PCV design changed and catch cans

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Dec 10, 2005
Threads
45
Messages
1,448
This will not come as a surprise to the parts and PCV experts out there, but found it interesting when I decided to change my PCV
in this particular vehicle for the first time.

I have wondered for about 40 years; do PCV's ever REALLY "go bad". ie: just little weighted plug with a weak spring, dirty yes, but bad??
When you shake them, old and new, they always sound the same to me. Of course, I am bit deef having been around helos too long

So, went through the usual yank and banking and pulling to
get it out; found what worked for me was to first put some penetrating lube on it; I know, it is just rubber, but it is dry hard
as a rock rubber; it did soften it up some.
Then took a long pair of bent needle nose pliers and used
the engine lift hook to use as my fulcrum; with a little wiggling up
it popped.

OK, not a big deal, everyone's done it; except I hadn't replaced it on this vehicle for 175K, and the PO never had done it either apparently.

Interesting what I found; the usual; the rubber grommet broke off
but was caught by the little oil/trash pan under the PVC opening.

What I found was that the little pan was full of sludge, about 3/16 inch deep. A bit of a surprize as I have used synthetic almost exclusively.
It wasn't crusty, but more like deep dark brown paste;
Which makes me now wonder what it looks like under the valve cover anyone have photos??

I also noticed that the original PCV had a skirt around the bottom,
also about 3/16 inch deep that extends from the tip; the new part does not have that skirt.

I'm getting to the point;
if the sludge is about 3/16 high in the little pan, and the old PCV has a skirt that extends from the bottom tip about 3/16; could the old PCV design suck up sludge and oil, and not just oil vapor/mist??
Looked like it to me (didn't actually measure the distances though)

Maybe that is why the old part (12204-66010) has been replaced with the new part??

Whatever; pulled out the broken gasket with thin needle nose pliers and cleaned out the sludge with my finger as much as I could
(no suction device handy) and sprayed some carb cleaner in there followed by some fresh synthetic (to re-oil anything that got sprayed with carb cleaner).

Final point:
I am definitely am getting an oil catch can after seeing that sludge.

g
 
Final point:
I am definitely am getting an oil catch can after seeing that sludge.

g

Excellent Decision! Let me put it this way ... whether you are sucking up sludge from that 3/16" lip there or you are sucking up airborne and vaporized oil/soot/stuff, you are still sucking up stuff that clogs up your intake and makes its way from there all the way through the exhaust. It is nasty crap and has no business in an engine, period. I'm convinced that it is much more environmentally friendly AND much more performance friendly to simply catch that crap in a can and dispose of it along with all your old oil when you change your old oil. You have just made the first step towards a much cleaner intake, a much cleaner combustion chamber, a slightly cleaner exhaust, less emissions, more performance and NO MORE PO401 CODES!!! WoooHooo. :cheers:
 
Excellent Decision! Let me put it this way ... whether you are sucking up sludge from that 3/16" lip there or you are sucking up airborne and vaporized oil/soot/stuff, you are still sucking up stuff that clogs up your intake and makes its way from there all the way through the exhaust. It is nasty crap and has no business in an engine, period. I'm convinced that it is much more environmentally friendly AND much more performance friendly to simply catch that crap in a can and dispose of it along with all your old oil when you change your old oil. You have just made the first step towards a much cleaner intake, a much cleaner combustion chamber, a slightly cleaner exhaust, less emissions, more performance and NO MORE PO401 CODES!!! WoooHooo. :cheers:

After working on my PCV I figured I would take rest on the couch;
next thing I know, I am being chased by little mechanical robots
with P401 written across their metal chest plates, all the while sludge was dripping from every orifice; the faster I ran, the closer they got.

I just couldn't seem to get ahead of them, just then I looked down and saw my feet were stuck in the sludge: sludge, sludge, sludge everywhere. Like something out of Walt Disney's Fantasia
(The Sorcerer's Apprentice).
.
"I've got to get out of here" :eek: I yelled, but no one came to my rescue, running, running, running,running, running, running;
"is there no God!!"

Then I woke up.

Got my temp sensors in the freezer.

g
 
next thing I know, I am being chased by little mechanical robots
with P401 written across their metal chest plates, all the while sludge was dripping from every orifice; the faster I ran, the closer they got.

I just couldn't seem to get ahead of them, just then I looked down and saw my feet were stuck in the sludge: sludge, sludge, sludge everywhere. Like something out of Walt Disney's Fantasia
(The Sorcerer's Apprentice).
.
"I've got to get out of here" :eek: I yelled, but no one came to my rescue, running, running, running,running, running, running;
"is there no God!!"

Then I woke up.

Got my temp sensors in the freezer.

g


LOL welcome to 80 series tech, just wait till you catch the "i wonder how is my head gasket is" bug.

under valve cover pics attached, from about 110K miles, I have seen others this is probably about average, some worse some better, first pic is where my avatar came from.
browncams.webp
valavecoverdeposits.webp
ValveCover.webp
 
LOL welcome to 80 series tech, just wait till you catch the "i wonder how is my head gasket is" bug.

under valve cover pics attached, from about 110K miles, I have seen others this is probably about average, some worse some better, first pic is where my avatar came from.

Yup, that's about average. :cheers:
 
Back
Top Bottom