I went through this last year. My 2000 was rear ended (at the time with 200k on it) and insurance ended up totaling it, but I bought it back. The route I took to getting them to up their pay out was reviewing all the routine / preventative maintenance I had just preformed. Oil change, spark plugs, fuel filter, air filter, rear cargo net, small LED light bar, CD player, blah, blah, blah.... Every little thing I had done in the past 6 months I made sure they knew about. I had printed out craigslist searches of comparable vehicles, documenting there are not many of those truck around so finding an equivalent one was going to be quite the task. I bought mine from my bro-in-law up in Idaho. I pointed out that a replacement vehicle would most likely end up costing me a plane ticket, a night (or two) in a hotel, and fuel money to drive it home, then the maintenance game all over again. I also reminded them that after the accident they failed to offer me a rental car for over 30 days (I didn't need one but figured it would only help my cause). It did get to a point that I thought the process was taking too long so I asked for a rental comparable to mine, which was a luxury SUV. After two weeks in a brand new Tahoe they became very anxious to settle the case. They offered me nearly double what I paid for the Cruiser originally. The adjuster working my case was a Jeep guy so he understood the value of a solid truck like the LC's. I hope you get a gear head working you're case as well. Good Luck!