Cost vs. Inexperience

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Aug 30, 2008
Threads
7
Messages
67
Location
San Diego, CA
So I have been looking over the custom bumpers and sliders that you guys have been showing off, and I began to think is this a good idea to try by yourself with absolutely no experience whatsoever with working with cars. If I were to do this I would need to rent a plasma cutter to make the cuts, and then rent a welder/learn how to weld to piece it all together. I would really like to do it myself, and am all for it, but what will end up being more expensive, going and buying a front bumper, rear bumper, and sliders or do it myself *hopefully* succesfully. :confused:
 
Most community colleges offer a short (4 week or so) beginning welding course. As far as renting all of the equipment, you would probably be better off finding used or Harbor Freight. You won't spend much more and it will be yours to practice with. Just buy good gear, some scrap and start cutting it up and sticking it back together. That is the only way to get any good at it, and every machine is different. Getting your own and getting comfortable with it is probably your best bet.
 
You need a friend, and you need to put a location in your profile. Friends have equipment, and profiles help you find friends in your area.

-Spike
 
Instead of a plasma, look for a torch on Craigslist. They're super versatile and you can probably pick up an outfit for $100 or less if you look hard enough. If nothing else, HFreight has a kit without tanks for $100.

And it's definitely cheaper to build than buy, even when you have to buy all the tools too.
 
And it's definitely cheaper to build than buy, even when you have to buy all the tools too.

Depends on how much you spend on tools. :lol:


Seriously though, a plasma cutter will set you back a grand (even for a relatively cheap one), a welder will be another $400+ (assuming you want a gas one at least), and that's not factoring in parts, time, and other misc expenses.

If you're planning on doing your own complete build, want the experience, and want to do something unique, then money shouldn't be a factor. Unless you already have the tools it's likely you'll spend near as much as buying it already done (especially if you shop around and buy used or find good deals).


Once you add in the cost of steel, buying an ARB and nice sliders is roughly the same price, and a heck of a lot quicker to bolt on.



That's not to say you shouldn't do it. I did my own skidplate (which I love), and plan on doing my own bumpers/sliders. But I have access to a plasma torch and a nice welder, as long as I keep the owner supplied with food and :beer:. :grinpimp:
 
The tools and build will probably be more expensive- but the next build will be much cheaper. Think long term.
Or, find a friend. :D

-Spike
 
Depends on how much you spend on tools. :lol:


Seriously though, a plasma cutter will set you back a grand (even for a relatively cheap one), a welder will be another $400+ (assuming you want a gas one at least), and that's not factoring in parts, time, and other misc expenses.

If you're planning on doing your own complete build, want the experience, and want to do something unique, then money shouldn't be a factor. Unless you already have the tools it's likely you'll spend near as much as buying it already done (especially if you shop around and buy used or find good deals).


Once you add in the cost of steel, buying an ARB and nice sliders is roughly the same price, and a heck of a lot quicker to bolt on.



That's not to say you shouldn't do it. I did my own skidplate (which I love), and plan on doing my own bumpers/sliders. But I have access to a plasma torch and a nice welder, as long as I keep the owner supplied with food and :beer:. :grinpimp:

I would disagree. Buy a torch for $100, an Arc welder for $250 (cheaper if you buy used) since you don't need MIG or gas for building a bumper or sliders, a grinder for $15, a chop saw for $100 (don't need but it's nice), and for $465 ($365 without the chop saw), you're ready to go. Factor in the cost of metal (again, use Craigslist or local classifieds) and for a decent bumper you're probably looking at $600, including tools. When you do your sliders, you're only looking at the cost of metal.

When I was still in the States, my buddies would bring me stuff to fix/weld that would cost them $300-500 commercially. I would never charge more than $50 and my tools quickly paid for themselves.

FYI, there's some decent deals (3 yr warranty) on Chinese Plasma's that are in the $400-500 range.

FYI2, an Arc Welder can weld just as pretty as a Mig in experienced hands. I'm not there yet but I'm working at it.

As a reference, I built a copycat ARB (for a LR Disco) for a friend that when compared side by side, can't be told apart. All I used was a torch, grinder, and Home Depot arc welder.

Take your time, measure twice and cut once, and get after it.
 
You should do it. Suffering is the best teacher.
 
I say if you have plenty of free time, want to learn, and don't mind if it doesn't come out "perfect" then go for it.

I got into a habit of making everything when I built up my car but with the Cruiser I didnt want to spend more time than it is worth and then I would be mad if it didnt fit properly or was off or something so I don't mind spending the cash on already built parts.
 
You are certainly ambitious! Sure - go for it!

But learning to weld is only one aspect, and it's not rocket science but also it isn't that easy a trade to learn, and welding round tubing is way harder than flat stock.

Learning to design, spec, cut, jig, rig and assemble a bumper from scratch is a whole 'nother thing. Not trying to dissuade you, but it is a really big project.

lastly... you're going to ask a lot out of the end product... like maybe saving your life? so it has to be right-on in many ways.

Take a class - that will probably answer all your questions. Or hook up with a friend? who has some experience.

After you learn how to make it yourself, you may decide that in many ways the 'expense' of aftermarket bumpers are perfectly reasonable.
 
Check out weldingweb.com, those guys have a wealth of knowledge. It's more than just welding too, there's lots of fab tips and examples of creating something from seemingly nothing.
 
Yeh thought I might have to take a welders course, so that will probably set my schedule back to summer aha. But I have been looking on craigslist and stuff and plasma cutters are not that expensive, i.e

"I have a Miller 135 in great condition with tank and extra tips it also comes with stand I also have a spectrum plasma cutter miller that I will sell for 999.00 if wanted "

And I talked the guy into letting it go for $1150 for both, but as i have no knowledge of what is a good deal when it come to these tools, I told him I would get back to him.
 
Yeh thought I might have to take a welders course, so that will probably set my schedule back to summer aha. But I have been looking on craigslist and stuff and plasma cutters are not that expensive, i.e

"I have a Miller 135 in great condition with tank and extra tips it also comes with stand I also have a spectrum plasma cutter miller that I will sell for 999.00 if wanted "

And I talked the guy into letting it go for $1150 for both, but as i have no knowledge of what is a good deal when it come to these tools, I told him I would get back to him.

I HIGHLY recommend you start off with a simple torch outfit. It will do everything you want and then some and you'll have far less into the setup. If you find out you suck at metal work, you won't have an $1150 pile staring back at you. Unless you're moving into production work, a torch will do the job all day long. If you're dead set on the Plasma, the Chinese units will do everything you want (I am not affiliated with them in any way) for a fraction of the price. The good thing about a torch is that even if you move up to a Plasma, the torch is still very helpful and can do things a Plasma can't.

Maybe you're loaded and don't have to worry about budgets and such. If you are, congrats! If you aren't, IMHO, start small and build up.
 
If I was loaded I wouldn't bother with building and whorring away in my garage now.....or would I?:hhmm:

But can you elaborate on what you mean about just a torch? What is just a torch? You mean just a welding torch? Would i not have to buy a welding machine either then?
 
By torch, I mean an oxygen-acetylene cutting torch. A torch will cut metal, heat metal, help you bend metal, free stuck bolts, and you can also braze with it. You can melt metal together for the purpose of welding as well but an Arc welder is much better. In short, a torch will do everything a plasma will do and it doesn't require electricity or an air source.

Check this out:
Oxy-fuel welding and cutting - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
 
So a torch will be useful all around and reduce the cost of buying equipment, but getting a welder is still a good idea to get. The next question I have is whether a MIG or TIG is better, and also why, if aluminum is much lighter, do people still use steel for bumper and slider projects?
 
For someone starting out I would recommend an arc welder. Again, it's cheaper, just as powerful as MIG and TIG (if not more so), and once you can arc weld, the other welding disciplines are much easier to learn. My learning curve was Arc, then Mig, and now I'm looking to get into Tig one day. Not because I need Tig, just because I'd like to know how to do it.

As far as MIG vs TIG, I'd go with a MIG. It's a faster process, more versatile, and easier to learn. Plus, there's not as many consumables as TIG if you're using flux cored wire.

With the aluminum question, you'd have to put so many trusses and braces to make it the same strength as steel, you're better off just using steel from the get go. Bumpers and sliders need to be able to handle large impacts as well as pulling forces (recovery hooks) and are much better suited than aluminum for this purpose.

As far as buying a Mig welder, I'd search the local Home Depots since Lincoln just came out with a new model and they're discontinuing the old models. I'd also look to get a 220V model, stay away from the 110V.
 
Back
Top Bottom