Fooling myself or clear thinking?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Sep 17, 2006
Threads
51
Messages
160
Location
Southwestern CT
So I have wanted to own an 80 for a few years now. It's time to get a new vehicle, I've found a great LX450 and am ready to pull the trigger. I'm just making sure that it's really the right choice.

I read this thread on the cost of ownership https://forum.ih8mud.com/showthread.php?t=124556&highlight=lx450+maintenance+cost but it seems to have two sides....guys that warn people about buying 80's because it's going to be expensive, and guys that say it isn't any more expensive than owning other vehicles when you take dependability into account.

The vehicle I'm dumping is a 2002 VW Passat GLX 4motion V6 with EVERY option. This thing is the money pit from hell. I have probably put 8-9k into it in the 5 years I've owned it. Also, it is the high performance model so....bad gas mileage and it must use premium.

The 1997 LX450 I'm set to buy has 120k on it, has been well maintained, has new brakes, a rear main leak has been fixed by the guy selling it to me, and the tires are very good. Other than that it looks very clean inside and out which bodes well for how well previous owners treated it. Lexus doesn't show any dealer maint. since 2001, but that isn't really a red flag if it was well taken care of by a good mechanic.

So, I can't imagine that the LX450 would cost any more to own, and more than likely it will be less expensive.

I guess I'm just looking for a little reassurance.
 
I heard those VW's can cost quite a bit to maintain. Just like the Audi's . I'm not saying I'm made of money, but so far it hasn't been bad owning my LC. I had to do some stuff on it, but I did it myself. If you have to take it to the dealer for every little thing, then I guess costs can add up, but if you work on it yourself, the cost shouldn't be bad. From what you've mentioned, it will be cheaper than your VW.
 
You have to do regular maintenance as a 4x4 - this is preventative maintenance cost and it is not cheap. There are also a ton of OCD people on this board who do way more than required.

In terms of actual failures, the driveline is unbelievable outside of head gasket failures, and the entire platform is extremely heavy duty.

Buying an Audi or VW is asking for a second car payment every month in repairs, and it never gets any better because they have weird designs that force you to pull the entire in order to fix a door handle. The best reason to buy a VW or Audi is because you can't afford parking and it will be free at the shop.

Just make sure you check the owner's maintenance records - if the 90K service was done (front axle service) you should be in good shape with a baseline fluid refill, but if not that may be some day one money you'll want to spend.
 
I have owned my LX450 for over two years now and put around 30,000 miles on it during that time. Sad to say, but all I have done is basic oil changes, coolant flush (once) and a few minor repairs, like a new fan clutch, thermostat and such. Overall, it has been an extremely low maintenance vehicle. I would highly recommend the vehicle to anyone. The only major concern for me is the potential for Head Gasket failure, but if (even when) that occurs, whether I fix it myself or pay for someone to do it, the cost in my mind will be minimal compared to the benefits of an 80.

I say go for it. It will be nowhere near the money pit a Passat will be. From what I understand (and knowing a number of Passat/A4 owners) your are not alone in your experience with the Passat.
 
I think they're cheap and easy to maintain. Fluids are easy to change, just pop the plug and refill... clearance is high enough, you don't even have to use a jack. We tend to go overboard a bit here on the PM stuff, but that may be largely in part to all the info that's available and most the stuff is easy enough that a weekend DIY'er can dig in and get her done. If you went with the "drive it till it breaks" approach (like typical Joe consumer), you'd find you spend very little on these rigs. The only thing is fuel cost (you should expect 14 to 15 mpg). If you're driving over 15k a year, that can add up.

Modifications for 4 wheeling is the slippy slope that alot of folks get into and sink some money on, but even at that, these vehicles are cheap to lift and mode compared most.

:beer:
Rookie2
 
If there is no record of the front axle rebuild, is there a way to tell if it's been done?

Sortof...Take some pics of the front axle, each end, and post up the pics. If the front axle was serviced recently and a decent job was done it will be easy to tell whether the front axle looks to be in good shape or in need of a rebuild (assuming the owner just didn't decrease and spray everything off). You could also search on "front axle" and look at some of the pics previously posted up where folks asked if there axle was due for service or not to get an idea of what you are looking for. At 120K if the PO didn't do the front axle yet it is WAY overdue...

The front axle service, done correctly, is one of those items that if you cannot do it yourself is going to cost you $$. The parts are relatively cheap ($250-$300 IIRC through CDan) but it is the labor that will get you. First timers usually spend an entire weekend doing the axle service (2 full 8 hour days)...A good shop or someone that has done the service before can get it done in ~6 hours (give or take). Not sure what a dealership will quote the hours at but it is probably in the 8 hour range. IIRC a dealership will quote around $1200 for a front axle rebuild and that won't include some things you may want done, like swapping the birfs.
 
As a relatively new owner I can't say the 80s are overly expensive to own or upkeep. I bought mine in July and have put 9000 trouble-free miles on it so far. I did go out of my way to find a clean one, and an ex-mudders, so a lot of PM was done. Parts costs are not all that expensive - the reality is ALL cars are expensive now, so at most we need to consider the difference in parts and service costs. C-dan takes the edge off of parts cost in a big way.

The front axle service is a big hit, but look at the mileage interval and it's perfectly reasonable. Not trusting any of my local shops, or myself, I'm taking mine to Cruiser Solutions next month to make sure its done right the first time. Gas costs - again - look at the difference. Remember a 3 mpg difference isn't much; so when I got my 80 I went from a 14-19mpg Nissan to a 12-17 Toyota but given the fundamental differences in the two vehicles, it seems a fair trade.

The extras that we drop thousands are are for fun, and shouldn't be put into the equation. You won't put a thousand dollar bumper on a Passat. But ask a volvo/audi/bmw/land rover owner about care and feeding and the 80s don't seem bad at all. Of all the comments on this board about care and feeding, we rarely see 80s behind tow trucks. Even with the concerns of head gasket failures - I use Blackstone Oil Labs as a possible forecaster on that, but with any vehicle, there is always the chance something will go wrong. Reliability remains paramount on Land Cruisers.
 
I'm in agreement with everyone else. I purchased my 80 new in 1996 and until this year never did more than routine fluid changes/brakes/tires (I did replace the starter at 75k miles). The thing has been a workhorse and completely trouble free - but I also take very good care of it and it still looks like it did when new (other than minor leather wear, which I'm replacing within the next month).

You have to do regular maintenance as a 4x4 - this is preventative maintenance cost and it is not cheap. There are also a ton of OCD people on this board who do way more than required.

I definately agree with the OCD people on this board - I actually may be one of them, but only after recently learning of all the things that I could have been doing all these years :), so maybe it is more correct to say I aspire to be one of the OCD people here.

Just make sure you check the owner's maintenance records - if the 90K service was done (front axle service) you should be in good shape with a baseline fluid refill, but if not that may be some day one money you'll want to spend.

I'm not knowledgeable enough to argue with this, but I just completed my front axle service earlier this week (along with new rotors, 100 series pads, and new fluid in all three diffs, and Slee stainless brake lines) and a very knowledgeable parts manager here on mud informed me that there is no recommended mileage interval for the front axle rebuild - just whenever the problem presents itself. However, everyone on this board seems to agree it should be done at 60k mile intervals. My cruiser just turned 100k on the clock without ever being done (pure dealer service until now) so I did it and it is a very good thing I did b/c it was badly needed. So if the service records do not show the front axle rebuild being done, it doesn't mean the PO was negligent. Likewise, if the records show a 90k service was done, look close b/c it doesn't mean the front axle was fully rebuilt (my dealer records show '90k full service' but did not include the front axle rebuild - just repack of the wheel bearings - and arguably a poor job based on what I found).

Certainly, your desire for mods will drive up the cost of ownership. Though I spent very little on repairs in my 11 years of ownership, I did spend a fair amount on mods (see my sig line). But again, none of that is necessary.

Good luck!
 
Yeah, the post about costs of ownership is a bit exaggerated, to say the least.

These trucks are dependable and if you are not too mechanically challenged then you will keep an eye on the truck and pinpoint any problems before they grow big.

So if you have these abilities then it's fine for you. For sure much better than a VW.

Over here gas is around $6 per gallon and I earn around $1.2K a month, which is not much. Consumer goods are 200% of US price and other stuff is also pricey. I can afford to drive an LX450 so why can't you. Yes, I can't afford to go to the dealer and I will never save enough cash for goodies such as ARB bumper and other stuff, but on the other hand the truck is dependable and it simply requires a bit of love and a look here and there to check if all is fine.

I can do it so you can do it too. Sell the VW and get the LC. You will never regret it. Trust me.
 
Likewise, if the records show a 90k service was done, look close b/c it doesn't mean the front axle was fully rebuilt (my dealer records show '90k full service' but did not include the front axle rebuild - just repack of the wheel bearings - and arguably a poor job based on what I found).

The full front axle service is not part of any maintenance schedule that you will find. I think the service industries sees it as a "fix it if there's a problem" deal, but as many have found, if there is evidence of a problem, damage could very well have already occured, therefore we've come to view it here as a PM item. The bearings on these vehicles carry a heavy load and just need to be replaced periodically, along the seals.

My $0.02

:beer:
Rookie2
 
All I've had to do to my truck since I got it was basic maintenance which would be the same with any 4x4.

If the front axle does not look like the pictures I gave you of my truck then it has not been done recently.;)
 
Regardless of prior history of a used car, I'd still budget $1-2K for pm's. And after you've gone over the car (or your mechanic) completely and everything is fine, then you can use the money for mods.

I think 80's owners fit into two categories. Those that do all the work themselves and those that have the money to pay someone to do it. Most owners are of the latter variety, and since they do the work themselves, they go the extra step by fixing it right and using quality parts.

I've heard other say that 80's parts are expensive, but they're right along the line of parts from a dealer.
 
I think 80's owners fit into two categories. Those that do all the work themselves and those that have the money to pay someone to do it. Most owners are of the former variety, and since they do the work themselves, they go the extra step by fixing it right and using quality parts.

Fixed it for ya'


FWIW, some have the money to pay others to do the work for them, but do it themselves anyway b/c they enjoy it, take pride in it, and want to know it is done right. :beer:
 
Like someone told me when I started looking: "It's a Toyota, right?" So, even if I don't know every little thing about this truck, I still feel relatively secure in purchasing it. I will do the PM and have a bit of cash set aside for up front stuff, only wish I had the space to do it myself but we currently live in a condo complex and they frown upon people tearing their vehicles apart in the parking lot :doh:

Anyone of you guys live in SW Connecticut?
 
<<FWIW, some have the money to pay others to do the work for them, but do it themselves anyway b/c they enjoy it, take pride in it, and want to know it is done right>>

Miescha - I was just in St Louis (w/o my 80) for a week on business, I shoulda looked you up!

I'd love to tackle my axle rebuild myself, but as I live on a dirt road, park in a dirt lot, have no garage, winter is coming fast and the 80 is my DD, I called Ted at Cruiser Solutions. I also welcome the opportunity for a cruiserhead to look over the whole rig for me, and tell me what he sees. As for the costs, well - I bill about the same per hour as he does, so I figure its a fair deal for me to drum up some extra work from my clients and have Ted do what he does best in return, it allows both of us to do what we're best at and it all washes out in the end. But most 'driveway' weekend wrench jobs I enjoy tackling myself. What I refuse to do is allow a dealership or shop work on it if they've never seen one before, which is the common response where am, in Northern Maine. I asked about the axle service, and actually had one mechanic tell me "That's foreign, right? They do things backwards. I'll try it, but no promises." Welcome to rural America.
 
Last edited:
I've put approx 100k mi on my 95 since buying it used in 99 with 54k on the odometer. Other than the front end repack, I don't think that the maintenance costs have been significantly more than for the wife's 98 ES300 (other than greater amounts of fluids needed).

As far as repairs are concerned, up to this point the only failure has been the windshield washer diverter valve and starter contacts. I'm not counting the dented driveshaft, bent tie rod and control arm since those were caused by poor driving :frown: I am going to have to replace the power steering pump soon, however I expect that its somewhat early demise has been brought on by over 7 years of overstressing it with oversized tires.

We also have a Ford Windstar van, which has accurred over $4k in repairs to achieve the same mileage. The van has also broken down 3 times and had to be towed. The 80 has never failed to get me home.
 
I've got 170k on my '97, rarely have to open the hood, but it doesn't wheel and I take it slow over the speedbumps at the mall.

I lusted for a Passat 4motion wagon, low-balled a few online. I had great luck with several 5-cylinder, awd wagons from VW/Audi, really miss those cars, but I couldn't swallow the koolaid on these newer ones. So what happens? My daughter's boyfriend knows all about cars, and talks her into a '96 a4, which I have to pay for. And pay for, and pay for. It's a great car to drive, but if my garage caught fire I'd push that car in!
 
Our other vehicle is an '03 passat W8 4-motion and I have to say, compared to the cruiser it is much more high maintenance. Granted, until now all repairs and problems have been taken care of by the dealer without costing us a penny but it is still and inconvenience to be without one vehicle. Owning a passat with as many miles on it as my 80 (153,000) is inconceivable. The passat is fast and it's fun to drive but will trade it way before the mileage gets too high.
The 80, however, I will drive forever. I just did the front axle service myself, it went fine and I'm a newbie. With the help of the folks on this forum you can conquer more yourself than you think. I love the 80, will fix whatever breaks, and will spend money on PM without reservation because it has always gotten me anywhere I want to go including home...every time. They may have to bury me in it.:D

Just my $.02
Welcome to the addiction,

Josh
 
Back
Top Bottom