Auto vs. manual

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Mar 24, 2006
Threads
18
Messages
117
Hey guys. Need some transmission info. Looking at using either an A442 or the overseas H151F. What I don't understand is which would have lower gearing. By the numbers it looks like the 151 wins hands down (4.081 vs. 2.95 1st gear). Are the numbers that straight forward or am I missing something. Seem to recall the torque converter figuring in somewhere but not sure that is a real factor or not. The Hummer is auto and it seems to feel pretty low but the geared hubs have something to do with that. Any info appreciated.

Thanks,
Kyon
 
Sorry, can you explain for us ignorant folk? :)
 
Doesn't that ruin your trans?
It generates alot of heat, and heat kills transmissions, but sparingly using this technique is not going to destroy anything.
 
One major difference usually overlooked between the manual and 5 speed is the overdrive gear ratio. On most Toyota transmissions, the autos have a much higher overdrive...around .72 or .76 if you get one of the A440Fs. The manual is going to be around .85.

The difference in cruising rpm will be significant...about 15%. So, for example you might cruise at 2500 rpm with the auto, but the manual would be around 2900 rpm.

For some rigs, like the older mini-trucks that I'm most familier with, the higher rpm is sometimes better when you have a really small engine pushing a lot of weight. But in other rigs, higher rpms, just means reduced top speed and burning more gas.
 
I am a fully converted auto guy for wheeling. Unless you have super low crawler gears, I think the auto is the way to go.
 
I'm building towards having dual t-cases so low isn't going to be a problem. I just want to make sure the auto wouldn't cut my crawl ratio by 25%. Looks like that isn't really a concern. I do like the auto while wheeling in the Hummer so maybe I'll go that route.

How about transmission length between the two? This is going under a 40 so length is going to be a small issue. I will be stretchng the wheelbase so not a big concern unless it's going to add a foot or something like that.

Thanks,
Kyon
 
Back
Top Bottom