LOL! This like the what's your favorite beer debate... everyone has thier differences. Here is what I have gathered in my research. Interestingly enough, talking with Spicer two years ago they confirmed that Yukon and Precision actually are made differently, both in metal and finish. Maybe that's changed? anyhow, here's my .02...
There are three major gear manufacturers in the United States:
Dana/Spicer
Richmond
US Gear
There are a handful of non-US based companies in many countries, including China, India, the Philippines and Italy.
There are 2 types of Yukon Gears: Yukon (manufactured by Spicer) and Yukon Value (usually manufactured in the Philippines in a factory owned by Spicer). The regular Yukon gears are produced in the US. They are considered high-quality gears.
The trademark of the Yukon Value brand of gears is noise, meaning the tolerances are not set as well as the U.S. produced gears. While this does not translate into a necessarily weaker gear, one has to suspect there may be other quality issues.
Dana/Spicer also manufactures Precision gears in the US. They are considered high quality gears.
Superior Gear and Genuine Gears are made in China. They are well known to be of low quality. The signs are loudness, weakness, poor performance under shock load and a susceptibility to failure under prolonged high-heat conditions (i.e. towing or slow trail riding).
Just as Four Wheel Parts has a vested interest in Pro-Comp, they have a vested interest in Genuine Gears, and this is why they push them.
Humbly submitted...
