tiree selection advice for my specific usage

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Aug 15, 2007
Threads
2
Messages
73
Location
Wilmington NC
tire selection advice for my specific usage

Hi folks, looking for some advice on tire selection for my specific needs. I did a search but didn't come up with any real info.

First, I live on the coast. A majority of the time I'll be encountering soft beach type sand. However, as you start getting away from the coast the sand turns to mud and/or clay.

My usage, I'm not a hardcore wheeler. But, I do quite a bit of bass fishing. Being on the coast there is only a couple lakes accessible by road that have boat ramps. Many of the lakes/ponds I fish are back in the woods so I have to do a bit of wheeling to get to them. There are times when I'll tow either of my boats(one 12' the other 17') and launch them. Generally these aren't the best conditions to launch a boat, such as down in an embankment where a boat hasn't been launched before. Putting the boat in usually isn't the tough part, getting it out is.

My question is, what type of tire would you recommend for my usage? Since I encounter some mud/clay would you recommend a mud tire? Or would you recommend a all terrain for the sand I predominantly encounter?

I know that a mud tire can be used in the sand if conscious about digging in. I also know that most A/t's can be pretty much useless in the mud. So which would you go with given my usage?

Thanks
 
Last edited:
I'd go with a bfg mt type tread - you'll sacrifice some noise and mileage compared to an AT, but if you're going to encounter clay an AT won't cut it.

You might check out Cooper S/Ts (not STTs). They are an all terrain, but if you get an LT size instead of a P metric the tread pattern is much wider and fairly agressive. A lot of the local farmers use them on their daily driver trucks that also see wet field use. Again not a true MT, but if on road manners are important it might be a good compromise.
 
With mud and sand you pretty much cant have your cake and eat it too, both require I'd say different approaches. Mud with a hard bottom you need to get through the goo to get a hold on traction a narrow tire, Sand is the opposite, dig to China and your high centered. A wide tire is needed.



Sand is one place you need flotation, BFG AT will give you great life, ride and when you need it it will be there, AT's float better than MT, consider traction diffs and you can get away with most any tire.

Sis has house in Wilmington, friend lives on ICW, used to call Richlands my home and drove to Wilmington everyday...................... :crybaby: IheartILM :crybaby:

me and I40 go waaay back!


Carolina beach ;)
 
Last edited:
I've only had the truck a month so I have been using it as a DD, but I have other vehicles so I'm not overly concerned about that aspect.

I do go fishing at least 1-2 times a week, sometimes more.

I'll be honest, I really like the look of the mud tires. But I don't want to let that sway my decision. I also don't want anyone to get the impression I'm looking for someone to talk me into the muds.

I've heard people say that even the aggressive A/t's such as the BFG's are useless in mud. I would hate to get in a situation where i got stuck because I had the wrong tire for the job. Of course that applies to mud tires in the sand as well.

I will say this though, when I'm out there I try to use common sense and good judgment. I'm not going through any mud holes or any areas that look suspect especially when towing a boat. My goal is to go fishing, not to see if I can get through a mud hole with my boat. Sometimes though there just isn't any other way around it, it's either go through the mud hole or somewhere else.

Anyone make any good paddle tires in a 285/75/16? :flipoff2:
 
I've heard people say that even the aggressive A/t's such as the BFG's are useless in mud. I would hate to get in a situation where i got stuck because I had the wrong tire for the job. Of course that applies to mud tires in the sand as well.
:

If this is your objective BFG A/T's will do fine and last a long time. I've gone through many a mud pit with BFG A/T's. If you're not concerned about longevity (20-30k miles) consider the Toyo M/T. The street manners are good but they're a lighter mud tire. I have experience with both of those mentioned, the BFG A/T will last a lot longer and ride a bit smoother but it's hard to beat the traction and look of the Toyo M/T's.

Last weekend I saw BFG's new M/T tire, pretty similar in tread pattern aggressiveness to the Toyo. The sidewall wasn't as impressive though. I had heard they have a mileage warranty...haven't checked it out.
 
Last edited:
I've heard people say that even the aggressive A/t's such as the BFG's are useless in mud. I would hate to get in a situation where i got stuck because I had the wrong tire for the job. Of course that applies to mud tires in the sand as well.


1: At's....NO at's are gonna be good in mud


and 2: :lol: I didn't know such a, "one tread fits all" tire existed.

Were all looking for that one :lol: you couldn't have picked more opposite sides of the spectrum with mud and sand!
 
1: At's....NO at's are gonna be good in mud


and 2: :lol: I didn't know such a, "one tread fits all" tire existed.

Were all looking for that one :lol: you couldn't have picked more opposite sides of the spectrum with mud and sand!


Definitely a world apart between the two which is why I asked.

MoJ is probably correct though, something like a BFG A/T is probably my best bet. Especially considering my usage is probably 80/20 sand to mud. Slightly more or slighty less depending on where and when.

One thought though, what about a compromise? How about a wide mud tire like a 305/70? It would get me more floatation especially when aired down for the sand, but still be good in the slop. A wide mud might not dig down as well as a more narrow tire but would still work fine, no?

Small world, I live near Monkey Junction and work for the Town of Carolina Beach!
 
One thought though, what about a compromise? How about a wide mud tire like a 305/70? It would get me more floatation especially when aired down for the sand, but still be good in the slop. A wide mud might not dig down as well as a more narrow tire but would still work fine, no?


This is pretty much the way I would go...........you need the void ratio for the mud and a wider tire to keep on top of the sand, although I would tend toward the 315s to keep your axles out of the mud or sand.........well then your gona need a small lift..........then your gona need a winch so your afternoon fishing trips stay on track. (I used to go salmon fishing in a spot where winching your whole rig off the beach was standard practice)
 
Back
Top Bottom