Noisy starting with indicator lights?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Feb 24, 2004
Threads
96
Messages
1,599
Location
Monroe, WA
Ok, so after doing some searching, it sounds like the starter in the LX is in need of rebuilding/replacement. That part I get. Over past few days, on cold start-up, the motor rumbles & shakes for at least a few seconds before everything mellows out into a smooth idle. Calling Dan on Monday.

Here's the part that's weird to me - primarily this is my wife's ride, so she told me about the problem and I hadn't actually experienced it until today. When it happened to me, I looked at the dash to check oil pressure, etc. The oil pressure gauge showed good pressure, but the idiot light was on. The "A/T OIL TEMP" light was also on despite being the first start of the morning. Both lights went out as soon as normal idle was achieved.


Was this just the remnant of the start-up sensor check? All the other lights were already off, so now I'm a little paranoid. I checked the oil and added half a quart just for prudence, but it wasn't below the hash.

Ideas?
 
Ok, so after doing some searching, it sounds like the starter in the LX is in need of rebuilding/replacement. That part I get.

Well, I don't. Why do you think you need a new starter or a rebuild. Is it doing the classic click-click-click-click-start?

Over past few days, on cold start-up, the motor rumbles & shakes for at least a few seconds before everything mellows out into a smooth idle. Calling Dan on Monday.

Rough idle can be a lot of things. What have you tested and eliminated as the problem?

I looked at the dash to check oil pressure, etc. The oil pressure gauge showed good pressure, but the idiot light was on.

There is no idiot light for oil pressure. Do you mean the oil level lamp?

The "A/T OIL TEMP" light was also on despite being the first start of the morning. Both lights went out as soon as normal idle was achieved.

Sounds like a bad alternator to me. When was the last time you replaced the brushes and what is the vehicle mileage?


Was this just the remnant of the start-up sensor check?

What is a start-up sensor check?

I checked the oil and added half a quart just for prudence, but it wasn't below the hash.

Ideas?

Please tell us that you don't add oil every time you get some strange lights in the dash. You should add oil when the level is below the hash marks on the dipstick. It is OK to add petrol to the fuel tank whenever you want but engine oil is different. :D

-B-
 
Well, I don't. Why do you think you need a new starter or a rebuild. Is it doing the classic click-click-click-click-start?

No. So far (and this has happened probably a total of about 6 times I guess), when starting, the sound is 'rough' - kind of like damaged teeth on the ring gear? Then, for maybe 10 seconds after the motor is started, the motor shakes. Not like a rough idle. Then, everything smooths out and it idles normally.

My quick search yielded a few threads of similar stories. Some were apparently solved by replacing the contacts, others had no luck with the contacts and replaced the starter.


Rough idle can be a lot of things. What have you tested and eliminated as the problem?

Really nothing thus far, except that the oil level was, in fact, not low enough to be of concern. Haven't had any time to touch it today.


There is no idiot light for oil pressure. Do you mean the oil level lamp?

Sounds good, sure.


Sounds like a bad alternator to me. When was the last time you replaced the brushes and what is the vehicle mileage?

Vehicle mileage is ~160K. 40K on a dealer-rebuilt motor, but I'm pretty sure from the records I have that the alternator has not been replaced. We've only owned it 8 months.

What indicates alternator? I'm still not terribly familiar with the intricacies of the 80-series, so is there a combination of lights that acts as a low voltage indicator? I was somewhat surprised by the noise, so I can't remember looking directly at the voltage meter.

What is a start-up sensor check?

Just a guess really, but I assumed there is a diagnostic check at some point? I couldn't think of another reason that the A/T Oil Temp light would be on at this stage.


Please tell us that you don't add oil every time you get some strange lights in the dash. You should add oil when the level is below the hash marks on the dipstick. It is OK to add petrol to the fuel tank whenever you want but engine oil is different. :D

Since the oil light came on, I checked the oil level after it cooled down. It was not below the hash marks, but was on the lower end, so I topped it off. I know there is a lot of oil in there, and I know it's not that sensitive to being slightly low, but since my driveway is on a slight incline, I wanted to definitively rule the oil level out.
 
It could be the starter is hanging and that could be the noises and rough running. If that is the problem then you should get this fixed ASAP. There have been a couple of times that this problem has caused extensive damage to the electrical system and one guy almost burned up his truck and burned down his house since the problem happened in his garage.

The multiple dash lights including the A/T temp lamp are indications of a charging issue which could be related to the starter hanging and it could be a different problem. I would start by pulling the starter (~3 hr R&R for a 1st time DIY guy) and see what is going on. If you have the contacts and plunger then put in the new ones. If you don't, you can still clean up the old ones and get another few months while you are deciding to do a reman or rebuild. Post up pics so we can help you decide if that is the problem causing the symptoms in the 1st paragraph.

If your starter begins working OK and you still get the Christmas tree lights then plan to pull the alternator and have it tested. It is very unlikely that you need new brushes at that mileage. Mine were replaced at 120k and they were nowhere near being worn out.

-B-
 
Last edited:
As much as I know you've been waiting in suspense, I didn't have a chance to pull it last night.

But... This morning it just clicked the first three times I turned the key. Then it started just fine. I think I'm going to hunt down a set of contacts before I pull it. Probably tomorrow with the way things are going...
 
For the sake of some 'closure' to this thread, here you go. The starter got stuck again (it's always the cold starts that bring out the problem). But this time it didn't free itself until my wife called me and I had her cycle the key from off to start about 8 times. I was ready to call a neighbor to run over and disco the battery but it finally quit.

I did pull the starter and replace the plunger and contacts with the $20 kit from Schucks (they had it in stock). The plunger was badly pitted and worn. The 'motor-side' contact was slightly worn, but the 'battery-side' contact was worn nearly all the way through. The very distinct wear pattern produced a sharp edge, which could easily have bound the plunger, causing the run-on problem.

All better now.

FWIW, the cheap kit is somewhat universal, so it comes with an assortment of contacts. It has two semi-circular pieces like the factory ones, and two that are just square. One of the semi-circular ones worked just fine for the battery-side terminal, but the other one didn't line up concentrically on the other post(plunger wouldn't have seated correctly), so I ended up using one of the square ones. Also, the kit only comes with the contact pieces and the plunger. It doesn't come with new terminal bolts, which appear to be included in the factory parts?


Thanks for the help Beowulf.
 
Back
Top Bottom