Auto Lockers vs Selectable

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

MoGas

Central Scrutinizer
GOLD Star
Joined
Jan 26, 2004
Threads
202
Messages
2,141
Location
Gold Canyon, AZ
For those that have Automatic lockers, ie: Aussie, Lock right etc. Has there EVER been a time, on road or off that you wish that you could have turned the locker off.

On ice or slick surfaces, how are the manners?

I am trying to decide between an Aussie and an ARB and want to justify the selectability.

I have had rear lockers in CJ's and they were sketchy on the ice and one time I had to sidehill and I would have rather had an open diff, but I don't have any experience in 80's with lockers.

:cheers:
Dave
 
:shotts:

My take on it is this (and I've never had an auto-locker): If you live in an area that frequents ice and or snow, then save up for the ARB.

Especially if this is your DD, the full time 4wd system on the 80 is very nice, I can't see adding an auto locker to it.
 
:shotts:

My take on it is this (and I've never had an auto-locker): If you live in an area that frequents ice and or snow, then save up for the ARB.

Especially if this is your DD, the full time 4wd system on the 80 is very nice, I can't see adding an auto locker to it.

My take on this, living in an area with ice and snow and having driven both extensively in all conditions, is that automatic rear lockers are excellent in an AWD system. When a selectable locker is on, it is a spool. When it is off, you have an open diff. Contrary to the widely held belief of people who have never driven an automatic rear locker in the snow as part of an AWD system on a long wheelbase, they are outstanding. Offroad for rock crawling, I turn on the rear locker and leave it on. No different than an automatic locker.

So your question is really this: will you only do a rear locker? If you will do a front, it will need to be selectable unless you plan on ditching AWD. Doesn't make much sense to put an ARB up front with an automatic locker in the rear. If you don't plan a front locker, I don't think you can justify the automatic rear.

Bottom line:

Rear locker only: automatic
Front locker one day: ARB

Of course, if you can't handle the occasional banging of an automatic locker or the clicking in a parking lot under low throttle, you gotta go ARB.

Nay
 
My take on this, living in an area with ice and snow and having driven both extensively in all conditions, is that automatic rear lockers are excellent in an AWD system.

Good info there from someone with experience with them.
 
I'm somewhat with Nay, but i feel that an auto locker in slippery road conditions...IE ice/snow is a bad thing.

I drove a jeep grand cherokee and a full size k5 blazer both having detroit in the rear. The rear end would come around on me all the time in the snow. With the 80, without the rear locker engage i honestly have yet to find a truck handle as well in the snow as it. I would not want the rear locked in the snow/ice unless i was offroad and stuck.
 
I have a Detroit in the VlakVark with a locker center (due to part time case) and on snow and ice I would not recommend it to someone that is not an "aggressive" type driver that knows how to handle a truck when it goes sideways.

The truck has a tendency to let it's back walk out when you accelerate.
 
My take on this, living in an area with ice and snow and having driven both extensively in all conditions, is that automatic rear lockers are excellent in an AWD system. When a selectable locker is on, it is a spool. When it is off, you have an open diff. Contrary to the widely held belief of people who have never driven an automatic rear locker in the snow as part of an AWD system on a long wheelbase, they are outstanding. Offroad for rock crawling, I turn on the rear locker and leave it on. No different than an automatic locker.

So your question is really this: will you only do a rear locker? If you will do a front, it will need to be selectable unless you plan on ditching AWD. Doesn't make much sense to put an ARB up front with an automatic locker in the rear. If you don't plan a front locker, I don't think you can justify the automatic rear.

Bottom line:

Rear locker only: automatic
Front locker one day: ARB

Of course, if you can't handle the occasional banging of an automatic locker or the clicking in a parking lot under low throttle, you gotta go ARB.

Nay

I don't mind the ratcheting sound and the occasional bang. I did, after all have Lock-right lockers in the rear of a CJ5 and a CJ7, both with V8s and standard transmissions so shifting while in a turn or curve on the street was fun for all.


If you don't plan a front locker, I don't think you can justify the automatic rear.
Nay

Did you mean "I don't think you can justify the ARB rear"?


I have never been in a situation that required the use of a front locker. Would it have been nice, yes. Needed, no.

I really want input from people that drive on icy, snowy roads or have had an experience in their Cruiser where an automatic rear locker was a hindrance.

:cheers:
Dave
 
I'm somewhat with Nay, but i feel that an auto locker in slippery road conditions...IE ice/snow is a bad thing.

I drove a jeep grand cherokee and a full size k5 blazer both having detroit in the rear. The rear end would come around on me all the time in the snow. With the 80, without the rear locker engage i honestly have yet to find a truck handle as well in the snow as it. I would not want the rear locked in the snow/ice unless i was offroad and stuck.

Tires have a lot to do with it as well - if you don't have good lateral traction I'd agree that an automatic locker could be a handful. I think any time you are increasing forward traction substantially that you should also be focusing on increasing lateral traction, which comes predominantly from your tires.

I had a Detroit in my old AWD XJ and I could absolutely hammer the throttle coming out of a parking lot in hardpack conditions and I could never get the thing to break. I really wouldn't choose any type of locker without also considering the tires in the equation for the conditions you will see. These things really are not independent variables.
 
I'm somewhat with Nay, but i feel that an auto locker in slippery road conditions...IE ice/snow is a bad thing.

I drove a jeep grand cherokee and a full size k5 blazer both having detroit in the rear. The rear end would come around on me all the time in the snow. With the 80, without the rear locker engage i honestly have yet to find a truck handle as well in the snow as it. I would not want the rear locked in the snow/ice unless i was offroad and stuck.

I wonder how the AWD of an 80 will compensate, which is still going up front? Is the above really an apple to apple comparison? I honestly don't know, but would really like to know.

I am faced with a similar dilemma. What I have elected to do is to run an Aussie and buy a set of sliders. I'll save my money for an ARB selectable and if I can, sell the Aussie. Granted, I only drive in snow/ice about 6 times a year, so snow/ice is not a big problem for me. What sealed the deal for me was that I was looking at about $400-500/axle to set up the ARB. I'll wait till I regear and get it all done at once.

Ross
:popcorn:
 
Wow, I need to learn to type.......3 posts since I started typing my last post till I posted it:o
 
How about some of those e-lockers which act as gear driven LSDs when not locked?
 
I don't mind the ratcheting sound and the occasional bang. I did, after all have Lock-right lockers in the rear of a CJ5 and a CJ7, both with V8s and standard transmissions so shifting while in a turn or curve on the street was fun for all.




Did you mean "I don't think you can justify the ARB rear"?


I have never been in a situation that required the use of a front locker. Would it have been nice, yes. Needed, no.

I really want input from people that drive on icy, snowy roads or have had an experience in their Cruiser where an automatic rear locker was a hindrance.

:cheers:
Dave


Yes, I meant the cost of the compressor and the ARB for the rear when you won't ever do a front locker.

If you drove a lockright'ed CJ5 on snow and ice and didn't die, the 80 is a no brainer, trust me. You sound like you know how to drive an automatic locker, you won't even feel it in an 80 compared to the CJ's. They don't bang around hardly at all because the automatic transmission keeps torque loads relatively constant when shifting, and the longer the wheelbase the better.

I guess all I can tell you is this: if my 80 was open, and all I wanted was a rear locker for the wheeling I do, then I'd put in an Aussie and I just got home from driving on my still icy and snowpacked roads down my driveway that still has had at least 2 feet of snow on each side for the last 3 weeks.

And with the money I saved, I'd put a True Trac up front. Incredible snow combination with AWD in my experience. I would take this combination over a rear ARB any and every day of the week for any and every situation.

This is my previous rig with Detroit rear, AWD, and True Trac front. This was my family car (as in only one car for my family with two toddlers) for 3 years :grinpimp:

Nay
The Jeep.webp
 
Nay is correct again in that i also belive tires play a huge role in this assumption. The vehicles i stated above that i drove, one had BFG mud terrains and the other had the old school dunlop rover RVs.

That said, i can also say that the 80 wheel base is also longer than both the vehicles i stated i drove with locked rears in the snow/ice. Also, i'm not bragging, but i will say that i'm really good at breaking the rear end loose in a turn and keeping control of the vehicle to straighten it back out. . . . . . with that said, i still think a full-time locked rear end in any vehicle in the snow/ice is not good.

All wheel drive IMHO is the way to go, and stay completely unlocked (this is for snow/ice road driving)
 
I have a Detroit in the VlakVark with a locker center (due to part time case) and on snow and ice I would not recommend it to someone that is not an "aggressive" type driver that knows how to handle a truck when it goes sideways.

The truck has a tendency to let it's back walk out when you accelerate.

Christo,

I am not sure if the Detroit is different than Aussie when it comes to this but here's my observation. If my CDL is off, I hear that clunk clunk noise while turning slowly in the snow. If I hit the gas padel hard (w/CDL off) then the truck wants to walk off and slide with the tires spinning, sort of like you mentioned. However, with the CDL on I get what you get regardless of speed and/or acceleration. Also, when my tires used to be brand spanking new, I used to hear just one clunk with the CDL off in tunrs. So I guess I agree with the tire theory. Anyway, my $0.02.
 
Back
Top Bottom