I've lived in the south all my life, and that's a new one on me (and my people, as we say down here, are from Sherwood, TN; look it up)
What happens when your starter is energized is that a solenoid moves the starter gear longitudinally into contact with the flywheel outer rim (which has mating teeth). The starter motor simultaneously spins its gear, which in turn spins the crankshaft via the flywheel. When the solenoid gets old (this is what is sometimes referred to as the Bendix, after the original design), the little starter gear has a hard time sliding forward to meet the flywheel. This is why you can, sometimes, coax a failing starter into working by tapping on it. The vibration frees the stuck solenoid and allows the starter motor to do its thing.
This is really an all or nothing operation, at least in my experience. There's no belt to slip to create squeal. You can bench test the starter, if you're brave and careful. Pull it off the truck and lay it on the ground, or on your bench (strap it down though). Grab yourself some jumper cables, put your foot on the starter and touch the cables to the terminals. This is what happens when you turn the key. Make contact for a couple of seconds and release. Whatever is happening when it's mounted, will happen during the test. You'll be able to physically see the solenoid move the starter gear (it's really quick, and it's pretty powerful; make sure you're putting some foot pressure on the starter), and hear the operation at the same time. (Have someone make a video, you'll love it later) FWIW, this was my first lesson in auto mechanics, courtesy of my grandfather.
Here's the FSM:
I've attached the whole section for you.
If your starter solenoid energizes and the engine spins, it's probably good. I'd look for another possible root cause, and maybe a second opinion.