If you want OEM, Toyota makes a armrest cover for the passenger FJ seat that will fit. If you Google it you can find the part number on fj cruiser forums. It only comes in gray. So if you have the tan interior you’d need to color match.
View attachment 2670595
as for the driver seat that would either take a modification of an FJ passenger arm rest cover or a complete diy. Could make them out of about anything.
