A question for the engineers & drivetrain specialists

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Nov 20, 2016
Threads
10
Messages
760
Location
Killeen, TX
If a person wants to lower gear ratios excluding a change to transmission gearing, it could be done in the transfer case, or in the front and rear differentials. Is one way preferable to the other? If so, what makes it the better option?

Thanks in advance for educating me.
 
Transfer case is less expensive, but you only have a couple of options. Differential has many different ratios available.

On paper, whichever point you lower the ratio at, it makes the job of everything upstream easier: doing diffs means less load on the engine, trans, transfer case and drivelines. Doing the transfer case makes the job easier for the engine and transmission. Kind of a moot point in practice since 80 owners aren't twisting their drivelines apart or blowing transfer case output shafts.
 
Transfer case is less expensive, but you only have a couple of options. Differential has many different ratios available.

On paper, whichever point you lower the ratio at, it makes the job of everything upstream easier: doing diffs means less load on the engine, trans, transfer case and drivelines. Doing the transfer case makes the job easier for the engine and transmission. Kind of a moot point in practice since 80 owners aren't twisting their drivelines apart or blowing transfer case output shafts.
Thank you for that info.
 
@Marvelicious outlined the key points. Only other thing that comes to mind is that the closer you get to 1:1 for the diffs, the stronger they are. So keeping stock gears instead of going to 4.56/4.88/5.29 will keep the diffs incrementally stronger.
 
This question does not need engineers and "drivetrain specialists" BTW.


To get started...

How is the rig tasked? How do you foresee tasking it in the future? What is your frame of reference, for wrenching an for using the vehicle? What other mods have been done to it? What other mods are you planning to do? What size tires does it have now? What size tires will it have? Is it gonna keep growing in any sort of way over time?

Mark...
 
Last edited:
This question does not need engineers and "drivetrain specialists" BTW.


To get started...

How is the rig tasked? How do you foresee tasking it in the future? What is your frame of reference, for wrenching an for using the vehicle? What other mods have been done to it? What other mods are you planning to do? What size tires does it have now? What size tires will it have? Is it gonna keep growing in any sort of way over time?

Mark...
It’s a ‘94 Cummins 6BT swapped FZJ80 with 3” lift. It’s on 35” tires. It has ARB front bumper with a Warn winch (synthetic rope) and a ARB rear bumper with a rear tire carrier. It has an ARB drawer system and ARB refrigerator. I plan to use it for touring and moderate rock crawling. I talked it over with AJ and decided that I’m doing the transfer case under-gearing from Sumo.

I did more research and learned that the parts of the drivetrain upstream from where you do the gearing change have less strain on them. Since I’m not making so much power that I’m likely to be twisting drivelines into pretzels I think this approach will achieve my goals of having a final drive ratio that is closer to what it was when it had stock size tires on it while make life easier on the transmission and engine.
 
Since you say that you "plan" to use it for "touring and moderate rock crawling", I am assuming that the rig is not yet in use with the new power plant. Since you do not indicate otherwise I am also assuming you have the A442F still.

I would encourage your to forego any gearing changes until you have put the rig to use a bit. 35s are only 10% larger that the OEM rubber. The OD of the 442 is only 17%. A 6BT is not a biger heavier 1FZ. It likes lower rpm. It does not particularly like higher rpm. It's efficiency range and it's power range are in much lower bands that the 1FZ.

For the 6BT...peak torque is between 400 and 440 ftlbs at 1500-1600 rpm. Peak horsepower is between 160 and 250 HP (this depends on the year and exact setup) at 2500rpm.

For the 1FZ... Peak torque is 275 ftlbs at... 3200 rpm!!!! Peak HP is 212 at 4600 rpm


Two very different animals. If you give that 6BT the same gearing as the 1FZ had (needed) it will hate you.

You will be cruising the highway at about 2440RPM to hold 65MPH. WAY WAY past ideal cruising efficiency. Might as well just loosen some connections and let fuel flow out onto the road as you drive. Realistically, not only will you be way way way over peak efficiency range, you will be right on top of your HP. Not where you want to be on the highway. And you will be just short of the 3000RPM "redline".

And there is NO NEED to spin that mill that fast. IF you were to go the other way and add 10 percent to you gearing, you will still be pushing the engine a bit faster than it likes to run and still beyond best efficiency. And it will still have power to spare... like might as well tow a Prius on a trailer as a "lifeboat" because that 6BT with that kind of gearing will not even know it is there.

My recommendation is to install a 3:1 low range, a 10% overdrive high range and keep the 4.11s in the diffs. Even in high range you are gonna have more low end grunt than you ever dreamed of with the 1FZ. In low range you can make all sorts of Big Dog claims and if you can't back them up it will not be the fault of your engine or gearing. 😉

Along with keeping the 6BT in a rpm range that it does not hate, you will get better fuel economy. Probably a LOT better. Diesels hate being pushed out of their happy place. That engine is happy just a little above peak torque (if you could gear it to cruise the highway at 1800 rpm or so, it would kiss you good night and make you breakfast in bed every morning 🥰 ). You will see*slightly* less engine noise. That's a big deal with the Cummins... it AIN'T a 1FZ, remember? :p AND it will still jump up a LOT peppier than the 1FZ ever could. And not redline out at 80mph if you ever need to merge hard or whatever...

The 6BT in a full sized dodge with a 27-30 percent overdrive and tire about the same diameter as your 35s/315s will out pull a FZJ on 275s (32s) with it's puny 17% OD even... in it's sleep.


So... my long winded advice is... wait and see before you make any gearing changes at all. You will likely feel differently once you drive it some. I do not think you will see any gain from shorter gearing, and you will absolutely see gain from taller.


Mark...
 
Last edited:
If you're swapping an NV4500 leave the high side of the tcase alone and run 37s.
I would not argue with that. Personally I prefer an auto in the '80 platform. But that 27 percent overdrive is... wow, what do ya know... 10% more that the A442F . 🤔

That and the 37s would work well behind the cummins... if you wanted a manual.


I have a 1993 GM/Detroit 6.5TD slowly being prepped for installation into a 1997 FZJ80. I also have a late model and already "beefed up" 700R4 (with the 3.05 1st and the 30%OD of course) that will be hooked to the existing Toyota case. I'll be using 3:1 low and 10%OD high and sticking with 315s on this rig. And occasionally 37 inch TSLs for any long (but close-ish to home) trail runs. This rig doesn't see much of anything I would call real rock crawling, but it see's lots of everything else and it is slated to be more of a hard core road tripper as well after the swap.

Mark...
 
It’s a ‘94 Cummins 6BT swapped FZJ80 with 3” lift. It’s on 35” tires. It has ARB front bumper with a Warn winch (synthetic rope) and a ARB rear bumper with a rear tire carrier. It has an ARB drawer system and ARB refrigerator. I plan to use it for touring and moderate rock crawling. I talked it over with AJ and decided that I’m doing the transfer case under-gearing from Sumo.

I did more research and learned that the parts of the drivetrain upstream from where you do the gearing change have less strain on them. Since I’m not making so much power that I’m likely to be twisting drivelines into pretzels I think this approach will achieve my goals of having a final drive ratio that is closer to what it was when it had stock size tires on it while make life easier on the transmission and engine.
As I have thought about this for a moment... Perhaps I should not assume you are keeping the A442F? I assume you know that you will need a stand alone ECU for the tranny if you do so. You will also need a much lower stall speed torque convertor.

Mark...
 
Last edited:
As I have thought about this for a moment... Perhaps I should not assume you are keeping the A442F? I assume you know that you will need a stand alone ECU for the tranny if you do so. You will also need a much lower stall speed torque convertor.

Mark...
That’s all done. The swap was done about 9 yrs ago.
 
Since you say that you "plan" to use it for "touring and moderate rock crawling", I am assuming that the rig is not yet in use with the new power plant. Since you do not indicate otherwise I am also assuming you have the A442F still.

I would encourage your to forego any gearing changes until you have put the rig to use a bit. 35s are only 10% larger that the OEM rubber. The OD of the 442 is only 17%. A 6BT is not a biger heavier 1FZ. It likes lower rpm. It does not particularly like higher rpm. It's efficiency range and it's power range are in much lower bands that the 1FZ.

For the 6BT...peak torque is between 400 and 440 ftlbs at 1500-1600 rpm. Peak horsepower is between 160 and 250 HP (this depends on the year and exact setup) at 2500rpm.

For the 1FZ... Peak torque is 275 ftlbs at... 3200 rpm!!!! Peak HP is 212 at 4600 rpm


Two very different animals. If you give that 6BT the same gearing as the 1FZ had (needed) it will hate you.

You will be cruising the highway at about 2440RPM to hold 65MPH. WAY WAY past ideal cruising efficiency. Might as well just loosen some connections and let fuel flow out onto the road as you drive. Realistically, not only will you be way way way over peak efficiency range, you will be right on top of your HP. Not where you want to be on the highway. And you will be just short of the 3000RPM "redline".

And there is NO NEED to spin that mill that fast. IF you were to go the other way and add 10 percent to you gearing, you will still be pushing the engine a bit faster than it likes to run and still beyond best efficiency. And it will still have power to spare... like might as well tow a Prius on a trailer as a "lifeboat" because that 6BT with that kind of gearing will not even know it is there.

My recommendation is to install a 3:1 low range, a 10% overdrive high range and keep the 4.11s in the diffs. Even in high range you are gonna have more low end grunt than you ever dreamed of with the 1FZ. In low range you can make all sorts of Big Dog claims and if you can't back them up it will not be the fault of your engine or gearing. 😉

Along with keeping the 6BT in a rpm range that it does not hate, you will get better fuel economy. Probably a LOT better. Diesels hate being pushed out of their happy place. That engine is happy just a little above peak torque (if you could gear it to cruise the highway at 1800 rpm or so, it would kiss you good night and make you breakfast in bed every morning 🥰 ). You will see*slightly* less engine noise. That's a big deal with the Cummins... it AIN'T a 1FZ, remember? :p AND it will still jump up a LOT peppier than the 1FZ ever could. And not redline out at 80mph if you ever need to merge hard or whatever...

The 6BT in a full sized dodge with a 27-30 percent overdrive and tire about the same diameter as your 35s/315s will out pull a FZJ on 275s (32s) with it's puny 17% OD even... in it's sleep.


So... my long winded advice is... wait and see before you make any gearing changes at all. You will likely feel differently once you drive it some. I do not think you will see any gain from shorter gearing, and you will absolutely see gain from taller.


Mark...
I just purchased the truck and drove it 2100+ miles from Washington to Texas with its current setup. My 1FZ-FE is waayyyy quicker and pulls hills much better with its 4.88s and 35” tires than the 6BT did with its 4.10s and 35” tires. The trip provided me with plenty of opportunity to become familiar with the 6BT’s behavior and I’ve had my 1FZ-FE truck for over ten years. For the places where I will be using it the most, I think the swap will work well.
 
I have not spent nearly the amount of time with any of the diesels as I have with the Toyota engines. Very little of that Toyota time has been with the various diesels with "our brand" on them. I do have a little bit of drive time with all of them under my belt. Older and newer Toyota diesels, the Mercedes diesels that are found in the Bandeirantes, and of course Power Strokes, Cummins and GM/Detroits. Not an expert on any of them. I have towed a few times with Power Strokes. Car trailers with 40s, 60s or 80s loaded on them. Through mild-ish hills mountains and flat ground highways. Usually could hardly even tell I had a load behind me. The Cummins (plural) I towed with seemed even stronger. Towed a heavily loaded car trailer from Seattle to Anchorage years ago in the middle of winter with a Cummins. I knew there was a laod back there... but mainly when I had to brake. ;) I have towed a lot with the much maligned GM 6.2. Mine has been fitted with a Banks turbo kit. NO OTHER mods to the engine. High speed highways, long steep mountain passes (to be fair, NOT Colorado high altitude passes), back roads, in the city... pretty much all over. 75MPH up Turnagain pass, and various similar climbs in the Steese mountains with hardly a second thought. Passing my buddies going up Caribou Creek Hill just for laughs. Getting 18 to 22 mpg towing 24-28MPG when unfettered in a beat to s*** old school 3/4 ton suburban. Done a little of that with a GM6.5TD in a 4x4 1 ton creww cab too. Considering what the diesel guys all have to say about those older GMs, that is an impressive little oil burner. (As I think about it ALL of these rigs I have mentioned here are 4x4. Which is irrelavent beyond MPG numbers really.)

And I have done most of those deeds with a, FZJ80 as well. The '80 did pretty darn well! For what it is. If you compare them all objectively however... it is a bit like a peewee football player sneaking on the field during a raiders/Steelers game. There is NO 75 MPH involved when towing a car trailer through any mountain pass with a 1FZ. unless you are headed DOWN the pass. And we won't even talk about the MPG numbers.

Based on your comments about your Cummins equipped '80 versus your 1FZ rig, I THINK you came here with the wrong question. In my opinion, you should be asking... "What is wrong with my Cummins?" Maybe I am over impressed with what my experience has led me to believe. But your experience seems 180* off from mine. Consider this though. Why would anyone swap that loud, rough, HEAVY powerplant into an '80 if what you have experienced was the norm? We'd all be swapping 1FZs into our one tons!!!

Either you have God's own 1FZ... or something ain't right with that sissy little Cummins conversion! :hungover:


The torque converter might be a factor too. The OEM unit has a stall speed of 2100 RPM. Much to high for the Cummins. The Cummins peak torque is at 1500-1600 RPM. Even peak HP is down at 2500 RPM.
The torque converter is supposed to lock in OD of course, but even if it is doing so as designed (no guarantee of that in it's new tasking), until it does lock you are turning lots and lots and lots of your power into heat as you churn fluid for no reason. At low engine speeds where the Cummins shines, it is gonna be worst.


What are you doing about controlling the tranny? Do you have a stand alone ECU installed? Even if it is working perfectly, the converter only locks when the tranny tells it to. There are other factors in terms of tranny "control" that come into play too.


Okay... all done with my LONG WINDED approach to suggesting that there seems to be a problem with what your engine is delivering for you.

Mark...
 
There is nothing at all wrong with what my engine is delivering. I had a GM 6.2l diesel in my Snap/On tool truck in 1983. It sucked. I had a 7.3l Powerstroke in an F-350 crew cab that was completely underwhelming until I used an adjustable tuner in combination with an AFE intake and 4” exhaust to wake it up. That motor was great. The 6BT was too aft for my driving style as it sat when I bought the truck. I decided to go with the Sumo 10% underdrive high range and 3.3:1 low range. It’s exactly what I hoped it would be like. With the tires I have on it and the axle ratios in the truck I puts it in the meat of its powered range on the freeway running between about 60 and 80 mph. In low range I can just allow it to idle across flat ground and when it’s time to crawl a hill I have excellent wheel speed control. I’m very happy with the changes.
 
Back
Top Bottom