Axle Rebuild Question

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Feb 8, 2017
Threads
38
Messages
347
Location
Portland Maine
Website
www.dogwashetc.com
I recently finished an axle rebuild on my 80 using OEM parts and the kit from Cruiser Outfitters. I followed the directions that accompanied the kit which I'm assuming is the same as the FSM. Everything went well and I used several brand new parts including two Toyota axles and a Nitro Birf. I also torqued everything to FSM specs and I measured the preloads with a fish-scale. The fish-scale specs were within Toyota specs however they were on the light side. For example: the wheel bearing preloads for Toyota are between 6-12lbs. My preload measured around 7lbs.

My problem is the passenger side wheel has some play in it from the 12 o'clock to 6 o'clock position. Not much play but enough to feel it. For folks that have run into this issue: do you think it is the trunion bearings or the wheel bearings? keep in mind I did use the original shim that came with the top trunion bearing. Do you think I should have tightened the wheel bearing preload more so It was reading closer to 12lbs on the fish-scale? My spindle has some slight wear but I didn't see enough to be too concerned.

Thank you for any help you can provide!
 
wheel bearings. What size tires are you running?

Seems like there is lots of debate over correct lb rating on the inner nut. I followed a conservative number (Landtank's explanation?) and haven't had an issue with it coming loose. Others have run higher, I think like 35 ft bs on the inner, 46 on outter but don't quote me. Do a search on Bearing preload.
 
Thanks Whaler. I'm running 33's and the FSM specifies a 48ft-lb preload.

@whaler is correct.

The FSM has what appears to be an error. The FSM actually states 48 LB-IN for the inner nut, then 45 LB-FT for the outer nut.

I has been experienced by MANY that the best way is to set the inner at 25 to 35 LB-FT and the outer nut at 45 LB-FT.

I personally followed the FSM verbatim, as you have done and in 5000 miles or less, my wheel bearings were terribly loose. I now follow what tools r us does and doing the 35/45 seems to work great.

I have now switched to the Trail Gear nuts from the standard stock nuts in order to see if I can get a longer lasting hold on mine. I torqued those at 35 LB-FT.

Good Luck, search is your friend on this. LOTS of threads on it.
 
wheel bearings in my experience. i had mine loosen up, probably from me not doing it right, maybe 6 months after my axle job.

tightened it up to specs on this forum, now all good.
 
Fish scales are good, for fishing. Put it back in the tackle box, with 33"s I would torque the inner to 30ft/lb and the outer 47ft/lb, bend the tabs, good to go.
 
In 25 years owning and servicing two 80s, I've had to tighten front wheel bearings often enough some indeterminate number of miles after repacking that I agree a slightly tighter regimen makes sense.
 
In 25 years owning and servicing two 80s, I've had to tighten front wheel bearings often enough some indeterminate number of miles after repacking that I agree a slightly tighter regimen makes sense.
So it is not uncommon to tighten the wheel bearings after an axle service? Do you typically torque past the recommended 47 ft/lbs? Do you think there is a likelihood that my problem could be the trunion bearings or it's a pretty safe bet that I, in-fact, need to tighten up my wheel bearings?
 
So it is not uncommon to tighten the wheel bearings after an axle service? Do you typically torque past the recommended 47 ft/lbs? Do you think there is a likelihood that my problem could be the trunion bearings or it's a pretty safe bet that I, in-fact, need to tighten up my wheel bearings?

Who said torque past 47ft/lb? Your symptoms sound like wheel bearing, if youre not getting side to side play in your wheel when jacked up, then loose wheel bearings are likely your issue.

It should take you 15 minutes to retighten the nuts. You just did the knuckle so you could probably retighten the nuts blindfolded. I would open it up, tighten inner to 35 ft/lbs, rotate hub back and forth a few times, tighten again, rotate a couple times tighten again to spec and then tighten outer lock nut to 45 ft/lbs. Make sure the star lock is not damaged and locked secure on both inner and outer nuts.
 
Who said torque past 47ft/lb? Your symptoms sound like wheel bearing, if youre not getting side to side play in your wheel when jacked up, then loose wheel bearings are likely your issue.

It should take you 15 minutes to retighten the nuts. You just did the knuckle so you could probably retighten the nuts blindfolded. I would open it up, tighten inner to 35 ft/lbs, rotate hub back and forth a few times, tighten again, rotate a couple times tighten again to spec and then tighten outer lock nut to 45 ft/lbs. Make sure the star lock is not damaged and locked secure on both inner and outer nuts.

The FSM states 47ft/lb. Idahodoug said, "I agree a slightly tighter regimen makes sense." So I am curious, if the bearings aren't getting tightened enough according to the FSM specs then other people are tightening it past the recommended 47ft/lb to achieve proper bearing preload?

I have already tightened it to 47ft/lbs so i'm just a little bit worried that I could tighten it too much.

I borrowed my mechanic friends' 54mm hub socket and I returned it back to him. Instead of pestering him again for the socket I decided to buy my own since I feel like I will need it in the future anyway. It should show up soon and I will get at it....again. I will report back with the verdict.
 
The FSM states 47ft/lb. Idahodoug said, "I agree a slightly tighter regimen makes sense." So I am curious, if the bearings aren't getting tightened enough according to the FSM specs then other people are tightening it past the recommended 47ft/lb to achieve proper bearing preload?

I have already tightened it to 47ft/lbs so i'm just a little bit worried that I could tighten it too much.

I borrowed my mechanic friends' 54mm hub socket and I returned it back to him. Instead of pestering him again for the socket I decided to buy my own since I feel like I will need it in the future anyway. It should show up soon and I will get at it....again. I will report back with the verdict.
The 47 ft/lbs in the manual refers to the outer (lock) nut, not the inner.
 
Yea, the outer is just tensioning the inner. Id guess if you do 47ft lbs in inner you may start melting up some bearings.

@cruiserhound you dont have a trail gear single nut replacement do you? You keep alluding to a single adjustment measure. If youre running the OEM setup just follow the advice in this thread.
 
Ok, so the FSM calls for for 43 ft/lb (not 47, my bad) on the inner nut. Turn rotor 2-3 times, back off until turn by hand. Re-torque to 43 ft/lb and then back off until turn by hand, measure with spring tension gauge. Torque inner nut to 48 inch/lb. Finally, torque outer nut to 65 ft/lb.

The instructions from Cruiser Outfitters, when you buy their kit, is almost identical. Except they use the same torque value on the outer nut of 43 ft/lbs.
 
Ok, so the FSM calls for for 43 ft/lb (not 47, my bad) on the inner nut. Turn rotor 2-3 times, back off until turn by hand. Re-torque to 43 ft/lb and then back off until turn by hand, measure with spring tension gauge. Torque inner nut to 48 inch/lb. Finally, torque outer nut to 65 ft/lb.

The instructions from Cruiser Outfitters, when you buy their kit, is almost identical. Except they use the same torque value on the outer nut as they do the inner nut of 43 ft/lbs.

**I could be missing something as I'm not a mechanic.
 
20180522_163048.webp
 
following the FSM and torquing the inner nut, then backing off the nut leaves you with zero preload.
48in-lb is equal to 4ft-lb.
4ft-lb is not going to be much more than finger tight on the adjuster/inner nut, and any preload you already applied is gone
 
Ok, so the FSM calls for for 43 ft/lb (not 47, my bad) on the inner nut. Turn rotor 2-3 times, back off until turn by hand. Re-torque to 43 ft/lb and then back off until turn by hand, measure with spring tension gauge. Torque inner nut to 48 inch/lb. Finally, torque outer nut to 65 ft/lb.

The instructions from Cruiser Outfitters, when you buy their kit, is almost identical. Except they use the same torque value on the outer nut as they do the inner nut of 43 ft/lbs.

**I could be missing something as I'm not a mechanic.
65 ft/lb is not mentioned anywhere in that document. The torque on the lock (outer) nut should be 47 ft/lbs.

You have transcribed the instructions out of order re: when to use the spring gauge. You say to use it after backing off the adjusting nut. In fact (per the FSM page you posted), you need to torque the adjusting nut to 48 in/lb prior to checking the pre-load with the spring gauge, then adjust it further as necessary to obtain the proper pre-load reading on the fish scale. Then torque the outer lock nut to 47 ft/lbs.

43 ft/lbs on the inner adjusting nut is to seat the bearings, not a final torque. This is where the confusion is coming from apparently. Yes, you torque to 43 ft/lbs, but (according to the FSM) you don't leave it that way. It says 48 in/lb as a starting point for the final torque and adjust as necessary to get the proper pre-load.

However, experience (and Tools R Us) has taught us that up to 35 ft/lbs on the adjusting nut will yield a sustainable pre-load with no damage, and is recommended for trucks on large tires. No fish scale required. In practice, some people have actually torqued the adjuster nut to 48 ft/lbs because they misread the instructions, and did not suffer damage.

My own inner adjusting nuts are torqued to 20 ft/lbs, because that was the figure recommended at the time, several years ago. I haven't experienced any issues.
 
Throw your hub on with bearings in. Tighten inner nut to 43ftlbs, spin around both directions a couple times. Torque it again to 43ftlbs, hell spin it some more and then torque it again to 43ftlbs. At this point your bearings are seated. Lossen the nut then torque to between 25ftlbs-35ftlbs as literally everyone on here has mentioned not just in this thread. Higher torque value for bigger tires. Then put your lock washer and stuff on and put on the outside nut and torque to 47ftlbs and remember to bend your lock washer over on that as well and your done.

As a side note when I did mine I tightened inner nut to 43ftlbs and did the spinning and tightening till I took up all the slack in the bearing and just left it at 43ftlbs with the outside nut at 48ftlbs and haven't noticed anything bad yet and it's been at least a couple thousand miles.

Pretty much just restated everything spike said, but hopefully you understand it now.
 
... I took up all the slack in the bearing and just left it at 43ftlbs with the outside nut at 48ftlbs and haven't noticed anything bad yet and it's been at least a couple thousand miles.
...

Doubt that it will be any problem. Have seen a few that were inadvertently set at 47ft/lb, driven long term, without issue. That said, don't see the need for the extra drag, the lower settings have worked well.
 
Back
Top Bottom