Battery or Alternator problem?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Aug 7, 2015
Threads
11
Messages
80
Location
ohio
So, the red light above the battery meter started coming on and going back off randomly. It's a new battery. I had a door ajar light that I thought was the culprit originally for draining the battery, but taped it up so when the door's shut the light's always off, no more blinking on and off. However since, every single day I have to jump to drive, no click, nothing it's totally dead, and the battery light is still sporadically coming on. If I leave the truck for an hour or park it and drive in the same day, it will start right up. I can drive it all day. But at home overnight, it's dead. When it's running the voltage meter is between the half mark and the 18v mark. Any thoughts?
 
You will need to use a multimeter to check the actual voltage while running. Test the alternator output at idle, it should be 14 volts or so. If you are jumping it in the morning and then it starts consistently all day without being on a charger, then it is likely a battery issue. You may have a parasitic draw somewhere other than the door switch.
 
An easy battery test is as follows.

-Pull your EFI fuse to keep engine from starting(some folks also pull the fuel pump relay to prevent fuel from being delivered)

-Make sure the battery reads at least 12v.

-Have an assistant turn the engine over while you are reading battery voltage.

-If the voltage drops below 9.6v while cranking, you have a bad or failing battery, it it remains above 9.6v, your battery is fine.
 
I had the EXACT same symptoms. So far i've swapped my grounds and battery cables while I've been doing PM. New Refurb OEM alternator as well (I have the 80 amp model). I'm going to be doing some testing once the truck is back on the road and I'll help if possible.
 
Took it to O'Reilly's today. Tested at 14 v idling, but has a failing voltage regulator. While running he tested it with me holding it at about 1000 RPM's and it was at 16 something. So not the whole alternator but I guess because it's attached it's better to replace whole thing?
 
Putting too much juice in system, he did tell me though that I can just unhook my positive cable every night and put it back when I'm ready t drive and it will keep it from going dead so I wont have to jump to drive
 
What year are we talking? If it's the 90 amp on later 80s then I hear they can be taken apart and rebuilt.

The 80 amp alt found on the earlier years must be replaced entirely.
 
I would still do a systematic check and eliminate any other electrical problems though. Fusible links, bad grounds, shorts, frayed wires...etc.
 
It's a 96, trying to find any help on here about changing the alternator, wondering if it's something I can do(versus husband) or how much of a pain it is .
 
It isn't terribly difficult, but I'd look a little deeper before springing for a new alternator. GM alternators used to have a well known issue where a diode in the voltage regulator would fail and allow voltage to pass through to ground. The symptoms were identical to yours. However, I don't think this has ever happened on an FZJ80. The fact that your voltage fluctuates with engine speed does not point to a failing voltage regulator--ALL alternators will fluctuate as you described, especially 20 year old alternators. You do have a parasitic draw somewhere it seems; I'd spend my time and effort isolating that before throwing parts at it. Did you test the battery? It wouldn't be the first new battery to be bad out of the gate.....
 
14-16 is normal, especially if the battery voltage is low and the regulator senses that it needs to actively charge the battery.
 
Could the starter be causing any of this? A few times I had to tap starter to start then for a month it stopped. I could start it everytime, it did have a couple days weeks ago where I was driving and everything just died. Put it in park, started right back up. It's been weeks since that happened. Now the last week or so it's been the symptoms I've described in first post. I have had to hook up charger everyday before I leave, however yesterday was the first day it wouldn't even start with the charger on it(set to engine start) I almost gave up but decided since it had been awhile since I had had to tap starter to try it. Voila. Started right up. I just cant figure out why or how the starter would cause it to die in the middle of driving, or the battery light to come on. There isn't any of that symptomatic clicking either. The guy at O'Reillys told me when I got home and was done driving for the day to disconnect my positive cable and then when I go to leave again, hook it back up and I shouldn't need to charge, it should start right up(because alternator wont be putting too much juice in system?). Will this prove anything?
 
Removing the positive cable keeps the parasitic draw from draining your battery overnight. It proves that there is a parasitic draw somewhere. The starter may be related, but it sounds like it is due for a rebuild anyway so doing that *might* help. The rebuild kit is like 10 dollars and is very easy to do. You can use a test light to chase down the parasitic draw pretty easily.

Remove negative battery cable and connect the test light to the cable and the battery. If it lights up when the car is off, doors shut, etc, then you have a draw. Remove each fuse in turn until you find one that makes the light go out. You have then identified your parasitic draw circuit. Post back here with which circuit it is, and we can help narrow things down. If none of the engine bay fuses reveals the culprit, do the same with the cab fuses.
 
Okay so it starts right up everytime now when I leave the battery disconnected at night. The weird thing is though my headlights dont work. The dims work, and the brights but not the regular.
 
Back
Top Bottom