Another broken birf thread...

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Aug 20, 2009
Threads
48
Messages
680
Location
Austin, Tx
So I was out wheeling yesterday and got hung up pretty bad. Had wheels turned and was trying to back up (front locker engaged), and heard a loud pop and then what sounded like a really loud card stuck in a bicycle wheel. It would click and grind and growl when you gave it gas. I winched out of where I was and the wheel would lock up and unlock, even worse with the wheels turned. I presume its a birf but haven't got it back to the shop to tear into it. What normally gets messed up with it besides an inner seal? I had to drive it about 2 miles very slow through some rough, very muddy terrain to get back up to the front of the place to get it on a trailer. It was making alot of racket and clicking and wheel would lock up occasionally, but the terrain is waayyy tooo muddy and rocky to get a trailer to it.

What else could I have damaged by driving it that far?

BTW I have pictures and a vid of the breakage I will post when I get them loaded.

D
 
It's obviously too late now, but you should have pulled the birf rather than driving on it for that long. You could have driven it out in 2WD.

Backing up with the locker engaged (especially with the wheels turned) is a recipe for disaster.
 
My guess would be broken star or cage....sucks man.
 
Yea I should have but due to the conditions of the terrain and weather it would have been a BIG MESS. I am sure its a birf if it is I will replace it with a chromoly unit and be done. The truck doesn't get driven THAT much. About 6 miles a day, 6 days a week. And I know turning and backing is bad but I am always a day late and a buck short. I should have just winched and saved my axle. Oh well. If it broke it needed upgrading. I was just curious if you thought I broke anything else. I don't know if the abs stuff is jacked up or not because I didn't take it out of low to get back to the trail head. Live and learn. LOL

D
 
BTW, to pull the birf I would have had to pull the whole spindle and knuckle right?
 
As I promised a few pics and a video of the carnage...shows what happens when you are determined to make it through something without winching. Sometimes it is an expensive lesson.

My homemade sliders (cat guard) doing their intended job.

rockcreek2.jpg


rockcreek1.jpg


My unfinished rear bumper. (Will look more complete after I finish it)

rockcreek3.jpg


The location of my birfields final demise...

rockcreek4.jpg


Me regretfully preparing to winch my dumbass out...

rockcreek5.jpg


A better idea of the terrain...you can't tell it in these pictures but it was really crappy weather outside...

rockcreek6.jpg


And here is a link to the carnage. Laugh it up. :doh:

YouTube - Rock Creek Daniel pt 1

D
 
Wow, big sharp rocks & mud....
 
Oh man. The last half of that vid I was cringing every few seconds.

And then you drove it out like that? :eek:

Definitely take pics of the carnage when you tear it apart. You just torture tested the front end hardcore.
 
Oh man. The last half of that vid I was cringing every few seconds.

And then you drove it out like that? :eek:

Definitely take pics of the carnage when you tear it apart. You just torture tested the front end hardcore.

Yea, well winched forward about 70 ft and then drove 1 - 2 miles out of that hell hole. LOL . Probably will be an expensive mistake. Oh well. I will definately take some pictures. I will be tearing into it tomorrow evening, so I can order whatever I broke. If thats possible. Hopefully I didnt trash the housing. I guess if I did it will be time for rockwells.:hillbilly:

D
 
:eek::eek:

I hope that jeep behind you didn't get through unmolested, tell me he broke his rear end or something please.
 
:eek::eek:

I hope that jeep behind you didn't get through unmolested, tell me he broke his rear end or something please.

Um no. That is a 100% stock Heap, all the way down to the street tires. The guy taking the pics was in an 03 TJ with 5.5" Lift and 33's, and he wouldn't try it either. I made it a long ways through there just fine and was just 70 ft from getting out of there. I was :censor:. Oh well.

D
 
Great pics! I like it, that was a rugged section of trail for sure. Sorry to hear about the birf. We have Longfield axles and birfs in ours (and Poly Performance in the rear) and so far after three Rubicon runs, it's been 100% reliable.
 
Great pics! I like it, that was a rugged section of trail for sure. Sorry to hear about the birf. We have Longfield axles and birfs in ours (and Poly Performance in the rear) and so far after three Rubicon runs, it's been 100% reliable.

Well that is probably going to be my plan, It just seems like alot of money to beef up axles when there are plenty of stock axles that are alot stronger. Oh well. Gotta pay to play I guess.

Thanks,

D
 
Are those Cooper Discoverer STTs? If so, do you like them?
 
Well that is probably going to be my plan, It just seems like alot of money to beef up axles when there are plenty of stock axles that are alot stronger. Oh well. Gotta pay to play I guess.

Thanks,

D

Well think about how many miles you have on that birf you popped, and then you put it under incredible strain (locked + turning).

Chomoly's will wear out very fast if you even occasionally DD it. Club member bought some longs and was pretty disappointed in the longevity as after about 15k they start clicking. He only occasionally drives his 80 (works from home).

You'd need to go to a part time kit if you want to run longs with any sort of longevity.

IMHO the cost of the part time kit + losing all wheel drive is not worth the savings of using longs. Get some new OEMs and don't use the front locker when abusing the rig. That's what ya got a winch for, right? :idea:
 
Oh man that video is brutal! Good luck to you, please post up pics of what you find in there.
 
Are those Cooper Discoverer STTs? If so, do you like them?

Well I sell tires for a living so I switch constantly, but so far I like them, I only have about 2k miles on them.

Well think about how many miles you have on that birf you popped, and then you put it under incredible strain (locked + turning).

Chomoly's will wear out very fast if you even occasionally DD it. Club member bought some longs and was pretty disappointed in the longevity as after about 15k they start clicking. He only occasionally drives his 80 (works from home).

You'd need to go to a part time kit if you want to run longs with any sort of longevity.

IMHO the cost of the part time kit + losing all wheel drive is not worth the savings of using longs. Get some new OEMs and don't use the front locker when abusing the rig. That's what ya got a winch for, right? :idea:
Yea but what is the point of having a locker in the front if everytime you use it you risk breaking an axle? I mean thats the point of upgrading. Our rockcrawler started with a 10 bolt and a 14 bolt semi floater, after breaking some shafts we went to a Dana 60 and a 14 bolt full floater. After breaking a few chromoly 35 spline shafts we went to Rockwells. And now were breaking those!? Anyways my point is the winch is to get me out of something I can't get out of on my own.

Oh man that video is brutal! Good luck to you, please post up pics of what you find in there.

Ask and you shall recieve. Check out the yummy watery birf soup. Granted it had been dunked several times that day and I was planning on repacking everything this week. LOL.

I am going to need a new birfield (with abs tone ring), and inner shaft and several hours with a file or die grinder to make a new axle seal fit.

Anyways here is the carnage.

birf1.jpg


birf2.jpg


birf4.jpg


birf5.jpg


birf6.jpg


birf7.jpg


birf8.jpg


birf9.jpg


birf10.jpg


birf3.jpg


Anyways, I have a few more questions about this. That deal that looks like a seal down in side the axle tube, what the deal with that? Where did that seal some from?

D
 
Yea but what is the point of having a locker in the front if everytime you use it you risk breaking an axle? I mean thats the point of upgrading. Our rockcrawler started with a 10 bolt and a 14 bolt semi floater, after breaking some shafts we went to a Dana 60 and a 14 bolt full floater. After breaking a few chromoly 35 spline shafts we went to Rockwells. And now were breaking those!? Anyways my point is the winch is to get me out of something I can't get out of on my own.

The OEM birfs are actually extremely strong.

You're running much larger tires than they were designed for, and wondering why under extreme stress a birf with 150k+ miles (guessing, dunno how many total miles on it) broke?

No offense intended, but you shouldn't need a locker. Some of the best people I've seen have only rear or even no lockers. An older guy in our club has a 40 that's open and goes everywhere that the triple locked 80's or ATRAC/Rear Locked FJC goes.

Knowing the limitations of your gear is a good thing. I know that if I jump my 80 (or bounce it repeatedly on a rock....hi chad! :p ) I run the risk of breaking something or bending the axle housing. So I don't do that.

You try and reverse with the front locked and wheels hard over and you might not break your birf next time. But you might be opening your diff to see what you broke in there.

Unless you completely replace the axle, hard over, locked, and lots of skinny pedal is a bad idea. Bad idea in forward, worse idea in reverse.

The solution is simple. Don't do that. Know the limitations and spend 5 minutes winching or 10 minutes stacking rocks instead of trying to power your way out of a situation.

Besides, you swap the OEM birfs for chromoly, and you're trading one problem for another. Run the risk of breaking a birf every 150k+....or change them out because they're worn out every 15k?


Ask and you shall recieve. Check out the yummy watery birf soup. Granted it had been dunked several times that day and I was planning on repacking everything this week. LOL.

That doesn't look like it's been touched in quite a while. Either that or you do a lot of water crossings.
 
The OEM birfs are actually extremely strong.

You're running much larger tires than they were designed for, and wondering why under extreme stress a birf with 150k+ miles (guessing, dunno how many total miles on it) broke?

No offense intended, but you shouldn't need a locker. Some of the best people I've seen have only rear or even no lockers. An older guy in our club has a 40 that's open and goes everywhere that the triple locked 80's or ATRAC/Rear Locked FJC goes.

Knowing the limitations of your gear is a good thing. I know that if I jump my 80 (or bounce it repeatedly on a rock....hi chad! :p ) I run the risk of breaking something or bending the axle housing. So I don't do that.

You try and reverse with the front locked and wheels hard over and you might not break your birf next time. But you might be opening your diff to see what you broke in there.

Unless you completely replace the axle, hard over, locked, and lots of skinny pedal is a bad idea. Bad idea in forward, worse idea in reverse.

The solution is simple. Don't do that. Know the limitations and spend 5 minutes winching or 10 minutes stacking rocks instead of trying to power your way out of a situation.

Besides, you swap the OEM birfs for chromoly, and you're trading one problem for another. Run the risk of breaking a birf every 150k+....or change them out because they're worn out every 15k?




That doesn't look like it's been touched in quite a while. Either that or you do a lot of water crossings.

Well, like I said, I am not used to getting out and stacking rocks or winching, unless I am broke. So like I said this thing may not be built enough to handle me. LOL. And I wheel this thing like its a comp rock buggy. Not just an "expedition" vehicle. And I agree it would suck changing out birfs every year and a half, but 700$ every year and a half is better than breaking my s*** every time I wheel it hard. Like I said maybe I need to look into putting in some other axle. Why can't you put a HP60 and a 14BFF under a LC? Am I missing something obvious? I searched and found one thread on Dana 60's and it didn't really say much.

D

Oh and BTW it has spent quite a bit of time under water in the last 2 weekends. I checked the grease 3 weekends ago.
 
The OEM birfs are actually extremely strong.

You're running much larger tires than they were designed for, and wondering why under extreme stress a birf with 150k+ miles (guessing, dunno how many total miles on it) broke?

And BTW I never wondered why it broke. I don't know where you got that. I asked what else normally gets broke in there. And what was the best way to prevent it from happening.

D
 
Back
Top Bottom