Mine looked the same way when I replaced it. It worked fine, did not leak and did not sweat at all. Having said that several here have had that top tank literally explode open and I believe it is IdahoDoug who has speculated that the cracks are caused by people leaning on the top tank along with all the expansion and contraction that the radiator goes through in its life. Whether or not it will be a problem is impossible to predict. My rule of thumb is if I'm worrying about it, I replace it, but, I'm a worry-wort and find peace-of-mind absolutely priceless.