Open VS Closed Knuckles

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

.......The others use the open style because it's cheaper, I'll bet.


I agree, for initial manufacturing cost, anyway. Plus it's a selling point to us "lazy Americans". It's part of the 'use it until it breaks, then throw it away' mentality that we've been herded into since the '60s. Not only on vehicles, but almost everything. It's helped to reduce costs on mass produced products.

That, I believe, is one of the reasons the 80 had such a short life ('91-'97). It was not made to those standards. It rose above the crowd, so to speak. Not the entire vehicle, but the drive train and enough of the rest of the rig was built to last, and be maintained - to last even longer. Original owners paid the price, though, they were not cheap. And somewhere, in the Toyota organization, the decision was made that this wasn't profitable? Argh! The 80 is a unique vehicle. It went against the grain in a modern market, and suffered a short life because of it's design. We are reaping the benefits, as 80 owners, today. The closed knuckles are just an example of the design of a rig made to last for the long haul.

Closed
steering knuckle is not a unique design, by itself. It was used on virtually all 4WD vehicles at one time. There are always cheaper ways of doing things, but cheaper is not always better and is often a relative term. It may be cheaper to produce, but after that the savings ends. And when the cost of maintenance becomes the owners responsibility, the true value of the design becomes apparent, especially to the owner. The age of the vehicle and the frequency of use make this even more critical. The paramount variable in the closed design was the quality of maintenance. Which prolly was the icing on the cake, so to speak, for the industry change to the open design. Labor is usually the highest line item on most maintenance visits at repair shops. With the turnaround in personnel going on, keeping the people with the experience for the older closed design was getting difficult. Those that have done the front end maintenance on the 80 know that it is not a quick task. Repetition helps, but shortcuts can lead to disaster later on and prolly at an inconvenient time and/or place.

The problems with the open design, as I see it, are first, the obvious exposure to the elements and second, the lack of ability to inspect the internals for health. It has to be sealed at some point, to keep out dirt and water, but on a open design, that seal also keeps out inspection. So you are basically guessing, or more accurately betting, on the condition of the joint. That, to me, is the same as a poorly maintained closed knuckle and not desirable for a vehicle driven to and through remote areas. I guess you could always stock up on spares as you'd prolly need them anyway since they're not as durable.




 
The 80 front end is a total PITA. I would much rather have a one ton open knuckle design with hubs (and I will at some point).

Yes, you can get good at closed knuckle maintenance. You can also get good at tending to a high maintenance woman. Neither is very much fun.
 
One thing that I do not like about the open (u-joint) type of knuckel is how they wear your tires.
Tire wear is much better (not cupped) with a CV joint.
 
I think it's important to differentiate between the durability of the two designs only among full time 4 wheel drive models. It's easy to get an open CV joint to last if it's only used for 50 miles of every 10,000 miles of road use. So, consider this in your responses. Besides the LandCruiser and the Land Rovers the other full time vehicles would be, ahhhhh...lesseee......uhhhhhhh (insert sound of crickets chirping).....

The open CV won't hold up as well to constant use. Look at machinery designed to operate on turning driven axles and it will either be closed (like a Cruiser) or it will have a boot and it will have grease fittings that are rigorously greased every 10 hours of use by a professional fleet mechanic.

DougM
 
I think it's important to differentiate between the durability of the two designs only among full time 4 wheel drive models. It's easy to get an open CV joint to last if it's only used for 50 miles of every 10,000 miles of road use....

Excellent point, Doug. Even though the early 4WD axles for most manufactures were closed knuckle, most of them were part time, so duability wasn't near as tested on a day by day basis as the 80's full time setup.

....Besides the LandCruiser and the Land Rovers the other full time vehicles would be, ahhhhh...lesseee......uhhhhhhh (insert sound of crickets chirping).....

Wasn't Jeep's Quadratrac and Instatrac(?) full time? I know they were solid front axles and I think they were open knuckle.

.......The open CV won't hold up as well to constant use. Look at machinery designed to operate on turning driven axles and it will either be closed (like a Cruiser) or it will have a boot and it will have grease fittings that are rigorously greased every 10 hours of use by a professional fleet mechanic.

DougM

I have trouble considering CV joints with rubber boots true open knuckle design. Maybe they are, but to me, they don't really qualify. The boot provides a barrier to dust and water, if it's intact, and a container for grease. It's definitely not as sturdy as the true closed knuckle, but a clear advantage to the open design. Like you say, most late model axle CV joints, whether they be FWD, full time 4WD with IFS, or part time 4WD with IFS, have rubber boots on the CV joints. Most even have the boots on IRS when the axle is powered. It's the solid front axles that have the true open knuckles.
 
My brother-in-law's 2006 Ford Super Duty F250 has a solid front axle with open knuckles. No rubber boot is covering the CV or u-joints on the axle ends. The joints are exposed and not serviceable. They replace them as part of the inner axle assembly.

The axle end u-joints are serviceable on the superdutys as they use the same 1480 u-joint on the F-250/350 as every other D60 and 1550's on the "Super 60". Even the factory joints have grease zerks as well and with the right u-joint press you do not even have to remove the shafts so $90 and 90 minutes of your time...
 
Last edited:
With the turnaround in personnel going on, keeping the people with the experience for the older closed design was getting difficult. Those that have done the front end maintenance on the 80 know that it is not a quick task. Repetition helps, but shortcuts can lead to disaster later on and prolly at an inconvenient time and/or place.

I have a mechanic buddy who worked for several years at a shop that did a lot of suspension and driveline work. When he saw the knuckles on my 80 he said "Hmmm... I've never been into one like that before. I would be interested to know how it works" Here's a journeyman mechanic who knows nothing about the closed design.

It was a good point about other equipment that has power always going to all wheels. Take a look at 4wd tractors, and pretty well all have the closed knuckle design. There must be a reason that John Deere, Kubota, Case, and many others go this route. Perpahs Toyota was on to something too.:hhmm:
 
Essentially, the more extreme the condition a powered machine is designed to operate in, the more likely it will have closed knuckles that allow the steering powered axle's weak link to be protected. An open axle as described by the OP (no boots) would not last long in a muddy field compared to its closed brethren. On the other hand, for road operation and occasional wheeling the open axle might last as long before needing service. For most people (even here on Mud) that design would work fine. The Cruiser's knuckles are designed to handle more extreme conditions for a longer period of time but do require more maintenance as the tradeoff. That tradeoff makes sense only for a few people and a shrinking few at that. Witness the newer Cruisers with their IFS and no longer closed axles that still far exceed the durability of their competitors. The world is simply becoming more civilized. Even mining operations that used to have blown out trashed access roads now often have paved and graded roads for example. Makes the operation run smoother and the owners make more money.

So, the 80 is somewhat of an anachronism but a properly packed 80 axle can take a pounding (esp with the breather mod which is a bit of a mistake/puzzler that Toyota installed).

DougM
 
I am gonna throw my .02 in I think the biggest advantage to an open knuckle design is the size of the u-joint that you can use, in a closed knuckle you are extremely limited in what fits inside the knuckle. A 1480 or 1550 u-joint is huge compared to a birfield and most new diesel trucks make at least 600 ftlb so there has to be something beefy there to take the beating. also even though the newer trucks aren't full time 4wd they for the most part don't run lockout hubs anymore so those shafts spin constantly. Don't get me wrong I've been beating samurai's for a while and am getting into toyota stuff lately and have no qualms about the durability of the closed knuckle design,however I think the domestic stuff gets a bad rap from most of the toy guys I know just because it's not a toy. chevy dodge and ford stopped using closed knuckles in the 60's right about the time power output was going up...how much power does that cruiser make again? I my personal opinion I will take an open knuckle any day at least I can look at my u-joint,axle seal,and grease it up before and after the trail without 3 hours of ****ing around
 
I am gonna throw my .02 in I think the biggest advantage to an open knuckle design is the size of the u-joint that you can use, in a closed knuckle you are extremely limited in what fits inside the knuckle. A 1480 or 1550 u-joint is huge compared to a birfield and most new diesel trucks make at least 600 ftlb so there has to be something beefy there to take the beating. also even though the newer trucks aren't full time 4wd they for the most part don't run lockout hubs anymore so those shafts spin constantly. Don't get me wrong I've been beating samurai's for a while and am getting into toyota stuff lately and have no qualms about the durability of the closed knuckle design,however I think the domestic stuff gets a bad rap from most of the toy guys I know just because it's not a toy. chevy dodge and ford stopped using closed knuckles in the 60's right about the time power output was going up...how much power does that cruiser make again? I my personal opinion I will take an open knuckle any day at least I can look at my u-joint,axle seal,and grease it up before and after the trail without 3 hours of ****ing around

The axle end u-joints are serviceable on the superdutys as they use the same 1480 u-joint on the F-250/350 as every other D60 and 1550's on the "Super 60". Even the factory joints have grease zerks as well and with the right u-joint press you do not even have to remove the shafts so $90 and 90 minutes of your time...

I'll have to look at my brother-in-law's truck again. I did not see any zercs on the knuckle joints. It's a 2006 F250 4X4 SD Diesel. He doesn't do maintenance on his rig, but knows the shop real well that does and thought he said they weren't serviceable. It would definitely help to be able to grease those joints. Jasonmt, you say you need a special fitting for the grease gun to do these?
 
I'll have to look at my brother-in-law's truck again. I did not see any zercs on the knuckle joints. It's a 2006 F250 4X4 SD Diesel. He doesn't do maintenance on his rig, but knows the shop real well that does and thought he said they weren't serviceable. It would definitely help to be able to grease those joints. Jasonmt, you say you need a special fitting for the grease gun to do these?

If the shop says they are non serviceable/non greasable I would be finding another shop that knows what they are talking about. Two complete axle shaft assemblies from Ford will run you around $1k so the only place that generally claims they are non serviceable items are the dealership.

Normal grease zerks, at oil changes I lift each front wheel off of the ground slightly with the steering wheel turned all the way to one side, spin the wheel a few times without the hubs locked in, spin the wheel a few times with the hubs locked in and then locate the zerk and give it a ~5 second blast with the grease gun.

I know our field trucks live a much harder life than most peoples cruisers (mine included) and the only set of axle end u-joints I can remember changing is in a F-550 with an Detroit and later an Arb in the front...
 
Back
Top Bottom