starter issues

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
May 26, 2006
Threads
27
Messages
128
I have a 95 80 115k on it, my initial problem was i would try to start the car and i would get a click and no crank and after a few tries would crank and start. So i decided to replace the contacts on the starter and the solenoid, now after i did that it always cranks however every once in a while i get a grinding noise almost like trying to you shift gears with out pressing clutch in all the way, The funny part is some times it starts right up and sometimes i get that grinding noise. Once it starts the engine runs fine I had a thought that maybe the engine was not turning forcing the starter gears to slip but this seems unlikely being that it runs fine when it does start. Also after the grind noise i let go of the ign switch right away and wait a second or 2 and try again and it will crank a few more times then normal (maybe one or two seconds longer then normal cranking time) but it will start with out any more grinding noise. So before i take the starter appart again i wanted to see if any one had this experience and if anyone had any suggestions.
P.S this is were i got the parts http://www.nationsautoelectric.com/densoparts.html seemed like a reliable source
 
Last edited:
I had the same problems as you describe. 115K on the original starter is awesome! I replaced mine at 120K. I bit the bullet and got a remanufactured unit at the stealer. Somewhere north of $300 plus a $30 core charge. I guess its just that having the peace of mind a "new" starter is in there.
 
if you're gonna swap in a "new" starter, you might as well get the 2.2 kw (BIG) starter...

I tend to order ALL my parts from CDan...but :meh: that's just me...
 
Well my intension was to try to fix it before i replace it, i think it may be the new solenoid not pushing the gear in enough, but im not sure exactly how the circuit works.
 
I have a similar problem, mine starts everytime and there is no delay; but it does grind at the tail end of the start cycle everytime. On occasion I have released the key at the right time and there was no grinding. Mine sounds like the starter gear is not retracting fast enough. I cleaded the contacts etc, and then tried a brand new reman. with still the same effect. I negotiated with the parts store and told them my issue and they allowed me to try a new one, and return it since it didn't work with my cruiser without the grind. You might be able to do something similar, to check a new one.

Dave
 
mine is at the tail end of the start 2 what bothers me is that before i took it off and put new solenoid and contacts in there would be a delay but once it got going there was no grind and it would start fine, now i have no delay but once in a while i get the grind, Your idea that it may not retract fast enough might be correct because there is crank and then grind at which point i let go of switch cuz its a nasty sound and im affraid of damaging somethign further so engine wont strat, Im still a lil confused, Does any one know how the starter know whe to retract?
 
Also when I investigated mine further, I found that the PO had the starter changed, with a reman. When I pulled this one off there was a washer on each mounting bold between the starter and mounting plate.
I figured this could not be right, and pulled them then re-installed. After this, not only was the grind still there but there was random ticks and grinds from the starter being closer. Obviously not correct, so I pulled and re-installed with washers a bit thicker but still have the grinding, however it still starts each turn.
Talking with a friend of mine he suggested tring one washer on the bottom to perhaps aid in clearance upon retraction. Obviously this is not optimal but may work for a temp fix. Have not tried it yet since it is not my daily driver.
Like I said, another reman did not solve the problem, and i have not tried toyota one from CDan yet. Maybe that is the way to go, I priced them out and the 2.0 is about 190 from CDan.

Dave
 
I've been told its the grease getting old and "stiff" that causes this slow retraction by a pretty good mechanic. I replaced mine with a heavier duty 2.0 or 2.2 KW from Cdan and it took care of the problem. Can't remember if it had washers on the bolts. My original one lasted until about 75K/10 years old before needing replacement.
 
Back
Top Bottom