cage?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Mace said:
Bull,

No offense but that is the WORST idea. In a roll you will be much more likely for the surrounding area around the weld to fail instead of bend..

I really cannot believe that you would reccomend this..

There is a HUGE difference between case hardening and your theoretical case embrittlement.
I`am not comparing to a bend, a great weld is hard to tare.
If it tares, then it wasn`t a great weld, I`am not talking about a 200 mile an hour crash here.
and a tig weld, is not as strong as a mig weld.
 
Last edited:
Jeasus you have a bunch of bad ideas..

I was not comparing to a bend either.

There is a significantly greater chance of the weld (or the surrounding area) failind due to embrittlement with your method than a plain old weld that is allowed to cool normally.

Okay einstein, why is a TIG weld not as strong as mig???
 
Mace said:
Jeasus you have a bunch of bad ideas..

I was not comparing to a bend either.

There is a significantly greater chance of the weld (or the surrounding area) failind due to embrittlement with your method than a plain old weld that is allowed to cool normally.

Okay einstein, why is a TIG weld not as strong as mig???
Why do people like you start calling sarcastic names just because you don`t agree with somebody?
And I should clarify myself better, I played around with the cooling method on other things, I haven`t did it with a roll cage.
I only spray acouple of pumps in the welded area, then let it cool by itself.
A coulple of welding books I have say that a tig is not as stong as a mig, but they are so close you wouldn`t probably be able to tell the difference unless it was in a stress test.
MIG welding gets better penetration.
Has anybody on here ever taken some steel and heated it, and then water cooled it, then put it in a press to see what it can handle.
Then take the same matel, but don`t heat it, and put that in a press to see what it can handle?
 
When did I start calling Names???


Please, go get your books and tell my why Tig is fundamentally weaker than Mig. Other than "Mig is better cause it gets better penetration cause a book says so"


We are not talking static loads here. We are talking shocks..

A press will not tell you the shock failure of a metal..
 
Scottb said:
A coulple of welding books I have say that a tig is not as stong as a mig, but they are so close you wouldn`t probably be able to tell the difference unless it was in a stress test.
MIG welding gets better penetration.


i call bull@&@&@&@&, get some better books. all the high pressure tube i have ever welded in power plant boilers, has been with tig. we did not spray our welds with water after.

spraying water on a hot weldment on your roll cage is a bad idea.

i've laid more bead than you've had hot luches, that's how i know.

hth's

crusty
 
Ok guys lets not get to heated here, this threads about sharing some knowledge. Scott not to join in against you but I'm going to have to disagree with you. I let my metal cool naturally its better then cooling it with water it lets the elements in the metal reform bonds in a more natural way. When they do welds on some of the most important structures around like bridges and ship hulls they always let it cool naturally. Also I have never heard or read or seen anything saying mig was better in fact I have on seen the opposite. There just arent enough people out there that can do good tig welding and its a good bit slower.
 
I think a welded cage can be very close to the strength of a bent cage. My philosophy is that if a weld wouldn't hold up then they would make cars out of one piece of metal(which we all know is impossible). I'm not an insurance expert but I would imagine if you looked at MOST accidents the welds made on the car in the factory you would find very few of them "torn or ripped". Now most of the time a cage is needed when you are on a trail and roll your vehicle. I believe the impact of roll is less intense than an accident cause you aren't travelin 50 miles an hour down a highway. Granted you have the weight of the entire cruiser layin on it. also depends on the way you roll, i.e. if you roll sideways I think the impact would be less than if you were to flip it backwards like 40's can. And yes there have been some nasty rolls, like down a mountain, when that happens you have a lot more problems. Also he is building this on a PIG with a longer wheel base..little more stability. So if you build it correctly and gusset it and make proper welds than you can make just as strong cage. Just my opinion take it with a grain of salt.
Chuck
 
A coulple of welding books I have say that a tig is not as stong as a mig, but they are so close you wouldn`t probably be able to tell the difference unless it was in a stress test.
MIG welding gets better penetration.

No way - that's just plain not true. TIG has reputation as the "best" type of welding because of the accuracy and control you get it. An operator equally proficient in TIG, MIG, or stick would lay down beads of equal strength using each process, IMHO.


If you spray cold water on the welded section right of way, it will harden it, I just use a spray bottle.

NO WAY! Anybody who wants to try this want to google "water quench welds brittle crack hydrogen embrittlement" or something like that?!?!
This is definitely NOT the thing to do on your cage, bumpers, axles, steering components, or anything else where you want your weld to last! Especially if your life depends on it! Slow cooling is where its at!

-Tyler
 
Scottb said:
That is why I would use a spray bottle, and not dunk a steel part in a tank, it only TEMPERS most of the outside not all the way through.
Just like harden axles are not hardened all the way through, only part of the way so they are stronger, but not brittle all the way through.


careful scott, you're using lots of big words. You've got some of the BASIC principles right, but you're using them where they aren't appropriate. You can't compare case hardening of an axle to quenching a weld. The two components are meant to handle different loadings and though both are made of steel that has been heated and cooled in some manner, they're not equivalent.
:whoops:
 
Scottb said:
If you spray cold water on the welded section right of way, it will harden it, I just use a spray bottle.
If you don`t beleave me, take some metal, weld on it, or just heat it up, then cool it with water, then try to cut it with a portaband saw, or drill it, you will dull the blade instantly, and it doesn`t even start to cut the metal.
Don`t even try to drill it, if you like to keep your drill bits sharp.

Ah hell, I just wrote a big long essay on strain energy and the reason why you don't harden ROPs and then realised you weren't even talking about hardenning your rollcage. Doh!

Mind you, spraying it on with a spray bottle will not do much to harden the steel as there would not be any significant cooling. You really need to pour the water on to harden steel. Plus if you do harden steel, you should always temper it afterwards to increase the toughness. Heat it up to 300 to 400 deg Celcius and let it cool naturally.

PS (but don't do that to a Rollcage!)
 
I would pay a professional to take the metal you have and make one for you. YOUR LIFE MAY DEPEND ON IT ONE DAY. When I can save up enough money it will be the next major mod to my cruiser. Talk to Franky40 and ask for a picture of his design that held up AMAZINGLY well when his son rolled a friends 40 down a rather large hill at moab. The cage was pretty tweaked in the end but they woulda been dead without it guaranteed!
 
since we're on opinions here...
i have been researching cages for a long time, first for my rallycar(83 bmw 318i) and now for my 55. in car cages there are very few if any bends, what is more important is TRIANGULATION. a tube is strongest when loaded in tension, and weakest when loaded perpendicular(sp?) to it's axis. also tubes should be joinned at single points; i.e., the roof lateral and b-pllar should meet the top side bar at the same point.
FWIW, carl
 
clemson55 said:
I am building a rollcage into my pig and I am going to go with angled corners since I dont have a bender. I know that I need to gusset it for extra strength that is lost with the angled connections and welding. My question is which works better using tube steel or sheet steel because I have seen both. I would think that tube would be stronger but the sheet steel can get all the way into the angle.

The tube brace will be the stronger of the two, assuming that it is further out from the join. Being further out gives the brace more moment arm on the join to exert force with. There is no need for the brace to get right into the corner because the moment arm is small and you already have enough material in there. Quite often with plate braces you'll see the corner of the plate is notched out. This makes it easier to weld.

Try not to make your roll bar too stiff, otherwise you'll damage your chassis in a roll over. Remember, the roll bar is a sacrificial component to protect the occupant and vehicle. It's purpose is to absorb energy, this is done by plastic deformation. Mind you, being too stiff is safer than being to flimsy.
 
Back
Top Bottom