Found this gem through recommendations on MUD. Taking the OEM cupholder out was a breeze, and the new unit fit perfectly.
What's cool about this cupholder insert is that it can fit the wife's Stanley or my Nalgene bottle perfectly. My wallet...
While I waited for more parts to arrive, I knocked out a set of custom center caps for @cosport. They turned out sweet and definitely gave me an idea for what I want to change mine up to in the future.
These are the custom caps I am...