Hello very good lucking, the center hub I think is not oem, try to look on Genuine OEM Toyota Parts and Accessories Online - Toyota Parts Deal - https://www.toyotapartsdeal.com, the part number is 43423-35010, I use to have same issue and I solve it buy new caps
I use to have some problem with light I throw that was a light I ordered the bulb to Toyota parts and deal (part no. 90076-04003). But went I put I still have the problem.
I switch between position and then see that in other position the bulb works.
Maybe the flex was broke and in that...