With All The Recent Gear Threads?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Jun 4, 2006
Threads
153
Messages
834
Location
Fairfax, VA
I have a question, might sound stupid but, I currently have a 3FE powered rig with 33" procomp mud terrains and 4.56's and I will be going to 35's. Based on the gear to tire ratio Im running currently what would be a better setup for the 35's 4.88's or 5.29's? Take into affect mixed driving, long highway runs(300 mile plus) and alot of city driving. Also take into affect the lower RPM's the 3FE likes to run at versus you guys with the 4.5. What would you all recommend? Right now the truck is not a Porsche, but I can cruise at 75 no problem.(except for the big mountain passes):doh:. Also what gear 4.88, 5.29 would net me better MPG's with motor at highwway speeds. Now Im at aroud 12-13 city,highway.

thanks for any input

:cheers:
 
5.29's and 35's is overkill IMO for a highway truck. In hindsight I should have got the 37 and not the 36 Iroks to match my 4.88s, they would cruise better on the highway and I could have fit them. Given your truck is a 3fe the ball game is slightly different, but still there is only so much power that motor makes.

Now realistically remember overdrive is made for economy. If you gear so low to make up for heavy tires (ie. 35's should be with 4.56 gears) there comes a point that turning the engine faster and faster may keep you in the engine's power band sweet spot and cruising at speed but you're consuming fuel at a faster rate than at a lower RPM.
 
It depends entirely what you mean by "highway speeds" or "highway truck". With the 1ZFE I get nearly 15 mpg if I keep it at 65-70 mph on 35" tires with 5.29's at 2,700 RPM or so. You want to go above that and cruise 75-80 and you are nearly 3K RPM. The thing wants to run still at those RPM's, but it gets a bit NVH unfriendly, and economy goes down to around 12 mpg.

Simply put: If you cruise at lower speeds, for whatever reason, or want to keep RPM up for whatever reason, then 5.29's can be great. If you prefer higher cruising speeds, I would not do 5.29's. If you simply don't wheel that hard, I would not do 5.29's because you won't see any offroad benefit.

For me, I run Interco tires, and even though trxus MTs are fantastic for me, they really aren't an 80 mph tire after spending a lot of time in the rocks. I also live at 7,400 ft, I don't daily drive, I do rock crawl, and I have a minivan for high speed city trips. Outside of city trips I may be climbing over 12K feet, and keeping RPM down is of no help at all.

There is no rule here - diff gears simply define the sweet spot for your usage. What you want to do is match your gear's sweet spot to your sweet spot, and then you've made the right choice.

Bear80 thinks 37's would be better matched to his 4.88's, and I worry about losing what I have with 5.29's by going 37's - I'd probably start longing for those 3:1 case gears or whatever that available ratio is, and I just don't want the spend. Both of us are right, of course :D
 
If I could make a suggestion - how about instead of all those what-if's, just keep it simple and aim to keep your truck's final drive ratio as close to stock as possible. With 35's, your diffs would theoretically need to be geared at 4.64 to correct for the tires. You're really close to that now, with your 4.56's.
 
Not to be a smart az but how do you know its a lower rpm motor?



The specs I have show the 3fe's Torque peak, 200 rpm's below that of the 1fz. The HP is peak is the same, 4,000rpm. I dont know why it bothers me that some can "feel" that its a low end motor and they think they can gear it high, but it just does. "They are not Chevy motors"

Trying to make a point with that.

Now with that said, gears can be a matter of necessity or preferance. For instence I was going to gear my 3fe, 33/35 shod, w/ 5:29's. I know the result, and thats why I wanted them. Some my need different. Like a DD, if you can get away with dropping a ratio, then by all means, do it.

Mall Cruisers, DD's and Starbucks trucks can get away w/o needing allot of gear. Some hard core wheelers not so much. I wanted my rig for basically everything but the highway so I was going to gear it there. Plus I like those engines turning, my 94 4runner has 4:56 gears w/ 28's and I love it. Spools and pulls! H8 to fill it, but love to drive it.

In the end, weigh the options and just pick what you need.
 
I'd get a Craigslist Honda for a couple thou. Drive it like Ms Daisy, and build the ell outta the 80. Then you can drive the 80 all day at 10mpg with a smile, cuz you know its not an everyday thing....your 40mpg Honda is.



:doh:. Also what gear 4.88, 5.29 would net me better MPG's with motor at highwway speeds. Now Im at aroud 12-13 city,highway.

thanks for any input

:cheers:


Thats hard to answer so think about this.

You cant escape it. Your either increasing load, that requires more fuel to compensate. Or your turning more rpm's that burn more fuel as a result.
 
Ok you guys have answered alot for me, Ok Il try to describe more what Im looking for based on your guys help, my truck now seems to be at about 2700 in the 70ish mph range, if I could keep that or stay close + or minus 1 or 2 hundred RPM, what gear should I use 488 or 529 with the 35" tire?I wish I was better at math, I dont rock crawl, but would rather have too much gear than not enough, tire size is alot easier to change than another set of gears. Thanks all.

:cheers:
 
Hilux, I know the 3FE and 1FZ power is close in the RPM range I just thought they had a little bit of a higher redline(maybe 4800) or so. Thanks for input. :cheers:
 
if I could keep that or stay close + or minus 1 or 2 hundred RPM, what gear should I use 488 or 529 with the 35" tire?

4.88

You want to go from 33 to 35" tires = 6% increase in diameter. You have 4.56 gears now. 4.56*1.06 = 4.83
 
If I could make a suggestion - how about instead of all those what-if's, just keep it simple and aim to keep your truck's final drive ratio as close to stock as possible. With 35's, your diffs would theoretically need to be geared at 4.64 to correct for the tires. You're really close to that now, with your 4.56's.

That may be a terrible suggestion . Your truck was not built for the aerodynamic reduction of a lift, the weight and rolling resistance of 35" tires, nor the usage for which you may intend. The low RPM in overdrive of a big inline six is not well tuned for a heavy modified truck. Hell, with a 3FE your engine wasn't even designed for your truck.

There are no set formulas here. It is a "what if" every bit as much as the lift, tires, and "armor" you choose. I know far more people who ended up disappointed with "back to stock gearing" than I have ever heard complain of having gone "too low". In fact, in 10 years, I have never heard one person complain of going to low.

But there is still an easy answer on this thread...
 
Ok you guys have answered alot for me, Ok Il try to describe more what Im looking for based on your guys help, my truck now seems to be at about 2700 in the 70ish mph range, if I could keep that or stay close + or minus 1 or 2 hundred RPM, what gear should I use 488 or 529 with the 35" tire?I wish I was better at math, I dont rock crawl, but would rather have too much gear than not enough, tire size is alot easier to change than another set of gears. Thanks all.

:cheers:

You are really 2,700 @ 70 mph with 4.56? And you want to stay within 100-200 RPM? And you don't crawl?

4.88. Don't even consider 5.29 unless you like how your truck drives @ ~65 mph with overdrive off. The '88's will give you some reduction and keep you close to the 33's/4.56 you have now.

Read my comments with this in mind: most people will not like 5.29 with 35's, because the 80 cruises nicely at 75 mph even on 35's, and 5.29's are not 75 mph friendly for a road biased rig.

In fact, if you want 35's just get them. Until you can prove that you hate the 4.56's I'm not sure you even need a regear. 4.88's over 4.56 for a 3FE is a lot of money for lipstick on a pig. It's not like that thing is going to get up and run because you added 250 RPM in overdrive.
 
Nay your right, didnt even consider all the added weight and height increasement factors. F it, gonna do 529's. Just have to turn up the Scion unit alittle louder to drown out the 3FE redlining down the road:eek:. Maybe I'll look for some rocks to crawl over!!

:cheers:
 
To each his own, but I have a 3fe with 5.29s and 35s and love it. I mostly drive in town, but have taken trips a few hundred miles away mostly freeway at 70+mph and like the power increase. I really doubt you'll see a MPG change in either case unless you're lugging the engine now. I wouldn't bother regearing for one ratio.
 
therealratfink,

Thats what Im looking for, 3FE guys with 529 experience. Any pics of your home brew sliders?

:cheers:
 
therealratfink,

Thats what Im looking for, 3FE guys with 529 experience. Any pics of your home brew sliders?

:cheers:

My sliders are fugly but functional. LOL

Built them out of what I could find at the s**** yard. I realized I have no pics in crawl mode, only people moving mode with steps attached. Here's a couple pics and a short ****py video. (save the damage multiplier cracks, LOL)

IMG00137.jpg


IMG00144.jpg


 
Incase you're curious, the chrome rings come off for crawling and pop back on to cover all the rash afterwards so I can look pretty in town. LOL
 
I did the chrome rings!
 
That may be a terrible suggestion . Your truck was not built for the aerodynamic reduction of a lift, the weight and rolling resistance of 35" tires...

Point taken.

In fact, if you want 35's just get them. Until you can prove that you hate the 4.56's I'm not sure you even need a regear. 4.88's over 4.56 for a 3FE is a lot of money for lipstick on a pig.

That was what I was actually thinking, although I wasn't forward enough to say it. I tried to hint in my first post that he should just keep his current gears but I don't think that was the advice he wanted anyway. :meh:
 
When I suggest 5.29's I get a bunch of "you're crazy, go 4.88" and when I suggest 4.88 it's "f'it, I'm going 5.29". Now I know how to respond to these threads :D
 
Back
Top Bottom