrate deeper. The slag buildup from the flux (and other contaminates) will quickly overcome any benefit that fluxcore wire gives you.

There's no reason why you can't use fluxcore wire with gas, but it's not done because the flux contaminates the pool. It also tends to puddle on top which means you have to burn through it, reducing how much penetration you get.

Granted, I haven't compared two identicle machines side by side.


I learned to stick weld first and as a result, every other form of welding has been a breeze. MIG welding is almost as simple as using a hot glue gun.

I have no doubt that those who learned stick welding first have an advantage over those who haven't. Just like anyone who learned to drive a stick (pun not intended) will have an advantage over those who started with automatics. (I've even talked with a few people--yes, more than one--who thought that using 1 and 2 on an auto transmission was somehow bad. :doh: )
 
I'd have to question TIG being the easiest to learn, I actually think Mig is the easiest because it's pretty much just point and shoot. As long as you have the fundamentals, it's really not that difficult. Maybe it's because I started at a young age but I don't think Arc is that hard either. I definitely wouldn't say it's much more difficult than MIG. At any rate, I still recommend that he start with an Arc since it's the cheapest of all and will do just a good a job as all.

As far as pretty welds, Arc will never be as "pretty" as TIG but if you have enough practice you won't be too far behind.

As far as fluxcore vs gas, I prefer flux since it's cheaper, you don't need to haul a tank around, and it doesn't matter if it's windy or not. I've never had a penetration problem with fluxcore, even when welding 1/2" thick material.

Again, I'd recommend you get an 220v Arc machine, read a book/watch a video/take a local class, get a bunch of scrap, and practice, practice, practice.

EDIT....why did s-c-r-a-p get edited into scrap.
 
Last edited:
I learned to stick weld first and as a result, every other form of welding has been a breeze. MIG welding is almost as simple as using a hot glue gun.

me too. I have a 20 year old Sears ARC welder that I have used on every project in the past 5 years. I also have a HF pipe kinker, a chop saw, 4" grinder, and some magnets.

ARC is easy, MIG is easier. Learn to do it right the first time. I bought a book with pretty pictures and learned how to weld, you can too.
 
That $75 one doesn't look too bad. Talk him down to $60 and jump on it.

You mentioned goggles but I would recommend you get a helmet with a shade #10 (I think) lens. You can get a HF auto darkening helmet for about $50 or just go old school with a flip down for about $20. The auto darkening is nice when you're holding one piece with one hand and can't flip the shield down. I'd also get some decent heavy gloves and a heavy shirt that will keep hot sparks off you. I wear a long sleeve shirt with a BDU top over it as an example.

Also, thanks for the editing explanation.
 
Alright I will try and talk him down, and thanks for your detailed explanations and helping me through this :)! And the editing thing comes from playing video games online and having to sidestep this editing $hit.
 
I second the torch. Plasma is way too costly for the hobbiest. I also second Spike. Find a friend. Most guys who have the equipment like to use it. In my area, if you have the beer, I'll find the time. Just slip my wife some help with the electric bill, and me some for gas, rods & blades. BTW, I don't even use a torch. My list is; 220v arc welder, 110v light mig for thinner metal, 14" metal chop saw, small drill press, various drills and 4.5" disc grinders. I cut most small stuff with the disc grinder with a cutting wheel. Also use grinding discs, wire wheel, and a sanding disc made from a 36-grit and a 24 for finishing. My metal supplier has some benders and things that I take advantage of for a reasonable cost.
 
I'd have to agree with what mainmike is saying.. You need to take into consideration of safety... It would suck if you were stuck and someone was strapped to your bumper to pull you out and that bumper detaches for some reason either to bad welds or design and someone gets hurt.:frown: Not saying you can't do it, just needs to be thought out really well.

You are certainly ambitious! Sure - go for it!

But learning to weld is only one aspect, and it's not rocket science but also it isn't that easy a trade to learn, and welding round tubing is way harder than flat stock.

Learning to design, spec, cut, jig, rig and assemble a bumper from scratch is a whole 'nother thing. Not trying to dissuade you, but it is a really big project.

lastly... you're going to ask a lot out of the end product... like maybe saving your life? so it has to be right-on in many ways.

Take a class - that will probably answer all your questions. Or hook up with a friend? who has some experience.

After you learn how to make it yourself, you may decide that in many ways the 'expense' of aftermarket bumpers are perfectly reasonable.
 
I have to go here. You need to learn to weld well to do this. Burning your welds deep into the heavy metal is key. Just making it look good will not do. Today, I ran my front bumper into a tree stump. The stump refused to move. So did my bumper. My 80 did move. It climbed up the stump and over. At the time, I wasn't out wheeling. I was just doing my job. I was remodeling a house. I go wheeling once or twice a month. But I lock my axles more often at work than I do while having fun. My 80 is a workhorse. It never gets a smoke break. It is a working rig.
It is a tractor with air conditioning. When I hit that stump, the truck went sideways. But it climbed over it. No worries!
 
Back
Top Bottom