First off, you should know you are going to break the grommet. There is no way to remove the PCV valve without doing so. How many pieces, varies from attempt. Luckily there is a baffle so the broken bits won't fall into the valve train. Nothing really long fine / narrow needle nose pliers and/ or flathead screw driver wont help with fishing out.
Second, breaking up the rubber (after 20 years of being in the valve cover it's now plastic) grommet is the only way to get the old PCV valve out. You can try if you want, but just accept this fact. At this point you may as well replace the PCV valve hose too, it's brittle and will break off or split lengthwise so replacement is required 10, 20 years is a long time to heat and expand and cool off and contract. Do that enough and rubber turns to plastic and becomes tough, less pliable, and eventually brittle.
Hope this helps.
Second, breaking up the rubber (after 20 years of being in the valve cover it's now plastic) grommet is the only way to get the old PCV valve out. You can try if you want, but just accept this fact. At this point you may as well replace the PCV valve hose too, it's brittle and will break off or split lengthwise so replacement is required 10, 20 years is a long time to heat and expand and cool off and contract. Do that enough and rubber turns to plastic and becomes tough, less pliable, and eventually brittle.
Hope this helps.