whoever gets the brown inner door panel - if you have an old panel with the rubber strip that is part of the panel, which runs along the bottom of the inside of the window, i believe it is stapled to the panel - please PM me if you wind up with an extra off of your old panel. i think / guess it can be separated from the panel?
I believe you are right... I have the same problem on my 62 the person who owned it prior removed the upper portion and spray painted it... I ordered new door panels and am going to try to separate the rubber portion since milo wer panels are in better condition then the ones I purchased. Here is a pic of what it looks like under the top portion... I'll keep you posted on what happens.
Jen
edit: IF that rubber piece can be removed from the panel, i guess it does not matter which color panel i derive a replacement from! Thanks,