Birf seal blown? pics inside...

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Feb 25, 2007
Threads
263
Messages
2,465
Location
Colorado m'fing Springs!
Anybody want to do another birf day :grinpimp:

Just in time for my trip this weekend, it couldnt come at a better time. Its only been like 15k since we did them, wonder what happened?
Ive been hearing a slight click every once in awhile but not loudly or frequently. Then a couple days ago i started to hear a faint metal on metal screech, today it was louder so i thought it may be the brake pad indicators. Pulled the wheel and tons of pad left, then i noticed some fluid at the base of knuckle but not much. Opened the diff plug and instead of gear oil i see grey sludge, thick. Did i blow a seal?

cool-breeze-albums-hub-picture9113-img-1878.jpg

cool-breeze-albums-hub-picture9111-img-1876.jpg

cool-breeze-albums-hub-picture9112-img-1877.jpg
 
Looks like it. What's the stuff in the knuckle look like? Take that square plug off then stick something down there... is it the driver's side that leaks? Usually those go first since it's harder to install the long side axle.

Lots of ideas: did you forget the shims on the top of the knuckle so your axle was running off center? Did your axle have any grooves in it when you had it out last time, and if so did you replace with the wider Marlin seal? Did you pop off that spring on the inner seal when you slid your axle in? Did you seat the inner seal nice and square? Hard to know for sure until you dig into it though, but hth..


edit: How far is your trip? I personally wouldn't let this stop me from going if only a couple hundred miles or so, odds are good it's been like that for a few months minimum, so another weekend probably isn't going to mean anything. If it were mine and I had to take the 80 somewhere, I'd swap in new gear oil and go for it. Things may be a little sloppier when you eventually pop that spindle but bfd as long as it's all wet inside. Not a long term solution but another tank or two of gas isn't going to make matters any worse. IMO, of course. :)
 
Last edited:
All parts were toyota oem, new.

Nakman, thanks for the ?'s but im not sure on, um, all of them. It was done with a friend when i was very new to wrenching so i was really just a helper. The person who helped me is Bear80 here on the board so we all know he is quite compentent so I'd venture to say the job was completed well. Maybe he can chime in with answers to your question.

Here is what im debating about doing the job before the trip. I have a locked axle i planned on swapping soon and was going to rebuild that so why do both. Secondly the trip is not going to be small, it will be 2500+ miles from tx to co, 4x4 trail exploring back country. I dont mind if the axle takes a little abuse because it will be replaced anyway, but will i be f';d in the A if go like this?
 
Oh yeah, and it does get wheeled...it is a cruiser!
 
Go read my post in the club corner. Find out what the metal sound was first. The seal did not lose the spring and it was seated perfectly flat with the seal driver tool.

The grease we also used seems to leave me drops of what looks like diff fluid on the bottom four knuckle studs. It isn't diff fluid but it had me worried before but it is from the grease.
 
Have you done the front diff breather mod? If not, do it immediately.

Sludge like that would be expected if your front diff had sludge in it when you and Bear did the repack. You put fresh diff oil into a chamber thickly coated with sludge and the fresh oil thinned it is all. I've seen that before and you essentially have to change the front diff oil monthly for a few months to get near to clear oil again. And you have to do the breather mod so it won't keep sucking more grease in from the birfs.

The metal sound needs more description - coulda been gravel in the brake dust shield? Coulda been dry spindle bushings?? If a metallic muffled thumping it may be simply the axle shaft clunking inside the spindle bushing.

DougM
 
Extended f+r breather lines into engine compartment and removed flap over a year ago. Ill start by replacing the diff oil today and try to find that sound more specifically.
 
Well since the seal has a thick liquid on the birf side and thinner on the axle side grease getting into the pumpkin is much rarer than gear oil getting to the knuckles. I wont say it can't happen just that if a seal is bad there is much more likely going to be gear oil in the knuckles.

I think Idaho is right in regards to the sludge. I run dino gear oil changed monthly for a while and when it stayed clear I went to synthetic and left it in. On other vehicles I went straight to synthetic and it cuts sludge even faster but is expensive to use those drain intervals on.

My plann for fording is to use regulators and OBA to pressurize the breathers and to add fittings and lines to the knuckle plug holes. Probably set a seperate regulator for the knuckles slightly above the regulator for the axles.
 
Back
Top Bottom