Water pump impeller?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Mar 21, 2004
Threads
7
Messages
29
Any of you guys have a thought on this issue? I rebuilt my 2F engine last summer, used SOR kits and head gasket. Since then the engine runs hotter than it did pre-rebuild. It starts off fine, but say I run 5 miles, shut down and restart, the temp gauge is at the hot end and is slow to come down. Pulling up a grade it runs hotter than it used to. Yeah, I've replaced practically everything (new hoses, radiator, fan clutch, thermostat, temp sensor). It acts like it's a flow issue, so I'm down to two suspects: water pump or head gasket. The water pump is 1 1/2 years old and seems to be fine (no leaks, squeals) but I'm wondering if the impeller is possibly slipping or not moving the water like it should. The head gasket was not OEM but was the SOR gasket. I'm sure it is installed correctly because I've got oil squirting on the rockers just fine. But I'm wondering if the OEM gasket might have had different flow holes.

The engine is nice and tight, good increase in power, oil pressure is high (in limit). I did have the block bored for the oversized pistons, but I can't imagine the slight increase in cylinder size increasing the engine heat that much.

Whatcha think? Replace the water pump?
 
Impeller can't slip or otherwise fail to spin and move water. If it is not leaking at the seal or wobbling at the fan (pulley/shaft)) then it;s fine.

I'd check the rad forst. I know you said it's new. I spent a LOT of time trying to figure out a cooling problem on a rig when I ignored the rad becasue the customer assured me it was new form the deler just a few months old. After a lot of frustrationI discovered that the rad was largely clogged.

Don't assume that your gauge is correct either.

Increase in displacement or compression wil not inceare operating temp enough to notice.


Mark...
 
Thanks Mark. I understand impeller slip is rare, but thought it would fit the symptom. All of my efforts were incremental. Ran it after rebuild and noticed the temp was running hotter. Checked and changed thermostat. No dif. Changed sensor, flushed radiator (thought maybe there might be residue from the machine shop in the block sleeve). No dif. Replaced radiator. No dif. Rebuilt fan clutch. No dif. Replaced fan clutch. No dif.

All of these things helped the cooling system, but didn't change the behavior. It did stop for awhile when the manifold gasket cracked and number 5 cylinder was pulling air and wasn't firing well, but after I replaced the gasket and got all 6 cylinders hot the temp problem reappeared. It could be the gauge, but it wasn't acting this way before the rebuild.
 
You might try the old standby: Boil the thermostat in water with a temp gauge to check if it opens at the right temp.

If you have access to an infared temp guage, you could check for cold spots in the radiator that would indicate obstructed tubes.

Also, vacuum leaks can cause a lean condition that increases cylinder temps.

Just throwin' a few ideas out there...
 
SOR tech suggested checking block for exhaust gas in coolant. I used a NAPA tester today and got a slight change of color to faintly green, and there seemed to be a little pressure occasionally in the system building up and venting. Not enough to turn the test yellow, but maybe enough to add that extra bit of heat. Ran a control test on my FJ55 and didn't get any color change.

So . . . looks like a head gasket replacement. OEM this time.
 
Radiator cap?


What is the condition and # rating of the one that you are using?


If the cap is bad, the system will not pressurize, and subsequently will run hotter....



I would hook up a GOOD mechanical or electrical temp gauge along with your stock gauge and see what is going on.....Toyota instruments, while typically accurate in the broadest application of that word, are not something that I would look at as Hoyle, rather, a suggestion of what could be going on with your engine at any given moment.

Just another idea....


Good luck!


-Steve
 
Radiator cap is new, Japanese, 0.9 (12.8 lb).

It's behaving like it is right on the edge of ability to transfer the heat. Either too much in or not enough out; add a little bit more and it can't quite handle it. Runs hotter pulling uphill than before, temp edges up at stoplights, comes down slower. And this is before it hits 110 outside this summer! If it had done anything like this before the rebuild I would think it was normal, but this is new behavior.

Kinda like the wife, when she starts acting differently? Better find out why or something is gonna blow sooner or later. For now I'll go with the head gasket theory. At least I'll get an OEM gasket in there and ease my mind that I'm not burning my way to a bigger problem. Thanks for all the ideas.

- Bob
 
Before you change the head gasket, check what the anti-freeze to water ratio is. If too much on the anti-freeze side, that can add cooling difficulties since anti-freeze doesn't transfer heat as well as water. Too much water and corrosion protection goes down a factor.

Check the ratio after the head gasket change, too.

Lobbing more ideas. :D
 
Did you put both gaskets on the T-stat when you replaced it? There's a second gasket that goes on top of the T-stat. It's rubber, and it's a circle. If you leave this off, you get strange heating/cooling issues.
 
Replaced head gasket with OEM, pulled water pump and thermostat and checked both while I was in there, flushed rad. Everything ok and back in place with all the gaskets, and it seems to be running cooler and behaving better now. It still cycles up and down, though, and maybe that's normal - now anyway, it didn't before. I'd be interested to know what's normal for your 2F.

Here's what it does: driving at steady speed and slope, gauge holds about 1-2 needles above lower hash. Stop and idle and it rises 1-3 needles. Resume driving and it drops to the lower hash or one needle below for awhile, then slowly rises to "normal" of 1 above. Same on a good slope. It reads a couple of needles higher when pulling up, then drops to the lower hash or below when the slope flattens. Turn around and drive down slope and the gauge reads about 2 needles below the hash until the slope flattens and starts pulling some weight again.

I can live with a mildly manic-depressive gauge as long as it stays well within the comfort zone. It'll be interesting to see what it does as the summer comes on. I'm going to follow up on Mark & Poser's excellent suggestion and get some real numbers with an accurate gauge. I'm also going to thin the dilution a little on the anti-freeze. Hadn't thought of that, but I am sure it is above 50/50 (you know Costco makes you buy two bottles). Thanks!
 
What about your fan, fan clutch, and shroud. Seems like some of your cooling issues hhave to do with cooling at idle. I ran for a month without my fan shroud and the temperature SKYROCKETS when you come off the interstate and sit at a stoplight. The fan just can't pull enough air through the radiator without the shroud. I just put my shroud back on and it seems to be back to normal.
 
Bob D said:
I'd be interested to know what's normal for your 2F.


\___II___I__/

With the stock gauge, it's pretty steady on the red mark after engine warm-up. Since the stock temp gauge does not deflect instantaneously (it has to absorb or dissipate a certain amount of heat before its conductivity changes), I suspect that a good gauge would likely show some degree of cycling, but probably not much unless it's in some really cold ambient temps.

For what it's worth, the emissions FSM says that the left-most mark on the gauge ("\" above) is supposed to be 122 deg. F. The computer triggers certain emissions functions at that temperature. Based on what my emissions junk is doing, my gauge appears to be fairly well calibrated at that mark and temperature.
 
OK, I rigged a new temperature gauge in the head socket and put it through the drive up the mountain road out back (~35-40 mph). Here's the temps:

Normal idle and flat drive - 185 - 190
Pull up grade - 195 - 205
idle after pull - 210
turn around and drive down - comes down to 185

I've gotta think that's too high with no real load and ambient temp at 80 degrees. I checked various surface temps after I got home and read about 190 - 195 on the plug side of the head (same as gauge), same at top of radiator. Outlet hose at bottom of radiator is about 155 so it seems to be doing its job.

I'm out of ideas, other than dropping in another water pump and seeing what gives. I'm wondering if I have a micro crack in the head or block. Ohhh, that's an ugly thought.
 
Back
Top Bottom