I finally built a swing down tire carrier off my tube bumper - with the addition of two large dogs to four kids, the roof rack can no longer carry the spare as I need it for gear.
I chose a swing down over a swing out for several reasons:
1) My 3rd row is used full time and I only need access to the upper hatch as tools/spares are stored behind the 3rd row, and I don't regularly need to access behind the 3rd row;
2) The hatch can be accessed in much tighter trail spots than a swing out;
3) Integration into a tightly tucked tube bumper would have been difficult with a swing out;
4) Low cost ($300).
We built a sliding mount with multiple locator holes - this allows the mount to stay lower for highway and mild offroad trips for visibility, but it can be raised to ensure no issue with departure angle for technical crawling trips. You can see the bolts on the mount pole in the 3rd pic.
I still need to buy caps for the open ends (hence the orange electrical tape), and the mount pole is left long above the tire for a light mount if I ever want one.
The swing down motion stops at horizontal when the tire contacts the hitch, but I may install a limiting strap so it only swings down far enough to open the upper hatch, which will make hoisting it back up much easier for regular access.
It does not rattle at all including on washboard, I am very pleased with the result. Design inspiration goes to Darwink, who built a swing down off his rear bumper.
I chose a swing down over a swing out for several reasons:
1) My 3rd row is used full time and I only need access to the upper hatch as tools/spares are stored behind the 3rd row, and I don't regularly need to access behind the 3rd row;
2) The hatch can be accessed in much tighter trail spots than a swing out;
3) Integration into a tightly tucked tube bumper would have been difficult with a swing out;
4) Low cost ($300).
We built a sliding mount with multiple locator holes - this allows the mount to stay lower for highway and mild offroad trips for visibility, but it can be raised to ensure no issue with departure angle for technical crawling trips. You can see the bolts on the mount pole in the 3rd pic.
I still need to buy caps for the open ends (hence the orange electrical tape), and the mount pole is left long above the tire for a light mount if I ever want one.
The swing down motion stops at horizontal when the tire contacts the hitch, but I may install a limiting strap so it only swings down far enough to open the upper hatch, which will make hoisting it back up much easier for regular access.
It does not rattle at all including on washboard, I am very pleased with the result. Design inspiration goes to Darwink, who built a swing down off his rear bumper.

