dead battery, please help

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
May 19, 2006
Threads
108
Messages
582
Location
Plano, TX
So my wife picks me up fom the airport, I walk out and the truck is dead. She says the light dimmed, volts dropped, etc. After the two nice gentlemen with machine guns got the airport tow truck to come by we jumped it off and it drove home fine. (to gilbert) This is the second time the battery went dead in the past month or so. I'm figuring it's got a bad cell that get's picky when it get's hot. Of course I drive it past Sears (it's a Diehard, about 2.5 years old) and they plug their stupid hand meter on to it and say "it's fine" and of course the company line "bet it's the alternator" I explain to them that the battery was totally dead at the airport I jump it and magically it drives 20 miles with a "bad alternator" and that it's driven fine for a month even though the battery died twice. And that it's putting the correct voltage out (confirmed by their meter).

1. Does my diagnosis sound correct?
2. To get my prorated $$$ I guess I have to get them to check each cell?
3. What is the largest "series" I can use?

Thanks, oh and I couldn't quite find this in my search so if it is a repeat...my bad.
 
You need to put in a known good battery and check the charging voltage. If it's normal, then it was just the battery.


Also, take the battery out, charge it over night, and have an auto place do a "load test". If your lucky, it's just the battery that's bad.

I assume you know to carefully check and clean the battery terminals.
 
You need to put in a known good battery and check the charging voltage. If it's normal, then it was just the battery.


Also, take the battery out, charge it over night, and have an auto place do a "load test". If your lucky, it's just the battery that's bad.

I assume you know to carefully check and clean the battery terminals.


Yep, and in the process of all of the above. Thanks.
 
Does sound like a bad battery but you should check other simple things before pronouncing a 2 1/2 yr old battery gone.

Simple q's for clarity...
- are the battery terminals clean? An external jump may reconnect a bad terminal temporarily.
- "...lights dimmed and volts dropped" How much? A little is normal, completely dim headlights, or dash lights that disappear is too low. I don't subscribe to the practice of turning on the headlights before starting. I wait until the car is running, alternator charging, but I know people have their habits.
- is either + or - cable, especially at the battery end "crunchy" at all when you wiggle it? Interior corrosion that can't easily be seen can increase resistance that will only show up when you crank a high draw starter. (are they Toyota factory cables?, or worse?)
- has the bolt at the starter gotten loose? not likely but a fairly simple check (wait til it's cooled down some!)

Now, what kind of "stupid hand meter" do you mean? Was it just a voltmeter? Or was it something where they attached to the battery and created a load (ergo load meter)? That would have been a more accurate check of battery potential.

Next, is your battery 'maintenance free'? If so, likely they wouldn't be able to check each cell, but if they can, specific gravity of each cell can be checked and is also a good indicator of cell health if ones gone south.

Although I buy a good portion of stuff, including a battery one time, from Sears, but I don't think I'd take my car for service there. Your case to get proration on a battery not-withstanding, go in a little educated, sound like you aren't going to leave until you completely understand that they've done a decent job troubleshooting, and it will likely work out for you.

Good luck, Dan.
 
LOL, 2 1/2 years is about 6 months longer than average battery life in Phoenix.

-Spike
 
Does sound like a bad battery but you should check other simple things before pronouncing a 2 1/2 yr old battery gone.

Simple q's for clarity...
- are the battery terminals clean? An external jump may reconnect a bad terminal temporarily.
- "...lights dimmed and volts dropped" How much? A little is normal, completely dim headlights, or dash lights that disappear is too low. I don't subscribe to the practice of turning on the headlights before starting. I wait until the car is running, alternator charging, but I know people have their habits.
- is either + or - cable, especially at the battery end "crunchy" at all when you wiggle it? Interior corrosion that can't easily be seen can increase resistance that will only show up when you crank a high draw starter. (are they Toyota factory cables?, or worse?)
- has the bolt at the starter gotten loose? not likely but a fairly simple check (wait til it's cooled down some!)

Now, what kind of "stupid hand meter" do you mean? Was it just a voltmeter? Or was it something where they attached to the battery and created a load (ergo load meter)? That would have been a more accurate check of battery potential.

Next, is your battery 'maintenance free'? If so, likely they wouldn't be able to check each cell, but if they can, specific gravity of each cell can be checked and is also a good indicator of cell health if ones gone south.

Although I buy a good portion of stuff, including a battery one time, from Sears, but I don't think I'd take my car for service there. Your case to get proration on a battery not-withstanding, go in a little educated, sound like you aren't going to leave until you completely understand that they've done a decent job troubleshooting, and it will likely work out for you.

Good luck, Dan.

Terminals are cool, new "-" cable, starter connection good. Everything clean. 2.5 years is actuallt pretty good here in AZ. 118 degree days have a tendancy of trashing batteries in about 2 years around here. Yea I believe it was a load meter. And there are caps on the battery, no they didn't pull them.

And yes, Sears does not ususally come close to any vehicle of mine. The theory of the Diehard was if it ever went when I was on a trip...there was Sears. Of course few years ago they'd simply swap it out on the spot without trying to upsell you.
 
Brought it to another Sears and suprise they tested the battery and it was bad...10 minutes later I drove away with a replacement.
 
Brought it to another Sears and suprise they tested the battery and it was bad...10 minutes later I drove away with a replacement.

I was going to say; go to a different SEARS or go when a different
guy is working.
We all have found that the level and quality of the service
you get often depends entirely on who you deal with.

Dinks give you bad service; nice guys who are properly trained and supervised give you good service.;)

g
 
...We all have found that the level and quality of the service
you get often depends entirely on who you deal with.

Dinks give you bad service; nice guys who are properly trained and supervised give you good service.;)

g

Unfortunately for Sears, these kind of guys usually find other places to work!

Brought it to another Sears and suprise they tested the battery and it was bad...10 minutes later I drove away with a replacement.

Nice. Way to persevere!

Dan.
 
Back
Top Bottom