Broken knuckle stud removal

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Aug 30, 2006
Threads
103
Messages
3,952
Location
Utah
Last week, during my regular checking-tightness-of-knuckle-studs-and-nuts, one of them just snapped. The remaining half is still in the knuckle, and, probably against all common sense, I've been driving like this since my 80 is the only thing I have. No problems so far. Whew.

I bought myself a set of extractor bits, 8 brand-spanking new OEM studs, and appropriate E12 Torx socket for installation.

Tomorrow is when I will remove the broken stud. I want to make sure I do this right the first time.

I worry because recently, I had to remove a bunch of broken body bolts from my '63 VW, but the extractor snapped inside the body, and as many of you probably know, hardened-steel-extractor-head + trying-to-remove-it-with-drill-bit = lost cause.

So. I'm confident that I can replace the remaining 7 studs. What's the best way to get the broken stud out? Remember, I'm a :banana: + 1/2 guy.

TIA
-Lane
 
How much of it came off? there might be enough to grab hold of when you pull it apart.
 
It broke right where the coarse threads start... I'm not sure how far it sticks out, if at all, I haven't pulled off the steering arms yet.
 
Best pic I can get...

n539070227_4521694_3421.jpg
 
Once you get it off you'll be able to get at it from the inside of the knuckle also. Slow speed drive, Mobil1 and lots of patience.

Alternatively, a used one from cruiserparts.net is 100.00 shipping included.
 
Best thing to do...... take the knuckle off, place in a vise, center punch the broken stud in the middle, then take a drill bit SLOWLY drilling in the center, after you do this take a easy out & SLOWY twist it out........ this will work but take your time.

Another thought is that when you take the knuckle off it may expose part of the broken stud allowing you to put vise grip on it & twist it out.


A picture of the knuckle would help:idea:
 
I would try a reverse drill bit to drill the hole for your tap-out. On occasion I have had the reverse bit back out the bolt - you might get lucky too.

Karl
 
Ok I've run into a snag... The hub won't come off.

I've removed the drive flange and both axle nuts, but the hub won't budge.
 
Where have you found a reverse drill bit? I've looked for them at any store that has drill bits and most staff I ask have never heard of them. :doh:

x2...

I went to Homo Depot, the guy was like "why would you need THAT?"

:mad:
 
Where have you found a reverse drill bit? I've looked for them at any store that has drill bits and most staff I ask have never heard of them. :doh:

Local Napa had one in stock. Looks like I might be in luck.
 
Exactly. But why won't the hub come off the spindle?
Does it run ok on the bearings? Sometimes when a bearing goes bad the inner race welds itself to the spindle. Hopefully this isn't your problem seeing how you didn't mention bearing issues.

Might just be that the bearing races were a very tight fit on the spindle and / or the hub oil seal is catching on a groove in the face that runs on. Is there any give at all? You might need to be a bit forceful with it ;)

On your origional problem - I've been there and if it's not loose enough to be turned out, my advice to avoid broken extractors would be find someone local who knows how to use their MIG welder. Carefully build a dome of weld on the end of the stud, then drop a big nut over that dome of weld and weld the centre of the nut to the weld dome. If it wasn't so hot you'd probably be able to turn it out by hand now but best use a spanner! Can't think of a time this hasn't worked for a sheared stud and worked for me on the knuckle studs that sheared on mine.
 
Well I got it done finally!

I ended up having to drill out the broken stud backward out of the knuckle...er, toward the inside.

Wildsmith- I found the problem. The thrust washer somehow found it's way onto the spindle threads, preventing the hub from coming off. A quick tap with a screwdriver and hammer, and the hub was off. I had to remove it a few months ago to replace the brake rotor, so all was well.

I even repacked the birfield :D
 
Back
Top Bottom