This will not come as a surprise to the parts and PCV experts out there, but found it interesting when I decided to change my PCV
in this particular vehicle for the first time.
I have wondered for about 40 years; do PCV's ever REALLY "go bad". ie: just little weighted plug with a weak spring, dirty yes, but bad??
When you shake them, old and new, they always sound the same to me. Of course, I am bit deef having been around helos too long
So, went through the usual yank and banking and pulling to
get it out; found what worked for me was to first put some penetrating lube on it; I know, it is just rubber, but it is dry hard
as a rock rubber; it did soften it up some.
Then took a long pair of bent needle nose pliers and used
the engine lift hook to use as my fulcrum; with a little wiggling up
it popped.
OK, not a big deal, everyone's done it; except I hadn't replaced it on this vehicle for 175K, and the PO never had done it either apparently.
Interesting what I found; the usual; the rubber grommet broke off
but was caught by the little oil/trash pan under the PVC opening.
What I found was that the little pan was full of sludge, about 3/16 inch deep. A bit of a surprize as I have used synthetic almost exclusively.
It wasn't crusty, but more like deep dark brown paste;
Which makes me now wonder what it looks like under the valve cover anyone have photos??
I also noticed that the original PCV had a skirt around the bottom,
also about 3/16 inch deep that extends from the tip; the new part does not have that skirt.
I'm getting to the point;
if the sludge is about 3/16 high in the little pan, and the old PCV has a skirt that extends from the bottom tip about 3/16; could the old PCV design suck up sludge and oil, and not just oil vapor/mist??
Looked like it to me (didn't actually measure the distances though)
Maybe that is why the old part (12204-66010) has been replaced with the new part??
Whatever; pulled out the broken gasket with thin needle nose pliers and cleaned out the sludge with my finger as much as I could
(no suction device handy) and sprayed some carb cleaner in there followed by some fresh synthetic (to re-oil anything that got sprayed with carb cleaner).
Final point:
I am definitely am getting an oil catch can after seeing that sludge.
g
in this particular vehicle for the first time.
I have wondered for about 40 years; do PCV's ever REALLY "go bad". ie: just little weighted plug with a weak spring, dirty yes, but bad??
When you shake them, old and new, they always sound the same to me. Of course, I am bit deef having been around helos too long
So, went through the usual yank and banking and pulling to
get it out; found what worked for me was to first put some penetrating lube on it; I know, it is just rubber, but it is dry hard
as a rock rubber; it did soften it up some.
Then took a long pair of bent needle nose pliers and used
the engine lift hook to use as my fulcrum; with a little wiggling up
it popped.
OK, not a big deal, everyone's done it; except I hadn't replaced it on this vehicle for 175K, and the PO never had done it either apparently.
Interesting what I found; the usual; the rubber grommet broke off
but was caught by the little oil/trash pan under the PVC opening.
What I found was that the little pan was full of sludge, about 3/16 inch deep. A bit of a surprize as I have used synthetic almost exclusively.
It wasn't crusty, but more like deep dark brown paste;
Which makes me now wonder what it looks like under the valve cover anyone have photos??
I also noticed that the original PCV had a skirt around the bottom,
also about 3/16 inch deep that extends from the tip; the new part does not have that skirt.
I'm getting to the point;
if the sludge is about 3/16 high in the little pan, and the old PCV has a skirt that extends from the bottom tip about 3/16; could the old PCV design suck up sludge and oil, and not just oil vapor/mist??
Looked like it to me (didn't actually measure the distances though)
Maybe that is why the old part (12204-66010) has been replaced with the new part??
Whatever; pulled out the broken gasket with thin needle nose pliers and cleaned out the sludge with my finger as much as I could
(no suction device handy) and sprayed some carb cleaner in there followed by some fresh synthetic (to re-oil anything that got sprayed with carb cleaner).
Final point:
I am definitely am getting an oil catch can after seeing that sludge.
g
