Need help diagnosing this sound!

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Dec 14, 2019
Threads
7
Messages
69
Location
Oakland, California
Started off as a faint rattling/grinding sound. But today it got much louder. Here’s a link to a YouTube video of the sound:



listen past the normal engine sound and you’ll hear the grinding/rattle

Is it a pulley? Something more serious?

ETA: Adding a bit more context. When first starting in the morning the sound isn't there. But when I drive for about 5 miles or more and come to a stop the sound can be heard. Obviously in the vide the truck is in park, but I haven't tried it in neutral. I have noticed lately what feels like a loss of power going uphill as well as a slight vibration when accelerating on the highway. Also, a few time at stop lights the truck vibrates AND rattles. All these could be connected or not, just giving as much info as I can.

My mechanic is closed for the holiday weekend so I'll be taking it over to them on Monday. Until then, the brainstorming is much appreciated.
 
Last edited:
That’s pretty non-rhythmic. Doesn’t sound like a bearing going. I’m totally guessing here but... Loose flex plate? Any recent work done?
About a month ago I had my local dealer change the transmission fluid and rotate my tires. After that I did a routine oil change.
 
Here’s one of mine I’m also trying to diagnose I thibk we have a similar sound? I posted on another site and fan bracket bearing was the consensus, I hear a similar rattle in mine and yours, take a listen
 
This will be a guessing game until you remove the belt and spin some pulleys. Also start motor with belt removed to eliminate any timing belt / motor issues.
 
Here’s one of mine I’m also trying to diagnose I thibk we have a similar sound? I posted on another site and fan bracket bearing was the consensus, I hear a similar rattle in mine and yours, take a listen

Your noise sounds more inline with a bearing as it is more rhythmic. My sound is more of a rattle at a random tempo. Thanks though and I'm glad you were able to find a consensus on your issue!
 
So taking the opinion of @Ayune to google I searched for the symptoms of a faulty flexplate. Not saying that's my problem, but a lot of the symptoms match up:

• Clunking, grinding, chirping, or rattling noises from rear of engine when engine is idling
• Knocking noise when engine is shifted into drive or reverse (I've had the shifting "clunk" since I bought it a year ago)
• Heavy vibrations felt through the driver’s seat when driving at normal speeds (felt more through the pedals than the seat)
• Rough-running engine
• Loss of power at higher speeds
• Poor fuel economy (poorer than normal!)
 
Remove the serpentine belt to rule out a bunch of other things. Watch from 2:15 to 3:00 in the below video. You don’t need to remove the intake parts like he did. Use a 14mm socket wrench.
 
Remove the serpentine belt to rule out a bunch of other things. Watch from 2:15 to 3:00 in the below video. You don’t need to remove the intake parts like he did. Use a 14mm socket wrench.

I will definitely give that a go this weekend. I replaced the serpentine belt myself back in February so I at least know how to take it off and put it back on.
 
Brief update: I had to drive the truck home from where it was parked about 5 miles. When I got into my drive way the rattling noise was in full swing. I noticed that it only happens when the truck is in drive or reverse, not park or neutral. This is different from this morning though when I could hear it even in park. Not sure this moves the needle int terms of anyone's opinions, just thought I'd add this bit of context.

Ultimately, I may skip the pulley test and just take it to my local shop next week to have them look it over. Happy to post updates for the benefit of anyone confronted with a similar issue.
 
Brief update: I had to drive the truck home from where it was parked about 5 miles. When I got into my drive way the rattling noise was in full swing. I noticed that it only happens when the truck is in drive or reverse, not park or neutral. This is different from this morning though when I could hear it even in park. Not sure this moves the needle int terms of anyone's opinions, just thought I'd add this bit of context.

Ultimately, I may skip the pulley test and just take it to my local shop next week to have them look it over. Happy to post updates for the benefit of anyone confronted with a similar issue.
Mine was doing something very simiar, rattling in D, to the point if I was ordering fast food, I'd put it in N so they could hear my order. I went ahead with a full timing belt job. Old Serp tensioner was shot, idler on tensioner was shot.....there may have been one idler that was not fubar. She is quiet as can be now. GL!
 
I'm going through sound issues as well.
Changed tensioner pulley first, nope not it.
Then on to fan bracket, nope. Then fan clutch, nope. I am down to looking at the a/c compressor. The noise would completely go away when I turned the a/c on. Now it won't engage and my a/c light is flashing. Gotta be it, right.
 
Mine was doing something very simiar, rattling in D, to the point if I was ordering fast food, I'd put it in N so they could hear my order. I went ahead with a full timing belt job. Old Serp tensioner was shot, idler on tensioner was shot.....there may have been one idler that was not fubar. She is quiet as can

Mine was doing something very simiar, rattling in D, to the point if I was ordering fast food, I'd put it in N so they could hear my order. I went ahead with a full timing belt job. Old Serp tensioner was shot, idler on tensioner was shot.....there may have been one idler that was not fubar. She is quiet as can be now. GL!
Thing is, I wish my noise was just a rattle. It's more of a grinding which makes me nervous.
 
I'm going through sound issues as well.
Changed tensioner pulley first, nope not it.
Then on to fan bracket, nope. Then fan clutch, nope. I am down to looking at the a/c compressor. The noise would completely go away when I turned the a/c on. Now it won't engage and my a/c light is flashing. Gotta be it, right.
In a perfect world there would be a warning light for every single issue a vehicle is experiencing!
 
Two questions. Keep in mind I'm not a mechanic, just an occasional DIYer.

1. If the fluids in the diffs and transfer case aren't maintained, will any of them start to make weird sounds? When I bought the truck it needed fresh suspension bushings, new shocks, control arms. I also replaced the spark plugs, three ignition coils, the heater T's and transmission fluid. Then the rest 2020 happened and the diff/t-case fluids fell off my radar.

2. Do the water pumps on these trucks give off warning noises when they're about to fail? When I bought it, there was documentation of the timing belt having been replaced, but no clear indication about the water pump. So I was going to do it in about 50k miles when the timing belt was due.
 
Last edited:
Update: I was finally able to have the truck towed to my local mechanic. But of course they aren't able to replicate the sound just yet. They're going to keep it another day to drive it a specific way hoping that will reproduce the noise. Fingers crossed.
 
The noise gets louder when you go downwards at the front of the engine. Me thinkey it is the water pump, and the water pump is starting to complain.

EDIT: I have a couple of friends who have NSXs, or "older Hondas" as they like to call them. They both have astoundingly good ears, especially when it comes to the aural signatures of their engines. Your noise vaguely reminds me of what I strained to hear, but did hear, when a water pump was changed out during a TB service. Just a hunch based on this past experience.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom