Battery Failure

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Jan 21, 2007
Threads
78
Messages
865
Location
New York & California
Website
www.rbfilms.com
I have gone through what is now 2 or 3 Optima Batteries and now a new Sears Platinum AGM Battery. I have a theory that is being debated with some people I am talking to.

My argument is that even though these are deep cycle batteries, if you drain them to the point of dead repeatedly over a few weeks or months ... you will kill the battery.


I am being told this is not he case. However, after 3 or 4 batteries in 9 months ... I am not convinced I am wrong.

Does anyone have knowledge of how these AGM Batteries work?
 
what exactly are you doing to kill these batteries? how long did it take you to go through 4 batteries?

It sounds like your alternator may be having an issue, or you need to replace your cables. There is most likely more to this than just batteries that don't hold up.
 
My argument is that even though these are deep cycle batteries, if you drain them to the point of dead repeatedly over a few weeks or months ... you will kill the battery.

Even with "deep cycle" batteries you do not want to drain them completely. The number I seem to recall is to keep them 40% or higher, with regular batteries you want to keep them 80% or higher, though I've seen different numbers in different places.


From: Deep Cycle Battery FAQ

Starting (sometimes called SLI, for starting, lighting, ignition) batteries are commonly used to start and run engines. Engine starters need a very large starting current for a very short time. Starting batteries have a large number of thin plates for maximum surface area. The plates are composed of a Lead "sponge", similar in appearance to a very fine foam sponge. This gives a very large surface area, but if deep cycled, this sponge will quickly be consumed and fall to the bottom of the cells. Automotive batteries will generally fail after 30-150 deep cycles if deep cycled, while they may last for thousands of cycles in normal starting use (2-5% discharge).

Deep cycle batteries are designed to be discharged down as much as 80% time after time, and have much thicker plates. The major difference between a true deep cycle battery and others is that the plates are SOLID Lead plates - not sponge. This gives less surface area, thus less "instant" power like starting batteries need.

Unfortunately, it is often impossible to tell what you are really buying in some of the discount stores or places that specialize in automotive batteries. The golf car battery is quite popular for small systems and RV's. The problem is that "golf car" refers to a size of battery (commonly called GC-2, or T-105), not the type or construction - so the quality and construction of a golf car battery can vary considerably - ranging from the cheap off brand with thin plates up the true deep cycle brands, such as Crown, Deka, Trojan, etc. In general, you get what you pay for.

Marine batteries are usually a "hybrid", and fall between the starting and deep-cycle batteries, though a few (Rolls-Surrette and Concorde, for example) are true deep cycle. In the hybrid, the plates may be composed of Lead sponge, but it is coarser and heavier than that used in starting batteries. It is often hard to tell what you are getting in a "marine" battery, but most are a hybrid. Starting batteries are usually rated at "CCA", or cold cranking amps, or "MCA", Marine cranking amps - the same as "CA". Any battery with the capacity shown in CA or MCA may not be a true deep-cycle battery. It is sometimes hard to tell, as the term deep cycle is often overused. CA and MCA ratings are at 32 degrees F, while CCA is at zero degree F. Unfortunately, the only positive way to tell with some batteries is to buy one and cut it open - not much of an option.


Battery life is directly related to how deep the battery is cycled each time. If a battery is discharged to 50% every day, it will last about twice as long as if it is cycled to 80% DOD. If cycled only 10% DOD, it will last about 5 times as long as one cycled to 50%. Obviously, there are some practical limitations on this - you don't usually want to have a 5 ton pile of batteries sitting there just to reduce the DOD. The most practical number to use is 50% DOD on a regular basis. This does NOT mean you cannot go to 80% once in a while. It's just that when designing a system when you have some idea of the loads, you should figure on an average DOD of around 50% for the best storage vs cost factor. Also, there is an upper limit - a battery that is continually cycled 5% or less will usually not last as long as one cycled down 10%. This happens because at very shallow cycles, the Lead Dioxide tends to build up in clumps on the the positive plates rather in an even film.




x2 on checking your belts.
 
Let's just say they are being run down for another reason....I don't want to get in to detail but I do not believe it is an alternator issue.

What I need to know is if you drain an AGM Battery consistently, will it kill the battery?

what exactly are you doing to kill these batteries? how long did it take you to go through 4 batteries?

It sounds like your alternator may be having an issue, or you need to replace your cables. There is most likely more to this than just batteries that don't hold up.
 
Those are only the most serious failures. I have others as well....lots of gremlins right now as I get this truck sorted out.

I have not checked the belts and I thought about that ... but the fluid on the ground leads me to believe it may be another issue.

The batteries I think are due to them being drained over and over again.

The AC Failure ... I have no idea.

Power steering failure
AC failure
Battery failure

Have you checked your belts?
 
These are AGM Batteries...Sears Platinum which are basically Odyssey AGM batteries.

I am kind of on my own here on these issues so I am trying to sort it all out but do not have the knowledge or skills to do this on my own. Last time I was at this Toyota Dealer, it was only in Stage #1 of Stage #4 of my build process. The MASTER Toyota Mechanic took one look under the hood and refused to work on it. He did not know Toyota made a supercharger for the truck and did not want to mess with anything else under the hood of my vehcile once he saw it was modified.

So, the problem is, I am afraid to have my local Toyota Dealer touch my truck. It is very heavily modified and I am not really comfortable with their techs working on it. I was uneasy even when I brought it in there as it drew a curious crowd of onlookers that worked in service.

As of now, the truck not drivable due to several issues which I not mentioned. The others I have figured out, but the AC Failure, Power Steering Failure, and Battery Issues are what I need to figure out so I can get this thing on the road...hopefully.


Even with "deep cycle" batteries you do not want to drain them completely. The number I seem to recall is to keep them 40% or higher, with regular batteries you want to keep them 80% or higher, though I've seen different numbers in different places.


From: Deep Cycle Battery FAQ









x2 on checking your belts.
 
Last edited:
I have the Sears DieHard/Odyssey PM-2/Group 31M in my truck right now. It's not a true deep cycle, but is something of a hybrid, designed to have better CCA/CA than a true deep cycle, but more of a charge than a true starting battery.

Regardless, I would not run it down more than 50%, even for a true deep cycle you don't want to run it down more than 50% on average.

If you're running your batteries to 0 repeatedly, that'll kill them in a hurry.



Do you have something wired directly to the battery?
 
No, nothing is being left on. I know why they are being run down but I cannot state why on the forum. I just need to confirm my argument that running them down consistently kills the battery ... which seems to be the case. That is the info I needed....thanks..:)



I have the Sears DieHard/Odyssey PM-2/Group 31M in my truck right now. It's not a true deep cycle, but is something of a hybrid, designed to have better CCA/CA than a true deep cycle, but more of a charge than a true starting battery.

Regardless, I would not run it down more than 50%, even for a true deep cycle you don't want to run it down more than 50% on average.

If you're running your batteries to 0 repeatedly, that'll kill them in a hurry.



Do you have something wired directly to the battery?
 
if you are running down a single battery regularly, why not put a dual battery setup in?

Overall it sounds like you have some pretty big fish to fry in your truck.

Who put the s/c in?
 
I do indeed have a dual battery setup in my truck. It is a dual rectifier Power Gate System with Mil Spec Tyco Relays. It is quite robust and it is the only way I can start my truck half the time. It seems teh main battery is the one with the biggest issue. That makes sense as it is the one being run down all the time.

However, the secondary battery is showing signs of trouble as well. If someone leaves the Inverter or Refirgerator on, it will drain the secondary battery to a point. Both the Inverter and Fridge have low voltage cutoof systems that prevent the batter fromn going below 10.8 volts or so I believe.



if you are running down a single battery regularly, why not put a dual battery setup in?

Overall it sounds like you have some pretty big fish to fry in your truck.

Who put the s/c in?
 
I would pickup one of these:
PriorityStart! - "Stop Dead Batteries" on Boats & Marine Equipment!

It won't totally save your battery (because you'll still be heavily deep cycling it) but it will prevent it from being totally drained, which will seriously help extend the life.

For bang for the buck, it's real hard to beat the Sears PM-1 battery. Since it's a hybrid it will hold up to deep cycling better than a true starting, though not as good as a true deep cycling battery.

You could put in a deep cycling battery, but just remember you need to oversize it by about 20% as the CCA is much lower. I'm not sure how you could fit that (physically) in the space given.

I would get the power cut-off, and use the PM-1. Avoid the Optima's, they are much more of a starting battery than the PM-1 is and I don't believe they'll hold up as well to deep cycling (in addition to their much smaller reserve times).

Both the Inverter and Fridge have low voltage cutoof systems that prevent the batter fromn going below 10.8 volts or so I believe.

10.8 volts = dead.

Code:
Charge	12 Volt battery
100%	12.7
90%	12.5
80%	12.42
70%	12.32
60%	12.2
50%	12.06
40%	11.9
30%	11.75
20%	11.58
10%	11.31
0	10.5
 
...
I have not checked the belts and I thought about that ... but the fluid on the ground leads me to believe it may be another issue. ...

Your rig doesn't have a power steering belt, the pump is gear driven.

No automotive batteries last if over drained. AGM batteries have some unique needs, all of my fleet customers have gone back to lead acid, it's been a while, but they said something like:

No batteries like heat, but AGM batteries are more sensitive. IIRC at a cell temp of ~120F they ether don't take a charge or require charge rates that are outside of typical automotive charging systems delivery rates.

When AGM batteries are deeply discharged the charge rate (volt/amp/temp) needs to be more tightly controlled when compared to lead acid. IIRC the rate is outside of typical automotive charging systems delivery rates, so needs to be done with a separate charger to successfully recover.

This is all IIRC, a Google search may bring up the correct numbers? When the first fleet changed over I figured it was related to budget, as more switched I payed more attention. Had the opportunity to talk to some of their techs and the answer was the same. Due to the heat here, lead acid is more reliable, lasts longer and delivers more power.
 
AGM batteries have some unique needs, all of my fleet customers have gone back to lead acid, it's been a while, but they said something like:

No batteries like heat, but AGM batteries are more sensitive. IIRC at a cell temp of ~120F they ether don't take a charge or require charge rates that are outside of typical automotive charging systems delivery rates.

When AGM batteries are deeply discharged the charge rate (volt/amp/temp) needs to be more tightly controlled when compared to lead acid. IIRC the rate is outside of typical automotive charging systems delivery rates, so needs to be done with a separate charger to successfully recover.

Are you sure you're not thinking of Gel? Everything you've said is what I remember for gel. It is not true for AGM.

Odyssey (who makes the Sears PM-1/PM-2 batteries) specs them to handle -40°C (-40°F) to 80°C (176°F).

Optima's are an AGM battery as well, for comparison purposes.


When the first fleet changed over I figured it was related to budget, as more switched I payed more attention. Had the opportunity to talk to some of their techs and the answer was the same.

There is a lot of misinformation/miunderstanding about AGM batteries. A lot of people think they're as picky as gel, but their not.

Due to the heat here, lead acid is more reliable, lasts longer and delivers more power.

I'd say true to delivers more power (for the price, not for the size). I would disagree on reliable and lasts longer.

Depending on the AGM you get, it may or may not last longer. Some AGM's are spec'd to last 20 years! (Granted that's only discharging them less than 10%, and they're huge and expensive...but still!)

AGM's I'd say are more reliable than lead cell's solely because they're sealed, while you have to monitor the water level in lead cells. If you let the water drop too far in one cell, you can easily kill the entire battery.

AGM's will work on their side (Optima advertises that quite heavily), while lead cell's won't. They will also (generally) hold up better to rough road and vibrations, which is why you see them used quite often for marine use.


For me, I want durability and a good cycle time. The Sears PM-1 meets that perfectly. I would be concerned about the durability in a lead cell for my purposes. For on road use where I wanted the most reserve power for the price, I would do lead cell in a heart beat as it's much cheaper. I would be concerned about how well it would hold up off road, however.
 
The operator error that lost database wiped out my posts to each of the individual threads so I am posting here again to sum it up. I just wanted to say that Rick & Nat came through big time and drove 5 hours each way twice to fix the issues with my truck. It turned out to be a defective radio for the batteries, a faulty Crimp on a PS Hose, and a loose connection for the AC Issue. They did a terrific job and went out of their way to get my truck back up and running. These guys are the greatest...!!
 
Back
Top Bottom