CEL Code 28 but Resistance is Good

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

ArmyFJ

Lookin’ for mud in all the wrong places.
GOLD Star
Joined
Mar 3, 2006
Threads
82
Messages
733
Location
NOVA
I have a code 28 on my 91 FJ80. I checked both O2 sensors and the resistances is good (6.1 and 6.0). The engine runs fine, doesn't smell rich and has plenty of power. Any ideas of where to start? Should I just replace it? For that matter should I just replace both?

BTW how do people get around that pesky heat shield on the outside O2 sensor bung? The inside one is easy but that shield was kicking my butt.

Matthew
 
as far as getting to the outer sensor, i just did mine today and wrote about it in the thread below this one...something about o2 sensors and installation. Should be the same if both of your sensors are before that catalytic converter...not sure about how they're set up in your year.
 
Thanks on that part. I will try it.

Any one on the other part? Should I just replace them even if they pass the resistance test?

Matthew
 
Thanks on that part. I will try it.

Any one on the other part? Should I just replace them even if they pass the resistance test?

Matthew

Hey Matt,

This isnt my forte. I will defer to others here. Quick question though. How long have they been in the car? My factory service manual says they are an 80,000 mile inspect/replace item...probably should replace em. I chose to replace and didnt even do the testing. CEL 28 just like yours and 94,000 miles on the clock
 
Thanks. I will take that into consideration. I am not sure when they were replaced. So it may be that time.

Matthew
 
For curiosity I tested the resistance of my two sensors and they both read 6.5ohm, which is within the given 5-6.5ohm range. Its interesting.

I've yet to reset the EFI fuse and drive around. Perhaps I have a rich/lean issue...we'll see
 
For curiosity I tested the resistance of my two sensors and they both read 6.5ohm, which is within the given 5-6.5ohm range. Its interesting.

I've yet to reset the EFI fuse and drive around. Perhaps I have a rich/lean issue...we'll see

Are you saying the two that you pulled read 6.5?
 
Are you saying the two that you pulled read 6.5?

Just rechecked. If I hold it in place for ~30 seconds I get 5.9 & 6.3 for sensor #2 and #1 respectively, so even further within tolerance. They both start right at 6.5 and drop from there slowly. Strange though since I got a #2 sensor CEL and the resistance there is even lower.

Also, just pulled the EFI fuse and fired it up. I had this high idle issue that is apparently solved now, but it still drops too low around 3-400 rpm. I think the exhaust smelled rich too, but I didnt drive it around, so I'll let you know how it does after driving tomorrow.

Later man,
Brad
 
Last edited:
Start up idle is normal now, but my idle is 300 rpm at stoplights and such. Engine took noticeably longer to warm up as well. I didnt notice any exhaust smell.

There is definitely something going on here. I'm going do some searching on here and see if I can find a solution. I will post a new topic if I cant find anything.
 
Brad,
Not sure if this is the case with your engine. But I found this.

"The Idle Control Valve (ICV) is probably the most common cause of problems as it's sole purpose is to control idle speed and is constantly adjusting itself to correct for different operating conditions.

A common problem with these is a sticking air valve which can be cleaned with carburetor cleaner to make the mechanism work freely again. But once the ICV becomes VERY worn, it will typically cause the car to stall at traffic lights. The only solution is replacement. Leading up to this severe failure, you will typically experience idle speed problems as the mechanism gradually wears out. Eg. idle becomes too slow. (can also be caused by intake air leaks)"



at this website: Idle Control Valve (ICV)



then there was this as well:




>Howdy-I'll get right to the point, my 535i (88-auto) is idling oddly, and I am
>getting bad gas mileage (13 around town). My cars idle when I slow down, kind
>of bumps or revs a couple of times around 1000 rpms. And yes my foot is off
>the gas.
<snip>

It's a little hard to tell from your description, but if the car experiences surge in idle, say from 600 RPM up to 1800 RPM and back down again, repeating every few seconds (like someone was trying to challenge another guy to a drag race), it may be your idle control valve. ( could also be caused by an injector sticking open and motronic trying to compensate for this, resulting in this cycling as the 02 sensor sees a rich mixture, compensates with leaner fuel mixture which causes idle to fall, so ICV compensates by trying to increase idle speed. Ed.)
This happened twice on my '86 528e. Turned out to be a bad electrical connector at the valve. Visit my web site at http://home.att.net/~ebaines/bmw.htm for a brief description of the problem and how I fixed it.

Matthew
 
My O2s passed all the tests with flying colors as well, but replacing them solved the CEL problem....
 
Tyler,
Thanks for the info. How many miles would you say you had it for? I am thinking its just time for them. The engine is not having any operational problems in open loop, so I am going to try to check the connectors again and then bite the bullet.

Matthew
 
Tyler,
Thanks for the info. How many miles would you say you had it for? I am thinking its just time for them. The engine is not having any operational problems in open loop, so I am going to try to check the connectors again and then bite the bullet.

Matthew

25,000 miles or so
 
Start up idle is normal now, but my idle is 300 rpm at stoplights and such. Engine took noticeably longer to warm up as well. I didnt notice any exhaust smell.

There is definitely something going on here. I'm going do some searching on here and see if I can find a solution. I will post a new topic if I cant find anything.

Correction, start up idle WAS normal...now its back to 1,600 rpm

So strange. I'm going to go through and clean/replace the following items this weekend:

PCV valve (clean or replace if parts come in)
IAC valve (clean and test)
throttle cable (graphite lube)
throttle body (clean)
MAF sensor (clean and test)
airfilter (clean or replace)

Anything else you think I should hit?
 
Not sure if yours has this...but is there a idle adjustment screw?
My bet is that cleaning the ICV will fix the problem.

I am about 99% sure my O2 sensor problem is in the connector so I am going to mess with it and see if I cannot get the problem to go away. If not I am buying new sensors.

Matthew
 
I am about 99% sure my O2 sensor problem is in the connector so I am going to mess with it and see if I cannot get the problem to go away. If not I am buying new sensors.

Matthew

My outer connector was marginal looking. The wires looked fairly brittle and a small amount of corrosion was there. This was on a vehicle that never saw off road use, so I assume less moisture. You could have a bad connector. I'll hope you dont have to drop the $200+ I did
 
Back
Top Bottom