IMHO,
Axles and other things with the chasis, should be painted according to the amount of prep time spent on the respective parts...
for instance, if you only wire brush an axle for 5 minutes and call it done, then a flat black will look best and hide surface rust etc. better.
However, if you strip them down and clean them free of any rust, grime, or road gunk, then I think that gloss looks killer.
I find that a semi gloss, is the best of both worlds... short of a total rebuild of an axle, the semi gloss looks really nice.
Napa has a chasis black that is SUPER!
Rezarf <><