I don't know what to tell you evan. I counted the pumps until the slip joint started to move and thats what I got. Using a Lincoln 1143.
I wasn't doubting your ability to count. More just wondering if somehow your shafts we're almost completely dry or close to it (I've never filled mine after a rebuild).
Sounds like it's easily a diff in grease guns. The couple times I've done mine it was just to make sure they're still full and while I didn't keep count I'm pretty sure it was under 10.
Never realized they were all that different.