Fair is a very subjective term. Only you can determine if it's worth that. If everything checks out, it probably is. Are you buying it at possibly the highest value it'll see (at least in the next couple years)? Maybe... Is the bumper worth something? New? Yes. Used? A couple hundred - but they're hard to find used. Consider that a win.
If the leather's solid, the mechanics are solid, and it doesn't need a whole lot of work to keep it running - then why not use some good negotiation skills and make an offer? The worst he can say is no.
What's it worth to you?
Edit: Without seeing the inside of the vehicle, it's definitely within the "range" of acceptable prices. So, at least if it's high - you're talking maybe $500-1500 high.
Edit #2: What about the 35s? I see what looks like 33s? If he's paying for a set of 35" tires, that's anywhere between $800-$1400 that isn't coming directly out of your pocket.