Charging/Discharge Issues

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Nov 11, 2007
Threads
150
Messages
913
Location
Nashville, TN
So my 96 80 has been discharging the battery when sitting for about a year. Admittedly it doesn't get much use - only every couple weeks. I'm planning to use it more often so I had the battery checked at the auto parts store - came back fine but charging circuit was only pushing around 12v. Ordered a replacement Denso alternator and put it in.

1. Started up and charging was running 14.5v - great! Charged battery up.
2. Truck sat for about a week. Battery dead - obviously I realize there is a parasitic drain somewhere
3. Started looking for drain this morning and found charging circuit putting out only 11.0-11.5V at idle. Only gets to ~12.5v max at 2000RPM.

Is there something else that can cause poor charging performance? Is it really possible I got a bum Denso alternator? Or is low voltage normal when the battery was completely dead simply because it is being absorbed by the battery? I let the truck run at about 1KRPM for about 45 minutes this morning (from jump start).
 
Last edited:
So my 96 80 has been discharging the battery when sitting for about a year. Admittedly it doesn't get much use - only every couple weeks. I'm planning to use it more often so I had the battery checked at the auto parts store - came back fine but charging circuit was only pushing around 12v. Ordered a replacement Denso alternator and put it in.

1. Started up and charging was running 14.5v - great! Charged battery up.
2. Truck sat for about a week. Battery dead - obviously I realize there is a parasitic drain somewhere
3. Started looking for drain this morning and found charging circuit putting out only 11.0-11.5V at idle. Only gets to ~12.5v max at 2000RPM.

Is there something else that can cause poor charging performance? Is it really possible I got a bum Denso alternator? Or is low voltage normal when the battery was completely dead simply because it is being absorbed by the battery? I let the truck run at about 1KRPM for about 45 minutes this morning (from jump start).
Recharging a flat automotive battery is never a good idea. They tend not to hold a charge well after that.
You also don't mention how old the battery is to begin with. You might have shorted cells which will bring down the system voltage. My first thought is to replace the battery and recheck your voltages.
Also, if the battery was flat and the alternator was trying to charge it, it would be in a long duty cycle and might have gone into thermal shutdown. A flat battery should be charged outside of the vehicle.
 
I thought the same thing about the battery having been run flat but the auto parts store hooked it up to a tester and said everything tests completely fine on it. It is an Optima yellow-top, about 5 years old.
 
I think the optima will take a different charge profile. If it's really low you can take a good fully charged 12v and jump them together to bring up the optima voltage. Then throw it on a battery charger. I would charge at the lowest amperage the charger allows.

The factory alarm will pull power.
 
you can take a good fully charged 12v and jump them together to bring up the optima voltage.
That sounds like a spectacularly bad idea. We don't know the condition of the 5 year old battery, unless you want to trust the "auto parts store" with their pubescent staff.
 
I don't trust the auto parts stores either. From what I read the main problem with optimas/AGM is that when they are fully discharged they won't take a traditional charge from a charger unless the voltage is brought up. You can do that or buy the "specially priced" optima charger.

It's about the same risk as jumping a dead battery. Results may vary. I'm not a fan of optima's in the later years.

Can You Recover A Dead Battery?

How To Charge an AGM Battery - Hot Rod Magazine
 
I used to only run Optima batteries when they were owned and made by Interstate Batteries. The last one I had was junk. I won't buy another.

If I was buying an AGM I would buy a Deka. That's what I have in my 92 (a customer works for them and gave it to me for free). It has been a very good battery.

I run wet Interstate Batteries in my 93. They've been fine. I will upgrade to group 31 when due in 4-5 years or so.
 
5yr old battery that was allowed to go into super deep discharge over a 1yr period. More than likely it's dead jim, regardless of less than useful parts store tests, they just do a quick load test, not a long term test of capacity retention etc. How was the optima fully recharged after it went flat?

Rather than guessing about parasitic drain etc, smart money would say measure it. Lots of stuff in the vehicle drains some current, ECU keep alive, clock, radio memory, alarm system... Much more than 20mA would raise some concerns.

20mA draw for 24 hours for 1 week means you pulled 0.02 x 24 x 7 = 3.4 AH from you battery. Not nearly enough to bother a 'good' battery.

A DC current clamp meter (with resolution to say 10mA) is a good thing to own when wondering about alternator charge output and looking for parasitic draw on various battery cables, fusible links etc.

1000rpm is hardly high charge rate for the alternator. Alternator charging system is really meant to top up the battery from starting and to supply running current for lights/efi etc. It isn't a good 'charger'.

If you plan to store your vehicle for long periods without use, it would be a very good investment to get a decent maintenance/charger to leave connected permanently to maintain your battery at peak efficiency. Cheaper than buying a new battery every year or two.

cheers,
george.
 
I keep my batteries on battery tenders or unhook the aux. I driven mine less then 4 times in 5 months. I hear what you guys are saying about trying to charge a old battery though.

My Vatozone wet deep cycle marine aux has been going strong for 7 years now. I make sure to keep them from full discharge and keep them on the tender.
 
Back
Top Bottom