Automatic Headgasket Helper for FAQ

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

NaterGator

On Gilligan's Island
Joined
Oct 20, 2006
Threads
57
Messages
1,634
Location
Gainesville, FL
I have a vision, but it's going to require some participation, really this is a test to see if people are interested and willing to contribute. :grinpimp:


There seems to be a tremendous amount of confusion for a newbie to the HG problem in regards to the HG job and what is required both parts and time wise.

What I would like to do is gather as much data as possible from the HG veterans (Dan, Doug, Rick, robbie, etc) about various aspects of the process of PMing or fixing a HG and then create a form which can take alot of the guesswork out of the process for a newbie.

Ultimately I want this to end up as a sort of "So, you're HG is getting replaced? Start here." resource where the user fills out/answers information and then they get the best of the most relevant data to them.


I want the user to answer questions like "Have you experienced a catastrophic HG failure?" (if yes: ask how quickly they need to get their truck back on the road, etc.) If not: "Are you interesting in servicing other components that may need maintenance while you have the head off?" and so on and so forth.


After the user fills out as much of the form as possible, they'll get their results page (I want to give them the option to get an email with a persistent link to their results page as well). I see this page including rough prices of all the parts needed (I need to confirm this is doable with cdan and will give him a way to change prices of 'kits' / parts easily as needed to adjust for changing market prices) as well as a time estimate to complete all the work based on their estimated skill level (this will be a question they answer), links to the best threads relevant to their specific needs and jobs they've selected, etc.


If people are interested in contributing data or ideas to this I'm willing to get the ball rolling asap.

What say ye? :cheers:
 
I didn't want to leave this hanging so I thought I'd reply.

Unfortunately doing this kind of repair isn't all that black and white. For instance on my truck I did a basic R&R of the gasket, that's it. I literally removed the head, cleaned it up and slapped it back on. The cost was a valve grind kit from Toyota and some cleaning materials. I've put on another 110k miles and the engine runs like a clock, but this is still not for everyone. This was done as a PM.

The problem is that people see this sort of PM as something more than it is and they suddenly want to do more while they are in there. Kind of like flying to France on business and not seeing the Eiffel tower while you are there. Everyone knows you can always go back but while you're there you have to see it.

Repairing an all out failure would be a little different, especially for a novice. Doing the minimal work and still getting a solid repair takes some skill and experience and a novice might be lacking in both. And it's hard to put that experience in a flow chart. I remember that IdahoDoug was replacing the HG and did just as I did but was still having issues. Turns out his failure was a cracked head and not the HG. So even at that level assumptions can be made that are incorrect.

The best way to proceed might be to lay out a rough draft of what you have in mind and then allow some input to fill in the blanks.
 
I didn't want to leave this hanging so I thought I'd reply.
Unfortunately doing this kind of repair isn't all that black and white. For instance on my truck I did a basic R&R of the gasket, that's it. I literally removed the head, cleaned it up and slapped it back on. The cost was a valve grind kit from Toyota and some cleaning materials. I've put on another 110k miles and the engine runs like a clock, but this is still not for everyone. This was done as a PM.

The problem is that people see this sort of PM as something more than it is and they suddenly want to do more while they are in there. Kind of like flying to France on business and not seeing the Eiffel tower while you are there. Everyone knows you can always go back but while you're there you have to see it.

Repairing an all out failure would be a little different, especially for a novice. Doing the minimal work and still getting a solid repair takes some skill and experience and a novice might be lacking in both. And it's hard to put that experience in a flow chart. I remember that IdahoDoug was replacing the HG and did just as I did but was still having issues. Turns out his failure was a cracked head and not the HG. So even at that level assumptions can be made that are incorrect.

The best way to proceed might be to lay out a rough draft of what you have in mind and then allow some input to fill in the blanks.

Rick I agree that it's not black and white at all. I just dropped a publicly editable wiki on a subdomain on my site (see here: Main Page - HGWiki) in which I will fill in many more of the blanks in the coming days.

What I don't have is the knowledge needed to foresee how people need to be guided on a microscopic level. What I do have is the knowledge necessary to fill in some blanks, pool resources and build a database driven resource when can at least take some of the guesswork out of the process for everyone (as well as hopefully cut down on the need for the gurus to repetitively answer trivial questions in tech)
 
I like the idea Nate and while I think Rick has some significant disclaimer points to consider, I don't see why we cannot go ahead and at least begin this type of venture.

The most difficult thing seems that there is the PM HG and the failure HG. The differentiation is important. Also some other points:

1. Is this vehicle your DD (this will greatly effect the work done and the time frame.)?
2. Will you be doing the work or will you be farming this out?
3. Will you be using OEM parts or aftermarket?
4. Will you be tuning the engine or keeping it stock?
5. How comfortable do you feel with your own wrenching and organizational skills?

Anyway, not to get off tangent, but I think this is doable.

Where do we start Nate?

-onur
 
I have a lot of pictures of the work that I'm doing, I already post them in the forum somewhere, I joined HG club tonight...

Buttercup is not longer my daily driving...
I'm working the weekends only... (like 9 in a row)
I'm a newbie who wants to learn, so Joe is like a mentor to me...
you need the owner manual... and know how to read it...
don't allow the dog to play with old hoses...
another 80 to figure out where the stuff goes...
patience, time...

the link to pics... 7 albums...take your time

Kodakgallery.com Slideshow
 
Last edited:
I like the idea Nate and while I think Rick has some significant disclaimer points to consider, I don't see why we cannot go ahead and at least begin this type of venture.

The most difficult thing seems that there is the PM HG and the failure HG. The differentiation is important. Also some other points:

1. Is this vehicle your DD (this will greatly effect the work done and the time frame.)?
2. Will you be doing the work or will you be farming this out?
3. Will you be using OEM parts or aftermarket?
4. Will you be tuning the engine or keeping it stock?
5. How comfortable do you feel with your own wrenching and organizational skills?

Anyway, not to get off tangent, but I think this is doable.

Where do we start Nate?

-onur
Onur,
I've added your questions to the Questions - HGWiki section.

I think the best place to start is just start farming as much information as possible and take suggestions from people on how we should organize this. The gist is: if you can dream something up, I'll program it to make it work.

The wiki is there though for anyone to edit (you don't have to register or sign in or anything) though, so any mudder can voice their opinion and contribute.
 
I have been busy lately and I am currently in Moab for the next week. After Moab I would be happy to help as much as I can. I agree with Rick as there is no Black and white to this, but hopefully the info you can compile will help many in the future. later Robbie
 
Back
Top Bottom