My choice was based mainly on price. The big reason is simply the fact that the cost to repair/replace the rockers and/or catalytic converters is huge, whereas a front bumper is cheap and easy to repair or replace. Given the fact that sliders are about the same expense as a front bumper (without buying a winch), it seemed like a no brainer (IMO) to protect the important and expensive bits first. I see the stock front bumper as being expendable. I probably won't get a Shortbus/ARB/tube bumper until I need a winch and the extra clearance or until I trash the stock bumper.
I could argue against myself with the fact that I do a lot of night driving and should have a bumper to protect me from deer/moose. However my encounters with critters on the road have been pretty infrequent and I'm a cautious (read: slow) driver, so I don't feel the need. I also have done all the light upgrades available to increase the range and clarity of my headlights and driving lights (HIRs in the high and low beams, Slee headlight harnesses, upgraded bulbs in the Hellas). The truck pumps out a lot of light, so I "hope" I see the animal first and can stop before a bumper is necessary.
I also purchased the IPOR skid plate at the same time as the sliders, so my transmission and transfer are both protected too. The wheeling around here is dirt and rocks (not rock crawling, just big random chunks of rock), so sliders and the skid plate made more sense to me. My priority was to protect the undersides of the truck first, since it has all the important and expensive bits!