Auto tranny vs 5 speed

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Sep 21, 2006
Threads
17
Messages
39
Hai, after having my cruiser for 6 months, my 1hz engine is working well, but it is lacking the power and torque of a a turbo engine, so i have decided to swap to an 1hdt turbo engine, the current set up is 5 speed manual, my questions are should i keep the present 5 speed manual or to swap to auto a422f? If i do keep to 5 speed , do i have to make any mod to cope with the extra power? any opinion and suggestions are highly appreciated. Thanks.:cool:
 
I would prefer the auto for most of my driving needs (see the thread about installing a 5 speed stick in place of a auto). My understanding is that the 1HD-T puts out 165 horsepower. Comparing that to the 212 of the 1FZ (which typically uses the auto tranny) and I don't think there would be a issue with the power. But . . . IIRC & IMHO so YYMV. :grinpimp:

Eh, where are you located anyways?
 
I imagine that the toyota 5 speed will handle the power of the turbo diesel. There is no 'correct' answer to your question, just preference. If it were my rig, no doubt I would want a manual. Just more enjoyable to drive. If your rig was equiped with an auto, you will need a clutch, clutch pedal, slave and master cylinder, and other miscellaneous pieces. Is this worth it to you? Only you know the answer!
 
It helps to read posts before replying. He already has a 5 speed installed. Also, it is not HP that determines if a heavier tranny is needed, but torque and the turbo puts out a lot more torque.

I think you should post which 5M tranny you have and maybe someone from a country with a 5M/hdt engine can post if it's the same tranny. That would give me confidence your existing tranny could handle it. I can see no reason to switch to an auto unless it turns out your existing tranny isn't paired with the hdt by Toyota. Even then, I'd rather swap manual to manual due to the complexity of putting in an automatic.

DougM
 
Back
Top Bottom