EGR Test clarification

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Jun 13, 2005
Threads
36
Messages
108
Location
Alpine, UT
As I'm still battling this Code 71 in my 94, I need a bit of clarification. When I performed the EGR test by applying vacuum to the valve at idle, the engine does indeed stumble but never dies. When I stop applying vacuum, everything returns to normal. Is the vacuum supposed to hold like a switch on this test? If so, a faulty EGR could be the source of my problem. Heaven knows I've replaced everything else (VSV, temp sensor, modulator, vacuum lines).

One other item that's pointing me in this direction is the fact that my engine pings frequently and my gas mileage has dropped from 14 to almost 10 and I have new O2 sensors. These same symptoms showed up a couple of years ago when I intentionally disconnected the EGR valve for awhile while doing some other testing.
 
Is the vacuum supposed to hold like a switch on this test?

No. When you apply vacuum the engine will stumble. When you remove vacuum it will (should) idle properly.

Have you checked the wiring to the VSV and to the EGR temp sensor. A few have reported problems in this area.

Since you have replaced the VSV for EGR (hopefully you got the correct VSV.... there are 2 under the intake), and the EGR modulator, and the EGR temp sensor [very rare if this failed!] and checked the vacuum hoses; another thing to check is the vacuum tube that goes through the intake. You will need to clean it out with a longish drill bit by poking it into this tube.

Good Luck and keep us posted on what you eventually find.

-B-
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the reply. I got the VSV from Dan. I'm quite sure it was correct. Also, I did clean out that little tube in the plenum. It was indeed plugged up. As for the wiring, what should I check for?

Its quite clear that the whole EGR system is completely NOT working. Why I think this is that the CEL light comes on immediately after two drive cycles following a reset. I could set my watch by it. It is not intermittent at all. So something is causing the whole system to not function. I've check for vacuum leaks, everything, and no go.

Please, pry this gun away from my hand before I shoot myself.:crybaby:
 
TWhy I think this is that the CEL light comes on immediately after two drive cycles following a reset. I could set my watch by it. It is not intermittent at all.

When my EGR system reached the above stage (2 drive cycles=CEL), it was the VSV. Since your VSV is new I would expect it to be OK but it is possible one of the vacuum hoses has come off or the electrical connector is not on or there is a problem in the wiring to the connector. That's about all I can give you to go on. Some have seen excessive corrosion on the connector to the VSV.

Time to put away the gun and get out the multi-meter. :D

-B-
 
One other item that's pointing me in this direction is the fact that my engine pings frequently and my gas mileage has dropped from 14 to almost 10 and I have new O2 sensors. These same symptoms showed up a couple of years ago when I intentionally disconnected the EGR valve for awhile while doing some other testing.

Thanks for posting this up. I also replaced my O2 sensors and almost immediately got a code 71. My gas mileage has also taken a severe nose dive. I havent gotten as far as you in diagnostic, but my EGR valve creates a stumble in idle when a vacuum is applied. My EGR modulator is very clean of carbon. I cleaned my EGR temp sensor. I also cleared all vacuum lines of carbon.

I will do as Beowulf says and get out the multi-meter, but please post up your results as you work this out. Thanks
 
Brad,
The OP replaced his VSV for EGR with a new one from C-Dan. You don't mention the VSV. If you still have the original then you need to remove it and test it. FYI, you don't need to remove the intake to remove the VSV.
-B-
 
And both vacuum ports to the throttle body are clean and can pull vacuum?
 
how does the egr system work?

From what I gather, the VSV is basicly an on/off switch for the vacuum lines. Right?

Once VSV is triggered, closing the valve and enabling a vaccum, the egr system is active and the modulator takes control of the egr valve. Right?

What and when does the VSV get triggered and the egr system begins functioning? Is it the temp. sensor? Does the egr system get "turned on" at a certain operating temperature?
 
The EGR system gets turned on by the ECM based on many variables; engine coolant temp, time, speed, air temp (I think), EGR temp, and probably a few others. The parameters have been documented many times so if you really want to know precisely what triggers the EGR system then you'll need to do a SEARCH or wait for someone to look it up and post here.

Search on P0401 for many very comprehensive discussions of the EGR system and how each component fits into the overall system. This is the most documented topic of anything here in the 80-Section.

-B-
 
I just changed a vsv that had the solinoid that had shorted out, and did not function properly. It measured 16 ohm resistance instead of 0 ohms. I had not see that before, it usually the carbon on the seat of the valve that created the problem. Go figure
 
you answered my question.

and for the record, I did a SEARCH. several SEARCHES to be exact. Hence, i began my post "from what I gather"-- gathered by SEARCHING.
 
you answered my question.

and for the record, I did a SEARCH. several SEARCHES to be exact. Hence, i began my post "from what I gather"-- gathered by SEARCHING.

Don't get all huffy surfer boy, the capitalization of the word SEARCH was intentional and was not used to 'shout'. In this context, the capitalization was intended to point you to menu options here on the forum... kinda like "FILE"... "SAVE AS"... "foobar.txt".

:cheers:

-B-
 
And both vacuum ports to the throttle body are clean and can pull vacuum?

I cleaned the EGR port in the throttle body. I'm assuming you mean the ports that connect to the modulator. Are you referring to any other ports I may have missed?
 
im in the process of tackling a P0401. i tested the EGR valve as per FSM, by attaching the vacuum tube from the modulator to the intake using another tube. idle did not stutter one bit. i then took a hand vacuum pump to it, gave it some squeezes, to get full vacuum. no change in idle. then i went and sucked the tube with my mouth. i had to suck on the vacuum tube quite hard in order to get the motor to stumble and die..but it did.

how much vacuum is required for the idle to stumble? im guessing my EGR is pretty much stuck closed...correct?
 
i went through this earlier- I replaced basically everything that the system entails. VSV, EGR, Mod...still a CE. Then my headgasket blew, after i got the truck back the CE never came back on...go figure- maybe a vacum leak in one of the seals that was replaced during the HG replacement?
 
Sonny,
You don't have to move the intake to R&R the VSV for EGR. Lots and lots of posts on this topic.
-B-
 
Back
Top Bottom