LC Engine Options vs. 200tdi?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Oct 4, 2018
Threads
59
Messages
269
Location
Marietta, GA
Does anyone have any experience with both the 200tdi that came in Land Rovers as well as the various engines that came in a 40 (gas and diesel). I am curious as to how they all compare from a drivability standpoint. I owned a Series 3 LR that had a 200tdi in it and am curious how the LC motors compare/contrast for street driving

Thanks
 
The 200tdi came along 5-6 years after the 40 series went out of production and there were huge changes in diesels in them years as they became more acceptable as regular passenger engines. Apples and oranges.
A fairer comparison would be the F , petrols B, H, PZ, HZ, 2L diesels that toyota sold in the same years as the 200tdi.
But there is really no comparison against Toyota's 6 cyl diesel.
And Toyotas finest 4 cyl, the 13BT was another that could run rings around the LR diesel. Toyota always won on cubic displacement alone.
A friend had a 200tdi, he had a lot of injection pump headaches before it reached 200000klms. But they went ok offroad
 
Last edited:
(Edit: it was a 300tdi I drove not a 200. But close enough.)

I’ve driven both a 200tdi and a hzj80. The 1hz is far better to drive, pulls stronger in every gear. The little turbo on the 200tdi needed to be kept spoiling hard to get the disco moving at a reasonable pace.

That said a 200tdi might respond quite well to a better turbo and intercooler whereas the 1hz can only be pushed so far before running into over heating issues.
The 200tdi I drove was 18 years old when traded in and only ever had oil and filter changes.

It also may not stand to well with the speed limits you guys seem to have as it ran out of legs at 100kph, but once again that could be solved with some power upgrades.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the replies. I have been slowly looking for the right 40 for me and have not really paid much attention to diesels. As stated above, I used to have a Series 3 LR with the 200tdi and know how that drove, so was curious if anyone could compare that to the 2f or diesel options for the 40. I guess I need to go find a diesel 40 and drive it to decide if I should consider them or not.

Thanks again all.
 
Back
Top Bottom