I reference this (in red) simply to note the contradiction between two statements you made.
I assumed collector EGT.... I find collector EGT's to be less accurate than post turbo EGT's. Neither gives you combustion EGT's. Put the probe on the hottest runner, it will give you the combustion EGT you should be watching and will be the 'most accurate'. I find exhaust EGT to be more useful and accurate to a turbo application putting the probe after the turbo. This will give an indicator of low compressor efficiencies (like a leak in a pressure hose will cause the turbo to run hotter). I make the claim that post turbo is more accurate to a turbocharged engine exhaust temp problem. I also assume that's why the EGT is going into a turbo diesel to begin with....
Scott, you continuously ask members for data and dyno runs to back up their claims and I ask you the same regarding turbo performance and the probe placement. BTDT etc. doesn't necessarily qualify your statements. (I reference numerous other posts you have made.)
Again, it doesn't matter to me where anyone puts it. The accuracy of it depends on the goal. I like EGT's on turbo motors to be after the turbo so that the EGT can identify a turbocharged engine exhaust temp problem. To me that includes the turbo, YOMV.
with this statement IF and only IF you aleady know the temperature differential. If you don't then post turbo temp data is more of a guess with an unknown variable margin of error due to the fact that you don't know how much the exhaust gases have cooled from the head to the turbo and how much heat energy has been utilized (again cooling exhaust gas temps.) by the turbo.
Who cares? Again it's a baseline reference. To really care about 'only' manifold temp, you use the highest temp runner. That doesn't give you any idea of what the other runners are doing. The collector doesn't tell you what the hottest runner is doing, nor does it give you any idea of the turbo hot side temps.
The time of the EGT probe in the collector vs. post turbo will be the same since it is inherent to the probe design but the benefit is a more accurate reading on the pre-turbo side. (It is accurate in the sense that the temp reading the probe is seeing is what the temp the turbo is seeing.) This will tell you what temp the turbine is seeing and when you are on the edge of bigger problems. Post turbo you will never know the temperature differential across the turbo.
But pre turbo temps won't give you an indication that the turbo is overheating either. Again, it's a debate on what's more useful. I've stared at EGT for hundreds of hours on dozens of turbo apps. I personally prefer post turbo, so that a turbo problem is included in the EGT as a diagnostic reference to exhaust temps. YDesireMV
Your statement, " An EGT is a reference to "normal", it isn't accurate"please define "normal"
A long time ago, I learned that guages, sensors and 'readings' are accurate to normal as defined by an awared driver scanning his guages and understanding that a rise of 100C in EGT (wherever you choose to mount it) is a cause for concern. As a Crew Chief and builder of track cars, I can install 50 guages. Normal means nothing if a driver isn't trained. A driver understanding what 'isn't' normal is the key to defining normal. Audisport was known for their lack of guages. In fact, in their Group B rally cars (and most race cars after that), they put a big orange light for abnormal water temps, and a big red lense for oil abnormal temps. A race car driver "hello"? The Spa EGT guage has a dual sweep EGT guage with a settable 12v relay trigger. Get out the wallet, but it works well, and can have a light attached to buckwheats line of sight.
Trivia: The 2.7twinturbo from audi monitors/reads *both* exhaust manifold EGT and turbo EGT by the ECU. Why? Because, it isn't enough to use exhaust EGT for exhaust temps on a turbocharger application. Given one is using a single expensive sensor and single guage, I'd take post turbo over pre turbo anyday. It gives you a better reference to a turbocharged exhaust temp problem. And it's more accurate in doing so.
My .o2 arbitraged thru the peso
Scott Justusson