Oil and grease question

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Feb 25, 2007
Threads
60
Messages
2,750
I am having a lot of trouble finding a moly grease for my front axle job. I have found Lucas Oil's X-tra Heavy Duty grease and their Red 'N' Tacky grease. Are either of these a moly grease that would be the right type for use in a birf job? I can't find any info (and I'm not really sure what to look for:confused:)

On a slightly different note, I've been keeping an eye out for Mobil 1 0w40 with no luck thus far. Yesterday I saw Mobil 1 5w50 at Walmart, would this work or would it be too thin at operating temps?
Thanks
 
I am having a lot of trouble finding a moly grease for my front axle job. I have found Lucas Oil's X-tra Heavy Duty grease and their Red 'N' Tacky grease. Are either of these a moly grease that would be the right type for use in a birf job? I can't find any info (and I'm not really sure what to look for:confused:)

On a slightly different note, I've been keeping an eye out for Mobil 1 0w40 with no luck thus far. Yesterday I saw Mobil 1 5w50 at Walmart, would this work or would it be too thin at operating temps?
Thanks

I use Valvoline Palladium which has 3% MOLY which you can find at NAPA parts stores. It is the same stuff that Semi trucks use on
the big plate that the trailer attaches to (forgot what they call it).

The so-callled Moly greases that everyone else carries has only 1% moly; not enough IMHO.

I am afraid to say anything about oil as there are people who will attack me for giving my (wrong) opinion. However, I have used Valvoline MaxLIfe Full synthetic 10W-40 with good results, and also Mobil 1 10W-30. From what I have been told by Mobil engineers, Mobil 1 is made in a totally different way than the other synthetics.

I have used Mobil 1 (5W-30 or 10W-30 for as long as it has been available; my 1988 FJ-62 with 280K miles uses no oil, no seal leaks,
and no smoke. It has been fed Mobil 1 since the first oil change.

g
 
That sounds about right. The 3% Moly is also used on other heavy equipment, farm equipment, etc,etc.
It is a Lithium base grease, so is compatible with the standard stuff. Main thing is that when the grease is squeezed out of where you put it, it leaves behind the Moly. Also, when the lubricant that is mixed into
the Lithium soap base is used up, the Moly also stays behind. Will not wash away as easy either.
Disclaimer; I am not a Tribology engineer; just read a lot.
g
 
So the Lucas is only 1% moly then? Anyone know for sure? My local Napa is pretty small, they'd probably have to order the grease, and I would like to get this done soon
 
So the Lucas is only 1% moly then? Anyone know for sure? My local Napa is pretty small, they'd probably have to order the grease, and I would like to get this done soon

Most NAPA stores that I have been into stock the Valvoline Palladium 3% Moly grease; problem is, the small stores do not sell much of it,
so be sure to check the date code on the tube; better yet, open
it up, if the grease is shrunk, do not buy it, ask them to order some
new stock. Grease does go bad ie: if sitting on a store shelf for 5 years.
g
 
So NAPA is ordering me the smallest amount of Valvoline Palladium they can get, which is 10 tubes:rolleyes:. I guess I'll be overly well prepared for this front axle service. Thanks gray!
 
So NAPA is ordering me the smallest amount of Valvoline Palladium they can get, which is 10 tubes:rolleyes:. I guess I'll be overly well prepared for this front axle service. Thanks gray!

If you are going to pull the axles, pay attention to the seals
that keep the gear oil away from the hubs, and the moly out
of the gear oil.

Overgreasing the hubs can cause the moly grease to get forced
past that seal, contaminating the gear oil; seems to happen on all of them. This, in my experience, is not from ie: repacking the birfs
when everything is apart, but from forcing too much grease into
the little plug hole on top of the hub.

Of course, if the seal is bad, then you can get gear oil into the hub.

Gear oil contaminated with grease will foam, causing air bubbles
which decrease the lubrication of the gears by the gear oil
ie: the bubbles collapse.
(I'm sure someone out there can say that better than I).

When it happens, your gear oil will look like a black milkshake.

But don't panic!! It is the Moly, not metal shavings.

From my experience, this is not fatal, just change out the gear oil
on the front axle frequently; gets expensive if you use Mobil 1 synthetic gear oil as I do.

I have also used engine flush to clean out a contaminated diff;
nothing in the diff will be harmed by the engine flush, as
long as you get it all back out. I use 1 qt engine flush with 2 qts generic gear oil, run it 5 miles, drain, repeat with gear oil only, then add the final fill with the good stuff.

g
 
Cool info. Thanks for the tips!

(I really want to use Mobil 1, but I can't find it in small quantities, and I don't want to buy barrels of it)
 
I don't know the moly content, but this stuff is supposed to be excellent. It doesn't use lithium soap as the thickener, it uses some sort of clay, so it never thins with heat. I was mostly hoping it wouldn't ooze from my grease gun and make a mess in my toolbox on hot summer days. It still oozes a little, but not like the cheaper stuff.
http://www.mrmoly.com
 
I also use the Palladium grease, but I've never heard any claims that run-of-the-mill 1% moly grease was not sufficient. The fsm does not call for any specific moly grade, just "moly-fortitied grease." I wouldn't sweat the moly % if you're having difficulty sourcing the Palladium stuff. Folks have been using plain ol' 1% moly grease for a long time.

Also, the moly-fortified stuff goes in the knuckle--not the hub. The hub calls for bearing grease (there is some evidence that says moly is bad for high-speed bearings).

I just replaced a badly leaking inner axle seal last weekend. My diff oil looked like the dark moly milkshake described above. Not a big deal if you don't let it go for too long. I figure my diff just got a good coat of molybdenite as a bonus... :D
 
Last edited:
(there is some evidence that says moly is bad for high-speed bearings).

Yep, bad for roller bearings, great for sliding surfaces. Of course, I've been advised that Mobil 1 engine oil has moly in it, and engines have lots of roller bearings. Maybe it's different with flowing oil that tends to flush particulate away?
 
I had also heard that moly is bad for bearings. It's too slick and makes them skid instead of roll is what I remember. I've got my Palladium (all 10 tubes of it), and three tubs of Lucas wheel bearing grease for the hubs and trunion bearings.
 
Yep, bad for roller bearings, great for sliding surfaces. Of course, I've been advised that Mobil 1 engine oil has moly in it, and engines have lots of roller bearings. Maybe it's different with flowing oil that tends to flush particulate away?

Howdy,
Mobil 1 has no Moly in it. Call the Mobil 1 toll free number 800-662-4525 (press option 1) and confirm.

I agree, the FSM does not call for any particular % Moly grease,
I just know that in the third world where these are driven
in extremely harsh conditions, that the preferred grease is
a 3% Moly content.

The purpose of the MOLY (Molybdenum) in the grease is to provide
an extra level of protection; it tends to stick to the metal parts, leaving some protection behind if the rest of the grease is squeezed out or washed away or worn out.

Moly is not good for small roller or pin bearings, like what you find
in U-joints; reason being it can build up on the the back side of the bearing causing it to not roll; sounds counterintuitive, but that is what the engineers say. The bearings inside the birfs are big loose balls rolling around inside a cage; the Moly will not bother them; that is what it is there for.

I would not use the Mr Moly; it is not a Lithium soap base as called for in the FSM;

Keep in mind; the lubrication in a grease is IN the grease ie: it
is a petroleum product (lubricant) captured inside of the carrier;
the Lithium soap complex. This is one of the reasons you always remove all old grease from ie: wheel bearings etc as the lubricant is used up. (also of course to remove any debris, water contamination etc).

Old grease may feel like it is still "greasy" but what you are feeling is the soap base, the lubricant is gone, or at least, it is at a lower level than when it was new. Ever notice what old grease looks and feels like when it is really old? Just like wax; no lubricant left at all, just
the complex/carrier left behind.

Check out this link to Valvoline; I don't sell the stuff, but it can
say it better than I.
http://www.valvoline.com/pages/products/product_detail.asp?product=110

g
 
They "moly" in moly grease is not referring to the molybdenum specifically. The molybdenum is bound to a couple sulfur atoms in the compound MoS2--molydenum disulfide, or molybdenite. It's this compound that does the lubricating, not the molybdenum. The molecules form sheets where the molybdenum atoms are sandwiched between the sulfur atoms. The sulfur doesn't bond well with the other sulfur atoms, so the sheets are slippery. The molybdenite molecules do have a high affinity with iron too, and they stick to the metal parts nicely.

While I wouldn't--and don't--use the Palladium on my u-joints because of its high moly content, most moly-fortified grease is specified for use in bearings by various automobile manufactures. I've been using Valvoline's Synpower (moly-fortified) on my u-joints for a long time with no problems.

Palladium works great on the drive shaft splines.

Also, 96r50--don't pack your trunnion bearings with the wheel bearing grease. The trunnion bearings sit in the knuckle--where all the moly grease lives. You'll just cross contaminate the two greases and end up with moly grease in the trunnion bearings anyway. Pack your trunnion bearings with whatever you're using in the knuckle (moly). The trunnion bearings don't really "spin" anyway. They just turn along the arc that your knuckle turns when you turn the steering wheel (less than 180 degrees).
 
Mobil 1 has no Moly in it. Call the Mobil 1 toll free number 800-662-4525 (press option 1) and confirm.

I was surprised that it had moly in it, but tests like this one http://neptune.spacebears.com/cars/stories/mobil1.html showed moly in the Blackstone analysis. I think the one I was originally pointed to was on http://www.bobistheoilguy.com/. I'll be relieved to find out there isn't moly in it, I was kind of let down when I was convinced of this long ago.

Is lithium really important? As I understand it, lithium is just a pretty good thickener to make oil into grease. A better thickener that holds up longer or to more severe duty should be good, although possibly a bit more expensive.
 
Yes,
it is recommended in the owner's manual and the FSM.

Moly is used in the hubs and driveshaft yolks, but not the U-joints. However,
the 1% Moly put in many greases probably will not hurt the U-joints,
just that the FSM calls for regular grease. (I use Mobil 1 Synthetic grease which has no Moly)

But be careful with the driveshafts; put just a little bit of grease into the yolk nipples.
You will see the yolk push out as the grease goes in; stop as soon as you see it move a fraction;
if not before.

Do NOT put a pressure gun on the yolk nipple and fire away; there is no place for the grease to go,
it only comes out slowly when driving by the action of the yolk going in and out when you drive
over bumps etc.

Keep in mind that fluids are not compressible; so, if the drivehaft yolk is completely full of grease
and then you go over a speed bump, the driveshaft comes down on a chamber full of grease;
the grease cannot get out, so the pressure or force is transmitted to the transfer case and the differentials. That defeats the purpose of the sliding yolks in the first place.

Just grease it a little bit, just a a couple of pumps from a hand held gun with 3% Moly should be plenty(IMHO).

Mobil also makes a 3% Moly grease; just harder to find; called Mobil CM-P (I think the CM stands for
construction and mining)

Here is a better number for Mobil Oil tech questions: 1-800-662-4525

g
 
I just looked at the Blackstone analysis in this current thread https://forum.ih8mud.com/showthread.php?t=179260, it also shows moly in genuine Toyota motor oil. I've been told all the oil makers now add moly to make certain performance marks.
 
Also, 96r50--don't pack your trunnion bearings with the wheel bearing grease. The trunnion bearings sit in the knuckle--where all the moly grease lives. You'll just cross contaminate the two greases and end up with moly grease in the trunnion bearings anyway. Pack your trunnion bearings with whatever you're using in the knuckle (moly). The trunnion bearings don't really "spin" anyway. They just turn along the arc that your knuckle turns when you turn the steering wheel (less than 180 degrees).

Good point :cool:
 
Back
Top Bottom