Minor bumper strike (with pic) fixable or replace????

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Jan 12, 2006
Threads
124
Messages
1,109
Location
St. Louis, MO
So I return to the office last night around 4:30pm and park in my usual spot in the garage. Before walking away, I notice an older Volvo 240 (I think) backing up sorta toward my cruiser and I decide to hang around to make sure they don't get anywhere close to the cruiser (and at the time I'm actually thinking that I'm WAY too paranoid and really weird for even thinking about doing this).

Then as the Volvo continues to back up from about 20 ft away I realize it is actually headed straight for my cruiser's DS rear bumperette corner!!!! When it is about 3 ft away and I can tell the driver isn't looking back at all (thankfully there was no person or child behind this idiot) I start slapping my hand on the volvo's rear deck lid and shouting 'stop' and the idiot continues to back up without ever looking back. I start pounding so hard I'm worried I'll dent the deck lid and finally the volvo stops about 1.5 - 2 ft from my DS bumper corner and the driver looks backward for the first time. I walk up to the volvo's PS window and notice an elderly woman driving who appears very startled (I later learned she is 78 y/o). I shouted through the closed window that she is about to hit my car and cannot back up anymore. She says 'OK' and waves. My heart is racing a bit from the close call, but I'm just glad I was there to stop her and save the cruiser. I back away from her window thinking what a close call that was.

Then she proceeds to stomp the gas and slam into the corner of my cruiser as I watch in complete horror, followed by me blurting out 'son of a b*tch!".

I got her info, but by the time I got upstairs to my office there was no answer from her Allstate office. I did call the local PD, but they wouldn't write a report for an accident that occured on private property ??

I did snap a pic of the volvo resting against my corner bumper, just in case insurance tried to argue otherwise later (but it was with my phone's camera, so not so great a shot - but better than nothing).

Really, the corner bumperette is dented, but I don't know if there is anything under/behind that which I should worry about. My rear signal lens 'guard' appers to be bent and pushed into the paint a bit, but I think the scuff will buff out and I guess I was thinking about taking the guards off anyway.

At this point, I guess all her insurance would need to pay for is the guards, a new DS bumperette, and the labor/material to buff out the paint.

However, before they call me back I'm curious what is behind the buperette. I vaguely recall there is a piece of stamped metal that could easily bend. I gotta say though, even though she stomped on it and there was a not so nice sound when she made contact, she couldn't have been going that fast given that she was at most 2 ft away to start with.

I don't know what a bumperette costs, and I think I paid something like $200 for the set of lens guards (5 years ago too) and I could probably buff out the paint myself. So should I take the nicest possible route and just have her (her insurance) pay for the bumperette and call it a day, or do I take the tougher stance and demand the paint repair labor, lens guard, bumperette and any other damage.

More importantly, what other damage should I be looking for when I remove the bumperette?

Sheez.
Volvo hits cruiser bumper.webp
 
You file a claim with your carrier and have them subrogate it. That's what you pay them for. You will have the truck inspected at a body shop where they will determine the extent of the damage, and her insurance company will pay you appropriately. You decide what to do with the check they give you.
 
You file a claim with your carrier and have them subrogate it. That's what you pay them for. You will have the truck inspected at a body shop where they will determine the extent of the damage, and her insurance company will pay you appropriately. You decide what to do with the check they give you.

Oh, I'm already on that. My question was more to the point of wondering what the likely outcome will be - largely b/c I've contemplated buying a quality rear bumper with tire carrier for some time and I'm now wondering if my bumper will have sufficient damage that it will just push me over the edge.

I called my insurance company this morning.
 
You file a claim with your carrier and have them subrogate it. That's what you pay them for. You will have the truck inspected at a body shop where they will determine the extent of the damage, and her insurance company will pay you appropriately. You decide what to do with the check they give you.

x2 I Just had a similar issue, older gentleman hit my DS front flare, cracking it. I had a check for over $700 in a couple days after the adjuster checked out my truck. I will add you get to decide what to do with the money if you own your truck out right.

So start rear bumper shopping!! The guy that hit me felt horrible, I told him not to worry, he was helping me out! :D
 
Since it will be her insurance I think you will get a check either way. Worst case you have to take it to a shop to get it fixed. If so, shop around to find a shop that will work with you. When my front bumper got nailed a found a shop that credited the ~$450 for a new bumper towards an ARB. I covered the $450 difference and they installed the bumper. Never been so happy to be involved in a fender bender in my life.
 
Back
Top Bottom