Alright, after a couple of weeks and waiting on a re-carpeting for the cargo area to happen, I finally have a verdict on my winter mats.
First off, the Lloyd Northridge mats for front and 2nd row. I'm very impressed with the fit and the weight of the rubber. Now I know they don't have the edges like everybody loves, but overall I'm very happy with the look. The driver side comes with a hole for the factory hook, a nice plus. The 2nd row is one piece which is what I really wanted and didn't seem to be common, great coverage overall, very happy.
2nd row:
For the cargo area, I went with the Flexomats "extended" mat. The fit isn't quite as good as the Lloyd, but it is a nice texture and weight. Overall, the only thing "wrong" is that it is a bit longer than it needs to be, so that if you pop up the 2nd row, it gets in the way when you go to put it back down. This is why they call it "extended" because the regular would not give you the coverage under the feet of the 3rd row occupants.
Not a big deal as I'd rather have more to work with than less, but just something to note. It's nice that it's one piece that goes all the way up to the back of the 2nd row, eliminating the need for a mat for the feet of those sitting in the 3rd row. I also like how far it extends out wide to go around the 3rd row seats all the way out the left and right. I'll just have to trim up the front a bit but I'd definitely recommend to anyone looking for something with a lot of coverage over the entire rear cargo area.
I hope this helps some people who are looking for alternatives to the WeatherTech. I bought them off of AutoAnything.com and was happy with customer services, price, and speedy shipment.
Thanks guys!